حکمرانی چندسطحی؛ بستری برای توسعه دیپلماسی شهری

پژوهش ‎های جغرافیای سیاسی

مقاله 6، دوره 9، شماره 1 - شماره پیاپی 33، فروردین 1403، صفحه 110-130   

نوع مقاله: مقالات علمی -پژوهشی

شناسه دیجیتال (DOI): 10.22067/pg.2024.27105.0

نویسندگان

حسین کشیری¹؛ حمیدرضا شیرزاد^{* 2}؛ گارینه کشیشیان سیرکی³؛ حسن خداوردی³

¹دانشجوی دکتری روابط بین‎الملل، واحد بین‏المللی کیش، دانشگاه آزاد اسلامی، جزیره کیش، ایران

²استادیار اقتصادسیاسی، گروه علوم سیاسی و روابط بین‎الملل، واحد تهران مرکز، دانشگاه آزاد اسلامی، تهران، ایران.

³استادیار اقتصادسیاسی، گروه علوم‎سیاسی و روابط بین‎الملل، واحد تهران جنوب، دانشگاه آزاد اسلامی، تهران، ایران

چکیده

حکمرانی چندسطحی مفهومی ذاتا پویا است و به نقض مفروضات ثابت درباره ویژگی‏های اساسی تصمیم‎گیری‏های مقتدرانه دولت‏ها اشاره دارد. ارجاع به حکمرانی چند سطحی، نیروی قدرتمندی در ارزیابی عملکرد دولت در روابط بین‎الملل است که حکمرانی چندسطحی می‏تواند از طریق مکانیزم‏هایی به بین‎المللی شدن شهرها کمک نماید. این جریان زمینه ساز توسعه دیپلماسی‎شهری می‏گردد. لذا تبیین مکانیزم‏های منتج از حکمرانی چندسطحی که منجر به توسعه دیپلماسی‎شهری می‏شوند، هدف این تحقیق می‏باشد. روش تحقیق کیفی است و داده‏ها از طریق منابع ثانویه گردآوری شدند. برای جمع آوری مقالات خارجی پایگاه Web of Science استفاد شد و مقالات بر مبنای جستجوی 4 کلیدواژه و 5 معیار، انتخاب شدند. پس از حذف موارد تکراری، 41 مقاله خارجی باقی ماند. جستجوی مقالات داخلی بر اساس 2 کلیدواژه و در میان 2 گروه تخصصی، در پایگاه SID انجام شد و 2 مقاله انتخاب شدند. در مجموع 43 مقاله به‎طورکامل مطالعه و به روش تحلیل محتوا، تحلیل گردیدند. نتایج نشان داد که 21 مکانیزم منتج از حکمرانی چندسطحی شناسایی شدند که‏این مکانیزم‏ها منجر به توسعه دیپلماسی‎شهری می‏شوند از جمله ترویج تصمیم‎گیری مشارکتی در سیاستگذاری‏ها، شبکه‎سازی بین‎شهری و ظهور شبکه‏های فراملی، بکارگیری بازیگران اجتماعی در فرآیند اجرا و انعقاد قراردادهای همکاری فرامرزی و تفاهم‎نامه‏های خواهرخواندگی. این مکانیزم‏ها در سه بعد سیاستگذاری‏های حاکمیتی و کلان، شبکه‎سازی بین‎المللی و حوزه اجرایی و عملیاتی تقسیم‎بندی شدند که به ترتیب هر کدام شامل 11، 5 و 5 مکانیزم هستند. همچنین ارتباط مکانیزم‏های هر بعد با دیپلماسی‎شهری ارزیابی گردید.

