تحلیل استنادناپذیری از منظر کارایی اقتصادی

دانشنامه حقوق اقتصادی

دوره 30، شماره 23، شهریور 1402، صفحه 81-94   

نوع مقاله: علمی پژوهشی

شناسه دیجیتال (DOI): 10.22067/economlaw.2023.81583.1261

نویسندگان

مهسا رباطی¹؛ رحیم پیلوار^{* 2}؛ حسین جاور³

¹دانشجوی دکتری حقوق خصوصی ، دانشکده حقوق، دانشگاه تهران (پردیس فارابی)، قم، ایران

²استادیار گروه حقوق خصوصی، دانشکده حقوق، دانشگاه تهران (پردیس فارابی)، قم، ایران

³دانشیار گروه حقوق خصوصی، دانشکده حقوق، دانشگاه تهران (پردیس فارابی)، قم، ایران

چکیده

استنادناپذیری ضمانت‌اجرایی است که از حقوق فرانسه به حقوق ایران راه یافته و مصادیقی را در قانون، رویه قضایی و دکترین حقوقی ایران به خود اختصاص داده است. جریان این ضمانت‌اجرا در جایی است که قواعد حامی حقوق اشخاص ثالث، مانند لزوم ثبت و انتشار یا رعایت شکل و... در ایجاد عناصر حقوقی همچون قرارداد، از سوی اشخاص دخیل مانند طرفین قرارداد رعایت نشود. این ضمانت‌اجرا در حقوق ایران در عرض ضمانت‌اجراها و وضعیت‌های حقوقی چون بطلان، عدم نفوذ و مراعی قرار می‌گیرد و این پرسش را ایجاد می‌کند که کارآمدی ضمانت‌اجراها و وضعیت‌های حقوقی پیش‌گفته برای عدم رعایت قواعد حامی حقوق اشخاص ثالث در مقایسه با استنادناپذیری به چه میزان است و آیا با وجود آن‌ها، نیاز به اقتباس استنادناپذیری از حقوق فرانسه هست؟ از آن‌جایی که کارایی، مفهومی اساسی در علم اقتصاد است که معیارهای متعددی برای ارزیابی آن ارائه شده، این پژوهش با استفاده از معیارهای ارزیابی کارایی در علم اقتصاد، استنادناپذیری را در مقایسه با دیگر ضمانت‌اجراها و وضعیت‌های حقوقی موجود در حقوق ایران، توصیف و تحلیل اقتصادی می‌نماید.
این پژوهش نتیجه می‌گیرد که نسبت به وضعیت عدم رعایت قواعد حامی حقوق اشخاص ثالث، استنادناپذیری، در مقایسه با دیگر ضمانت‌اجراها و وضعیت‌های حقوقی موجود در حقوق ایران، بر اساس معیار کارایی پارتویی و کالدور-هیکس دارای کارآمدی اقتصادی است.

کلیدواژه‌ها

استنادناپذیری؛ عدم قابلیت استناد؛ تحلیل اقتصادی حقوق؛ کارایی اقتصادی؛ ضمانت اجرا

مراجع

 

