Investigating the Effect of Tribal Culture on Electoral Behavior of Villagers in Dena County

پژوهش ‎های جغرافیای سیاسی

Article 2, Volume 3, Issue 1 - Serial Number 11, April 2018, Pages 27-66   

Document Type: مقالات علمی -پژوهشی

DOI: 10.22067/pg.v3i11.76500

Authors

Ali Bagheri Dolatabadi^{* 1}; Mohammad Mojahedzadeh²; Farzad Akbari³; Seyed Asghar Bagherinejad²

¹Yasouj University

²Yazd University

³University of Isfahan

Abstract

Extended Abstract

Introduction

Dena County in Kohgiluyeh and Boyer Ahmad province is one of the areas in Iran with more than 83% of its population with tribal culture living in villages. The dominance of this culture has led to a certain type of electoral behavior in this county. Although the electoral behavior can be judged as the highest political participation, it can hardly be considered as a symbol of political development. What is the impact of tribal culture and tribal elites on the electoral behavior of the villagers in Dena County is the main question of the present research. In order to answer this question, the impact of tribal culture on people's electoral behavior must be examined. The same question can be formulated in two research hypotheses: "there is a meaningful relationship between tribal culture and villagers' electoral behavior" and ''there is a meaningful relationship between the political viewpoints of the tribal elites and the electoral behavior of the villagers".

Review of Literature

In reviewing the research literature, two categories of research projects can be mentioned. The first is the books and articles dealing with the geography of elections, and the second is the works that have attempted to analyze the relationship between tribalism and elections in Iran. The first and most prominent work in the first category is the book of “Geography of Election” by Johnston and Taylor (1979). Johnson, in another work with Pattie (2006), tried to show how geographical boundaries as an electoral context could affect the composition and political functions of government in Britain. In Iranian works, Kaviani Rad has attempted to study the impact of geography on Iran's elections. He has authored two books entitled Geography of Elections: Emphasizing on the Presidential Elections (2013) and Geography of Elections: Foundations, Approaches, and Concepts (2018). He has also published articles in this field (2007, 2009). The second group of works related to tribalism - which are closer to the subject of the present study - are the works of Yeganeh and Hasanvand (2013), Pooran Asl (2013), Safari (2010) and Rameshk (2003).

Method

The present research employes an analytical and survey method. The statistical community of this research consisted of the villagers of Dena County. The method of data collection was simple random sampling that was determined using Cochran formula. A sample of 250 people was analyzed using SPSS, 21. The tool used in this study was a 37-item questionnaire (19 questions about tribal culture, 11 questions on electoral behavior, and 7 questions about the impact of the political views of the tribal elites) that measured three areas of tribal culture, tribal elite, and electoral behavior. Cronbach's alpha was used to assess the validity of the instrument.

Findings and Discussion

Findings of the research show that: 1. There was no significant difference between tribal culture and gender-based electoral behavior of the subjects; 2. Education did not affect the relationship between the variables of the study; 3. Marital status of the subjects affected almost equally the electoral behavior of the subjects; 4. Employment had no significant effect on the electoral behavior of the subjects; 5. People's income had no effect on their electoral behavior; 6. There was a significant and an inverse relationship between tribal culture and electoral behavior of the subjects. Also, there was a significant and an inverse relationship between tribal elites’ political viewpoint and the electoral behavior of the voters. The feeling of deprivation among the voters in villages in comparison with the urban voters or a tribe over the other tribes and the existence of traditional culture among them has played an effective role in the continuation of this condition.

Conclusion

The electoral behavior of the people of Dena County is influenced by the tribalism culture, and different tribes in this culture tend to win the election. According to Max Weber's theory, this behavior can be considered emotional, traditional, and less rational. For this reason, Gabriel Abraham Almond's distinction between the three types of political culture (Limited political culture, subordinate political culture and participation in political culture) may not easily be accepted; but we can identify, with a bit of modification, subordinate-limited political culture in analyzing the electoral behavior of the region. Parliamentary elections and town and village council elections are a perfect sample of this behavior. In these elections, subordinate political culture and emotional behavior based on ethnicity and tribal prejudice prevail over other intellectual and institutional aspects. Equally, in presidential elections, electoral behavior takes on a more political, economic, and partisan nature. What reinforces the tribal culture and its impact on the electoral behavior is the sense of deprivation and unequal distribution of amenities within the province's cities and between urban and rural areas. Comparison of this study with other studies in similar areas in Fars Province (Nourabad Mamsani), South Khorasan (Birjand), Ilam (Dehloran) and East Azarbaijan (Harris) showed there are some kinds of tribal competition for achieving more power resources and welfare amenities.