کلیدواژه‌ها

حکمرانی چند سطحی؛ دیپلماسی شهری؛ مکانیزم

مراجع

1. Acuto, M., Morissette, M., & Tsouros, A., (2016). City diplomacy: Towards more strategic networking? Learning with WHO healthy cities. Global Policy, 8(1): 14-22.
2. Acuto, M., Decramer, H., Kerr, J., Klaus, I., Tabory, S., & Toly, N., (2018). Toward city diplomacy: Assessing capacity in select global cities. Chicago Council on Global Affairs.
3. Amiri, M., Khalili, A., & Mofidi Shemirani, S. M., (2022). Conceptual explanation and presentation of urban diplomacy model in urban networks. Journal of Geographic Urban Planning Research, 4(10): 135-158 [In Persian]
4. Amoretti, U. M. and Bermeo, N. (2004). Federalism and territorial cleavages. Baltimore: John Hopkins University Press.
5. Alcantara, C., Broschek, J., & Nelles, J., (2015). Rethinking multilevel governance as an instance of multilevel politics: A conceptual strategy. Territory, politics, governance, 4(1): 33-51.
6. Asadi, R., (2021). Preparing Urban Diplomacy Strategies in Mashhad with an Emphasis on Islamic Countries. Journal of Geography and Urban Space Development, 7 (2): 105-123 [In Persian]
7. Bache, I., & Flinders, M., (Eds.). (2004). Multi-level governance. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
8. Bache, I., & Flinders, M., (eds). (2015). Multi-level Governance: Essential Readings. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar.
9. Bagheri, H., Ibn Al-Ridha, S. M., & Sahraei, F., (2016). Identifying Strategies for Economic Globalization in the Field of City Diplomacy: A Case Study of Tehran Metropolis. Journal of Urban Economics and Management, 4(4): 87-106 [In Persian]
10. Basirat, M., & Jalili, S.M., (2014). Analysis of Opportunities and Challenges of Development of City Diplomacy in Tehran Metropolis. Journal of Fine Arts, 19(3): 53-66 [In Persian]
11. Beidollahkhani, A., & Hosseini, S.M., (2021). International Non-Governmental Organizations and Tehran’s Path to Becoming a Global City. Journal of Politics, 51(3): 639-667 [In Persian]
12. Brancati, D., (2008). The origins and strengths of regional parties. British journal of political science, 38(1): 135-159.
13. Bulkeley, H., Davies, A., Evans, B., Gibbs, D., Kern, K., & Theobald, K., (2003). Environmental governance and transnational municipal networks in Europe. Journal of Environmental Policy & Planning, 5(3), 235-254.
14. Budd, L., & Sancino, A., (2016). A framework for city leadership in multilevel governance settings: The comparative contexts of Italy and the UK. Regional Studies, Regional Science, 3(1): 129-145.
15. Castells, M., (2001). The Information Age: Economy, Society and Culture, the Power of Identity. Tehran: Tarh-e-No Publication [In Persian]
16. Dale, A., Burch, S., Robinson, J., & Strashok, C., (2018). Multilevel governance of sustainability transitions in Canada: policy alignment, innovation, and evaluation. Climate change in cities: Innovations in multi-level governance, 343-358.
17. Dehshiri, M.R., (2014). Para-diplomacy in Globalization Era: A case Study of Urban Diplomacy. Journal of Strategic Studies of Public Policy, 4 (13): 34-54 [In Persian]
18. Di Gregorio, M., Fatorelli, L., Paavola, J., Locatelli, B., Pramova, E., Nurrochmat, D. R., & Kusumadewi, S.D., (2019). Multi-level governance and power in climate change policy networks. Global environmental change, 54, 64-77.
19. Enderlein, H., Walti, S., & Zurn, M., (Eds.). (2010). Handbook on multi-level governance. Edward Elgar Publishing.
20. Faraji, A., Babaee, H. R., & Rashedi, A., (2021). Analysis of Urban Diplomacy and Development in the Space of Flows by Study on Tehran City. Urban Sustainable Development Journal, 2 (2): 29-44 [In Persian]
21. Fenton, P., & Gustafsson, S., (2017). Moving from high-level words to local action—governance for urban sustainability in municipalities. Current opinion in environmental sustainability, 26(2): 129-133.