References

• Abdali, Mehrzad. (2010). The Place of Ethics in Economic Analysis of Law, Journal of Comparative Law, 19(85). pp. 101-126. (In Persian).
• Aghaei Thogh, Moslem (2014). Analysis of ‘Economic Analysis of Law’, Comparative Law Review, 4(2). pp. 1-17. (In Persian).
• Babaei, Iraj. (2016). Theoretical foundations of the economic analysis approach of law, Law and Policy Research, 9(23). pp. 59-13. (In Persian).
• Badini, Hassan. (2003). Philosophical foundations of the economic approach to law, Journal of the Faculty of Law and Political Sciences of Tehran University, No. 62, pp. 136-91. (In Persian).
• Becker, Gary S. (1993). Nobel Lecture: The Economic Way of Looking at Behavior, The Journal of Political Economy, 101(3). pp. 385-409.
• Bolurifar, Mina, Hagi Azezi, Bijen & Jafari, Fazlullah. (2018) The Application of Economic Analysis of Law Based on Rational Independence and Expediency, Contemporary Legal Studies Journal (CLSJ). 10(18). pp. 1-23. (In Persian).
• Calabresi, Guido and Melamed, A. Douglas. (2013). Property Rules, Liability Rules, and Inalienability (Economic Analysis of Laws). translated by Saeedeh Mazinanian and Khashayar Esfandiarifar, Tehran: Noor Elam Publishing. (In Persian).
• Coase, Ronald. (1960). The Problem of Social Cost, Journal of Law and Economics, pp.2-144.
• Cooter, Robert & Ulen, Thomas. (2011). Law and Economics, 6 ed., Boston: Pearson Education.
• Cornu, Gérard. (1992). Vocabulaire juridique, 3 éd., Paris, Presses universitaires de France.
• Dadgar, Yadalallah. (2013). Principles of micro and macro economic analysis, Tehran: Amareh Publishing. (In Persian).
• Dadgar, Yadalallah and Rahmani, Timur. (2013). Basics and Principles of Economics, ed. 13, Qom: Bostan Kitab Institute. (In Persian).
• Deffains, Bruno & Kirat, Thierry. (2001). Law and Economics in Civil Law Countries, Elsevier Science.
• Delmas Saint-Hilaire, Philippe. (2000). Le tiers à l’acte juridique, Paris: L.G.D.J.
• Demogue, René. (1933). Traité des obligations en général, T.7, Partie 2, Paris, Rousseau.
• Duclos, José. (1984). L'opposabilité: essai d'une théorie générale. Paris: Librairie générale de droit et de jurisprudence.
• Eshraghi Araei, Mojtaba. (2014). Economic and Legal Analysis of Anticipatory Breach, Iraninan Jouornal of Trade Studies (IJTS). 18(69). pp. 59-82. (In Persian).
• Friedman, David D. (2000). Law’s order : what economics has to do with law and why it matters, Princeton University Press.
• Ghabouli Dorafshan, Seyyed Mohammad Mahdi & Mohseni, Saeed. (2011). The general theory of nullity in contracts (a comparative study in the legal system of Iran and France). Tehran: Jungle. (In Persian).
• Habibi, Behnam. (2003). Economic analysis of private Law, Tehran: Majd. (In Persian).
• Hicks, J. R. (1939). The Foundations of Welfare Economics, The Economic Journal, 49(196). pp. 696-712.
• Iranpour, Farhad. (2018). foundations and application of economic analysis in private law (behavioral and functionalist approach to the foundations of private law). Tehran: The World of Economy Publications. (In Persian).
• Issaei Tafreshi, Mohammad, Abdali, Mehrzad. (2012). The Approaches of the Protection of Contracts in the Economic Analysis of Law (A Comparative Study in Iranian and French Law). Comparative law Research Quarterly, 16(2). pp. 151-173. (In Persian).
• Jafari Langroudi, Mohammad Jaafar. (1991). Civil rights: mortgages and compromises. Tehran: Ganje Danesh Publications. (In Persian).
• Kaldor, Nicholas. (1939). Welfare Propositions of Economics and Interpersonal Comparisons of Utility, The Economic Journal, 49(195). pp. 549-552.
• Kaoplw, Louis & Shavell, Steven. (2002). Economic Analysis of Law, in Handbook of Public Economics, Edited by A.J Auerbach and M. Feldstein, V.3, Chapter 25, Elsevier Science.
• Karimi, abbas. (2012). Essay to organize the theory of ineffectiveness of Mora’a, Judicial Law Views, No.58, pp. 156-188.
• Katouzian, Nasser. (1997). Nominate contracts, V. 1, 6 ed., Tehran: EntesharCo. (In Persian).
• Katouzian, Nasser. (2000). Civil Law, general rules of contracts. V.2., 5 ed., Tehran: EntesharCo. (In Persian).
• Kerkmeester, Heico. (2000). Methodology: general, Encyclopedia of law and economics, V.I., the history and methodology of law and economics, Cheltenham: Edward Elgar, pp. 383-401