Keywords

tribal elite; tribal culture; electoral behavior; Dena County; election

References

1. Ahmadi, H. (2002). Ethnicism in Iran from Myth to Reality. Tehran, Iran: Ney. [In Persian]

2. Ahmadi, H. (2003). Iran's National Identity in the Span of History. National Studies Quarterly,15(1), 46-47. [In Persian]

3. Akbari, H., Fakhari, R. (2015). The Role of Ethnicity in the Electoral Behavior of Multiethnic Communities: A Case Study of Birjand County. Applied Sociology Quarterly, 28(2), 71-90. [In Persian]

4. Alem, A. (2016). Foundations of Political Knowledge. Tehran, Iran: Ney. [In Persian]

5. Azar, A., Momenie, M. (2011). Statistics and its application in management. Iran,Tehran: Samt. [In Persian]

6. Basiri, M.A, Shadi Vand, D. (2001). Electoral Behavior in Tribal Areas: A Case Study of the Dehloran Constituency. Strategic Quarterly, 20 (1), 230-240. [In Persian]

7. Campbell, P.A., Converse, P., Miller, M., Stokes, D. (1960). The American Voter. New York: John Wiley.

8. Darabi, A. (2009a). Electoral Behavior in Iran. Tehran, Iran: Soroush. [In Persian]

9. Darabi, A. (2009b). Theoretical Foundations of Citizens' Electoral Behavior in the Islamic Republic of Iran. Communication Research,16(1), 9-37. [In Persian]

10. Deputy of Information and Statistics. (2017). Selected Results of the General Census of Kohgiluyeh and Boyer Ahmad Province's Population from 2006 to 2016. Kohgiluyeh and Boyer Ahmad Province Management and Planning Organization. [In Persian]

11. European Election Result. (2019). Results by National Party:2019-2024, United Kingdom - Official results. Available at: https://europarl.europa.eu/election-results-2019/en/national-results/united-kingdom/2019-2024/

12. Giugal, A., Johnston, R., Buti, D., Radu, A. (2019) Reforming An Electoral System – An Experiment That Failed: Romania 2008–2012. Representation, DOI: 10.1080/00344893.2019.1636851

13. Glassner, M.I., F., Ch. (1993). Political Geography. Canada: John Wiley.

14. Harrop, M., Miller, W.L. (1987). Elections and Voters: A Comparative Introduction. London: Red Globe Press.

15. Heywood, A. (2002). Politics. London: Pal grave.

16. Imam Jomezadeh, S.J& Karami Rad, J. (2012). Analysis of Factors Affecting Electoral Behavior with a Look at Iran. Journal of Political Research, 1(3), 36-39. [In Persian]

17. Inglehart, W., Welzel, C. (2014). Modernization, Cultural Change and Democracy. Translated by Yaghoub Ahmadi, Iran, Tehran: Kavir. [In Persian]

18. Jafari Nejad, M., Babanaasb, H. & Rabiei, Sh. (2011). Analysis of Electoral Behavior: A Case Study of the 10th Presidential Election in Harris Constituency. Journal of Political and International Research,7(1), 159-208. [In Persian]

19. Johnston, R., Wiley, J. (1980). The Geography of Federal Spending in the United States of America. London: Research Studies Press.

20. Johnston, R.J. (1977). The electoral geography of an election campaign: Scotland in October 1974. Scottish Geographical Magazine, 93(1), 98-108.

21. Johnston, R.J., Pattie Ch.J. (2006). Putting voters in their place: Geography and elections in Great Britain. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

22. Johnston, R.J.; Forrest, J. (1984). On the Geography of Voting in the 1984 New Zealand General Election. Political Science, 37(1), 151-159.

23. Kalantari, S. (2001). Analyzing the Electoral Behavior of the Iranian People in the Seventh and Eighth Presidential Elections. Journal of Political-Economic Information, 167-168(1), 166-171. [In Persian]

24. Kaviani Rad, M. (2007). Geography of Elections. Strategic Studies Quarterly,10(37), 481-505. [In Persian]

25. Kaviani Rad, M. (2009). The Impact of Hometown on Iranian Elections: A Case Study of the First Round of the Ninth Presidential Election. Geopolitics Quarterly,13(1), 1-19. [In Persian]

26. Kaviani Rad, M. (2017). Geography of Elections (Foundations, Approaches and Concepts. Tehran, Iran: Research Institute of Strategic Studies. [In Persian]