22. Goodarzi, M., & Sabagh Kalateh Hosseini, E., (2017). The Relationship between the City and Diplomacy in the Era of Globalization. Journal of Strategic Studies of Public Policy, 7(23): 61-71 [In Persian]
23. Ghourchi, M., Razavian, M.T., & Dastvareh, F., (2022). City Diplomacy and Its Legal Position at the Scale of Local Governments. Journal of Human Environment Studies, 1(2): 51-71 [In Persian]
24. Gholipour, Y., Ahmadi Pour, A., Asghari Abkenar, A., & Falah Heydari, F., (2018). The Role of Sister Cities in City Diplomacy Development. In the First Conference on Competitiveness and Future of Urban Transformations, Tehran [In Persian]
25. Gualini, E., (2003). Challenges to multi-level governance: contradictions and conflicts in the Europeanization of Italian regional policy. Journal of European Public Policy, 10(4): 616-636.
26. Hataminajad, H., & Mehdi, A., (2010). Investigating the Sister City Relationships in Relation to Globalization Concepts. Municipalities Journal, 100(11): 1-6 [In Persian]
27. Hawkins, C.V., Kwon, S. W., & Bae, J., (2016). Balance between local economic development and environmental sustainability: A multi-level governance perspective. International journal of public administration, 39(11): 803-811.
28. Hooghe, L., & Marks, G., (2001) Multi-level Governance and European Integration. Lanham, MD/Oxford: Rowman & Littlefield.
29. Hooghe, L., & Marks, G., (2003). Unraveling the Central State, But How? Types of Multi-Level Governance. IHS Political Science Series: 2003, No. 87.
30. Hooghe, L., Marks, G., (2010). Types of multi-level governance. In: H. Enderlein, S., Wälti, Zürn, M., (eds.) Types of Multilevel Governance. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar.
31. Jerrems, A. (2020). Theorising International Urban Politics. Millennium: Journal of International Studies, 1-12.
32. Leijten, J., (2019). Innovation policy and international relations: directions for EU diplomacy. European Journal of Futures Research, 7(1): 1-21.
33. Maggetti, M., & Trein, P., (2018). Multilevel governance and problem‐solving: Towards a dynamic theory of multilevel policy‐making?. Public Administration, 97(2): 355-369.
34. Marks, G., Hooghe, L., & Blank, K., (1996). European integration from the 1980s: State‐centric v. multi‐level governance. JCMS: Journal of Common Market Studies, 34(3): 341-378.
35. Mohammadian, A., & Rezaei, A., (2016). The Evolution of the Concept of Diplomacy in International Relations. Iranian Research Letter of International Politics, 1(5): 105-127 [In Persian]
36. Muluk, M. K., Indaswari, F.V., Wiswayana, W.M., & Yunita, P., (2022). The Role of City Diplomacy for Sustainable Environment: Study Case of River Restoration in Bandung. KnE Social Sciences, 690-707.
37. Myers, M.D., (2015). Qualitative Research in Business and Management. (Anabestani et al., Trans.). Mashhad: Behnashr Publication [In Persian]
38. Nejati Hosseini, S.M., (2010). Urban Citizenship: From Theory to Urban Policy and Cultural Experience. Encyclopedia of Social Sciences (Journal of Historical Sociology), Tarbiat Modares University [In Persian]
39. Nejati Hosseini, S.M., (2011). Urban Politics and Urban Diplomacy: From Theory to Experience. Journal of Historical Sociology, 2(3): 117-142 [In Persian]
40. ÖZCAN, B.A., (2023). The City Diplomacy and Istanbul's Capacity for City Diplomacy. Kent Akademisi, 16(3): 1930-1945.
41. Piattoni, S., (2009). Multi‐level governance: a historical and conceptual analysis. European integration, 31(2): 163-180.
42. Peters, B.G., & Pierre, J., (2004). Multi-level governance and democracy: A Faustian bargain? In I. Bache & M. Flinders (eds), Multilevel governance. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
43. Pierre, J., (2013). Globalization and governance. Cheltenham, England: Edward Elgar.