• Khodabakhshi, Abdollah. (2010). Another Interpretation of Article 22 of Registration of Documents and Real Properties Act, The Judiciany Law Journal, 74(71). pp. 9-39. (In Persian).
• Lord Robbins, L. (1932). An Essay on the Nature and Significance of Economics, London: Macmillan.
• Miceli, Thomas J. (2004). The Economic Approach to Law, California, Stanford: Stanford University Press.
• Mohaghegh Damad, Sayyed Mostafa, Qanavati, Jalil, Vahdati Shobairi, Sayyed Hasan and Abdipour, Ebrahim. (2009). Law of Contract According to Imamieh Jurisprudence. V.2, Tehran: SAMT. (In Persian).
• Mohaghegh Damad, Seyyed Mostafa, Ghabouli Dorafshan, Seyyed Mohammad Mahdi and Saatchi, Ali. (2014). Analysis of the legal status of customer transactions regarding to pre-emption’s subject, Civil Jurisprudence Doctrines, Razavi University of Islamic Sciences, 7(11). pp. 21-3. (In Persian).
• Mohseni, Saeed. (2011). Mistake in the Party to the contract (with comparative study in Iranian and French Law). Tehran: Imam Sadiq University (peace be upon him). (In Persian).
• Mohseni, Saeed & Ghobuli Dorafshan, Seyyed Mohammad Mahdi. (2010). The concept and effects of relative nullity. Journal of Knowledge and Development, 17(33). pp. 245-271. (In Persian).
• Naeemi, Seyyed Morteza. (2021). An Interdouction to the Approach of Economic Analysis of Law, 2 ed., Tehran: Mizan Publishing. (In Persian).
• Nguyen Xuan, Chanh. (1977). De l'application de la notion d'inopposabilite en droit commercial, Sous la direction de Jean Stoufflet, thèse de Doctorat D'ETAT: Droit privé: Clermont Ferrand 1, France, S.l.: s.n.
• Posner, Richard. (1999). Consequentialism, In book: introdution to the philosophy of Law, Readings & Cases, Problems of jurisprudence, reading 2, edited by jeferson White & Dennis Patterson, Oxford University Press.
• Robati, Mahsa, Mohseni, Saeed and Ghabouli Dorafshan, Seyyed Mohammad Mahdi. (2016). "non-opposability of nullity in commercial companies", Journal of Legal Studies, 9(4). pp. 117-140. (In Persian).
• Samuelson, Paul A. & Nordhaus,William D. (2009). Economics, 19 ed., New York: McGraw-Hill.
• Shahidi, Mahdi. (1996). Collection of Legal Articles, 1 ed., Tehran: Jurist (In Persian).
• Shami Aghdam, Shahin. (2008). Economic analysis of the sanctions of contractual obligations in Iranian law, Master’s thesis in economic law, Allameh Tabatabai University, Faculty of Law and Political Sciences, under the supervision of Dr. Iraj Babaei. (In Persian).
• Shapiro, Scott & McClennen, Edward F. (1998). Law-and-economics from a philosophical perspective, in book: The New Palgrave Dictionary of Economics and the Law, V.2, London: MacMillan Reference Ltd., pp. 65-460.
• Shavell, Steven. (2004). Foundations of economic analysis of law, Harvard University Press.
• Shiravi, Abdolhossein. (2021). Economic Law, 2 ed., Tehran: SAMT. (In Persian).
• Stelmach, Jerzy and Bartosz Brozek. (2005). Methods of Legal Reasoning, Dordrecht: Springer.
• Tabatabai Hessari, Nasreen. (2014). Economic Functions of Official Real Estate Registration in the Light of the Doctrine of Economic Efficiency, Legal Research Quarterly, 18(72). pp. 311-336. (In Persian).
• Terré, François, Simler, Philippe et Lequette, Yves. (1996). Droit civil: les obligations, 6 éd., Paris: Dalloz.
• Tousi, Abbas. (2013). Law and Economy Methodology, Legal Research Quarterly, Special Issue, No. 4, pp. 251-277. (In Persian).
• Wacks, Raymond. (2006). Philosophy of Law: A Very Short Introduction, New York: Oxford University Press.
• Wintgen, Robert. (2004). Étude critique de la notion d'opposabilité: les effets du contrat à l'égard des tiers en droit français et allemand. Paris: LGDJ.
• Yasrebi, Seyed Ali Mohammad & Rezapoor Akerdi, Mohammadali. (2018). The Choice Between The Owner or Possessor; Economic Analysis of the Land Registration System (Record and Register System) in Common Law with a View to Article 22 of the Law of Deed and Real Estate Registration, Private Law Studies Quarterly, 48(2). pp. 343-362. (In Persian).
• Zerbe, Richard O. (2001). Economic efficiency in law and economics, Massachusetts: Edward Elgar Publishing.
• Zoghi, Saeed. (2015). Getting to know the basics of economic analysis of law, Legal Discourse Quarterly, 13(30). pp. 35-62. (In Persian).