27. Kaviani Rad, M., (2013). Geography of Elections with Emphasis on Presidential Elections. Tehran, Iran: Kharazmi. [In Persian]

28. Lazarsfeld, P., Berelson, B. (2003). The People's Choice: How the Voter Makes Up His Mind in a Presidential Campaign. Translated by Mohammad Reza Rostami, Tehran, Iran: Tabalvor. [In Persian]

29. Masoudnia, H., Mehdipour, A. (2007). Tribal Political Culture and Political Participation in Ilam Province. Journal of Political and International Approaches, 26(1), 61-90. [In Persian]

30. Mirzaei, M., Hosseini, S.M.H. & Sadeghi, V. (2017). Explaining the Relationship between Tribalism and Citizenship Rights: A Case Study of the Parliament Elections in the Mamasani Constituency. Journal of Political Geography Research, 2(2), 25-54. [In Persian]

31. Mohammadi, H. (2011). National Conference on Group Strife and Tribal Role in Preventing It. Yasouj: Kohgiluyeh and Boyer Ahamd's Provincial Police Command Research Office. [In Persian]

32. Nikfar, J., Akbari, S. (2015). Investigating the Electoral Behavior of Citizens of Noorabad City in the 9th Parliamentary Elections. Urban Management Quarterly, 40(1), 329-352. [In Persian]

33. Pishgahifard, Z. (1993). Geography of Elections. Geographical Research, 33(1), 43-66. [In Persian]

34. Puran Asl, Kh. (2012). Investigating the Factors Influencing the Electoral Behavior of Bahma'i City: A Case Study of the Eighth Parliamentary Elections. MSc Thesis, University of Isfahan: Faculty of Administrative and Economic Sciences. [In Persian]

35. Rameshk, A. (2003). A Sociological Study of Electoral Behavior in Kohgiluyeh and Boyer Ahmad. National Studies Quarterly, 4(1), 192-225. [In Persian]

36. Rennie Short, J. (1993). An Introduction to Political Geography. London and New York: Routledge.

37. Rezvani, M. (2007). Analyzing Electoral Behavior: A Case Study of the Ninth Presidential Election. Quarterly of Ma'refat, 16 (123), 1-20. [In Persian]

38. Romina, A., Sadeghi, W. (2015). Investigating The impact of Tribalism on Voting Patterns: A Case Study of Nourabad Mamasani County. Geopolitic Quarterly, 11(3), 84-116. [In Persian]

39. Sadeghi Jagheh, S., (2015). Investigating Social Factors Affecting Iranian Electoral Behavior. Strategic Studies Quarterly, 18(3), 89-118. [In Persian]

40. Safari, A. (2010). Investigation of Tribal Affiliation and its Impact on People's Electoral Behavior in Baghmalek ژounty. M.Sc. in Political Science, Isfahan University. [In Persian]

41. Sajasi Gheidari, H., Et.al. (2016). Analyzing the Relationship between Tribalism in Local Community with Political Development in Electoral Conditions: A Case Study of Nourabad Mamasani County. Journal of Geography and Regional Development, 14(1), 19-46. [In Persian]

42. Samiei Esfahani, A., Ahmadi, S. & Enfeali, S. (2014). Investigating the Differences of Economic Factors, Political Competition and Foreign Intervention in the Presidential Elections of 1997 and 2009. Journal of Applied Sociology, 5(4), 169-182. [In Persian]

43. Sariolghalam, M., (1998). The Tribal Foundations of Political Culture. Journal of Political and Economic Information, 135-136(1), 34-43. [In Persian]

44. Sarwar, R., Khaliji, M., (2013). Measuring the Development of the Counties of Kohgiluyeh and Boyer Ahmad Province. Journal of Urban Research and Planning, 6(21), 89-102. [In Persian]

45. Shahbazi, A. (1990). Introduction to Tribal and Nomads Recognition. Tehran, Iran: Ney. [In Persian]

46. Shamsoudini, A. (2010). Elections and Tribalism with Emphasis on the Fifth to the Eighth Islamic Council Elections in Mamasani Constituency. Encyclopedia of Law and Politics,14(1), 11-40. [In Persian]

47. Taylore, P., Johnston, R. (1979). Geography of Election. London: Croom Helm.

48. Webb, P., Eula, H., Gibbins, R. (2019). Election. Encyclopedia Britanica. Available at: https://www.britannica.com/topic/election-political-science

49. Yeganeh, M., Hasanvand, M. (2013). The Culture of Tribalism and Elections in Lorestan. Tehran, Iran: Daneshparvar. [In Persian]