44. Pierre, J., (2017). Multilevel governance as a strategy to build capacity in cities: Evidence from Sweden. Journal of Urban Affairs, 41(1): 1-15.
45. Portuguese Presidency (2007) First Action Programe adopted under the EU Presidency of Portugal http://www.eu-territorial-agenda.eu/Reference%20Documents/AP%201%20Anexo.pdf.
46. Ranjkesh, M.J., & Geramian, S.S., (2022). Mashhad City Diplomatic Potential and its Impact on Iran’s Role in Geopolitics of the ECO Region. Scientific Journal on Culture of Diplomacy Studies, 1 (1): 93-117 [In Persian]
47. Saeed, P., Hafeznia, M.R., & Ghourchi, M., (2022). The Role of City Diplomacy in International Relations of Cities: A Case Study of Tehran's Urban Management System. Journal of Sustainable Development of Geographical Environmental, 6(4)6: 16-30 [In Persian]
48. Saremi, H.R., Farhadimanesh, N., & Khatami, S.M., (2021). Governance Structure in Iran Based on Multilevel Governance Theory. Journal of Urban Management Studies, 48(13)48: 13-27 [In Persian]
49. Saramad, Z., Bazaragan, A., & Hajazi, E., (2012). Research Methods in Behavioral Sciences. Tehran: Agah Publishing [In Persian]
50. Sarrafi, M., & Nejati, N., (2017). Multilevel governance of the metropolitan region: applying new regionalism approach (Case study: metropolitan region of Mashhad). Hoviatshahr (City Identity) Journal, 31(11): 31-42 [In Persian]
51. Skelcher, C., (2005). Jurisdictional integrity, polycentrism, and the design of democratic governance. Governance, 18(1): 89-110.
52. Stephenson, P., (2013). Twenty years of multi-level governance: ‘Where does it come from? What is it? Where is it going?’. Journal of European Public Policy, 20(6): 817-837.
53. Stilwell, F., & Troy, P., (2000). Multilevel governance and urban development in Australia. Urban Studies, 37(5-6): 909-930.
54. Tamizkar Mostaghim, M., & Abbasi, B., (2016). The posed popular political participation challenges to the political system of the Ialamic Republic of Iran. Quarterly Journal of Political Science, 8(29): 151-180
55. Tohidfam, M., & Dalili, Sh., (2016). Globalization of Cities and Localization of Diplomacy: A Case Study of Urban Diplomacy. Journal of Politics, 2(46): 303-321 [In Persian]
56. Tohidfam, M. & Taheranizadeh, N., (2009). Neoliberalism and Globalization. Journal of Law and Politics, 11(3): 65-86 [In Persian]
57. Tortola, P. D. (2016). Clarifying multilevel governance. European Journal of Political Research, 56(2): 234-250.
58. Trein, P., Thomann, E., & Maggetti, M., (2019). Integration, functional differentiation and problem‐solving in multilevel governance. Public Administration, 97(2): 339-354.
59. Wu, D. Y. (2020). City diplomacy, multilateral networks and the role of Southeast Asia. Global Strategis, 14(1), 17-30.
60. Zahrani, M. & Rajaei, A., (2020). International Cooperation Opportunities with a Focus on Sister Cities. Journal of Knowledge of Political Interpretation, 3(2): 1-24 [In Persian]
61. Zarghampour Boyerahmadi Ahmadi, A.M., Bigdelirad, V., & Khatibi, M., (2021). Codification of a model for the development of urban diplomacy with regard to globalization capacities (Case study: Tehran). Quarterly of Geography and Regional Planning, 3(11)3: 520-534 [In Persian]
62. Zarghani, S.H., & Eskandaran, M., (2012). Global Cities in City Diplomacy and City Geopolitics. Proceedings of the fifth Congress of the Iranian Geopolitics Association [In Persian]
63. Zarghani, S.H., & Eskandaran, M., (2014). The Role and Position of Urban Diplomacy in Good Urban Governance. Proceedings of the seventh Congress of the Iranian Geopolitics Association, February 17-18 [In Persian]
64. Zarghani, S.H., Ranjakesh, M.J., & Eskandaran, M., (2014). City Diplomacy: Analyzing the Role of Cities as New Actors in International Relations. Urban Regional Studies and Research, 20(5): 163-182 [In Persian]