Working capital management and profitability during the business cycles

اقتصاد پولی مالی

Article 8, Volume 24, Issue 13, April 2017, Pages 181-204   

Document Type: پژوهشی

DOI: 10.22067/pm.v24i14.53286

Authors

maryam davallou¹; fatemeh bastami^{* 2}; mohammad hossein mirzaali tehrani³

¹shahid beheshti

²alborz

³allame tabatabaie

Abstract

1-Introduction
This study is aimed to investigate the effect of working capital management on profitability during business cycles (boom and bust). If capital structure and long-term investment decisions are foundation of firm, proper management of working capital likes blood in the firms’ veins provides financial health and continuity possibility. One of the most important functions of every organization is the efficient management of working capital. Obviously, the uncertainty associated with macro-economic factors plays an important role in changing the product demand and firms financing. So that Kvrazyk & Levi (2003) believe firms determine the timing for debt issuing based on economic conditions. The main source of working capital financing, is retained earnings so it can be argued that business cycles affect the firm financing through its impact on economic growth, product demand and subsequently sales. For example, when sales of firm decline its profit is reduced and an important source of working capital financing is affected. In this situation, management will have to use external funds that are expensive. Regardless of the kind of industry in which the firm operates, the macroeconomic conditions affect all industries. For example, the recession declines the general level of demand, decreases sales and liquidity and imposes increasingly pressures on firms business. Lending limitations of financial institutions have led to cash becomes the scarce resource. Hence, the importance of working capital management is more than ever before. Therefore, this study investigated the effects of working capital management on profitability in different business cycles. In this study, for the first time, the effects of working capital and the profitability are examined taking into account the business cycles in both fixed and variable sample. Fixed sample includes companies that listed in the stock exchange continuously for the whole sample period. However variable sample includes companies that also have been listed during the research period (every year new companies listed in Tehran Stock Exchange). This study is aimed to investigate the relationship between business cycles, working capital management and profitability.
The study hypothesis includes:
Hypothesis 1: There is a relationship between profitability and cash conversion cycle (separated by boom and bust).
Hypothesis 2: There is a relationship between profitability and commitment payment period (separated by boom and bust).
Hypothesis 3: There is a relationship between profitability and average collection period (separated by boom and bust).
Hypothesis 4: There is a relationship between profitability and average inventory turnover period (separated by boom and bust).
2- Methodology
The effect of working capital management on the profitability during business cycles is examined by panel data regression using annual data. The diagnosis tests to determine the model (panel or pool regression) including F Limer and Hausman tests are fitted. It should be mentioned that profitability is calculated through two measures including return on assets (ROA) and gross operating profit. To evaluate the effect of business cycles on the relationship between working capital management and profitability, we must first identify business cycles. For this purpose the filter Hodrick –Perescot is used. The study consisted of both fixed and variable samples with 143 and 251 companies in Tehran Stock Exchange for 2001 to 2013 respectively.
3-Results & Discussion
The results of the two fixed and variable samples are shown in the below table.
Business cycles Variable Expected Sign ROA (dependent variable) GOI (dependent variable)
Example(251) Example(143) Example(251) Example(143)
Boom Ccc1 - Negative and insignificant positive and insignificant Negative and insignificant positive and insignificant
Ccc*D1 + positive and significant positive and insignificant positive and insignificant Negative and insignificant
Bust Ccc - positive and insignificant positive and insignificant positive and insignificant Negative and insignificant
Ccc*D2 - negative and significant Negative and insignificant Negative and insignificant positive and insignificant
Boom AP + negative and significant negative and significant negative and significant negative and significant
AP*D1 - negative and significant negative and significant Negative and insignificant Negative and insignificant
Bust AP + negative and significant negative and significant negative and significant Negative and insignificant
AP*D2 + positive and significant positive and significant positive and insignificant positive and insignificant
Boom AR - negative and significant negative and significant negative and significant negative and significant
AR*D1 + negative and significant Negative and insignificant negative and significant Negative and insignificant
Bust AR - negative and significant negative and significant negative and significant negative and significant
AR*D2 - positive and significant positive and insignificant positive and significant positive and insignificant
Boom INV - negative and significant Negative and insignificant Negative and insignificant Negative and insignificant
INV*D1 + positive and significant positive and insignificant positive and insignificant positive and insignificant
Bust INV - positive and insignificant Negative and insignificant Negative and insignificant Negative and insignificant
INV*D2 - negative and significant Negative and insignificant Negative and insignificant positive and insignificant
CCC: Cash Conversion Cycle, AP: Accounts Payable, AR: Accounts Receivable, INV: Inventory Conversion Period
As it can be seen there is a significant negative relationship between the profitability and collection period and this finding is supported by the expectations. In other words, this result has not been changed despite of balanced and unbalanced sample. There is negative relation between collection period and profitability during the boom that is reversed during the recession relative to the boom. The results indicated significant negative relationship between the profitability and commitment payment period. According to the results, as long as the economic downturn prevails, the commitment period has a positive relationship with profitability while the mentioned relationship is reversed in the boom period. Sensitivity analysis indicates that no change in the findings has been achieved with balanced sample.
4- Conclusions & Suggestions
The results indicate that as long as the return on assets (ROA) is used as a profitability measure, the relationship between profitability with the commitment payment period and the collection period is negative during the boom and there is a positive significant relationship between profitability and the cash conversion period and average inventory turnover. These relationships are reverse in recession. While if the gross operating earnings is used as second measure of profitability, it cannot find any significant relationship between profitability with the cash conversion period, average inventory turnover and commitment payment period neither during boom nor bust. There is negative (positive) significant relationship between gross operating profit and the average collection period in boom (recession). So, the results of this research are affected by the profitability measures. The results of the study are always true in variable and constant samples. Findings sensitivity analysis shows that the main results of this research are not influenced by variable sample and is established also for constant sample.

Keywords

working capital; Business cycle; profitability

References

[1] Attari, M, A, & Raza, K. (2012). The Optimal Relationship of Cash Conversion Cycle with Firm Size and Profitability. International Journal of Academic Research in Business and Social Sciences. 2. (4), pp:189-203.

[2] Azadegan, A.,& Pai, D. (2008). Industrial awards as manifests of business performance: an Empirical Assessment. J. PurchasingSupply Manage. 14 (3), 149–159.

[3] Azimi, M. & Sabagh, M. (2014). The value relevance of net non-cash working capital in companies listed on the Tehran Stock Exchange. Journal of Financial Accounting; (3): 89-104 (In Persian).

[4] Bagchi, B,& Khamrui,B. (2012). Relationship between Working Capital Management and Profitability: A Study of Selected FMCG Companies in India. Business and Economics Journal, pp:1-12.

[5] Barber, B.M., & Lyon, J.D. (1996). Detecting abnormal operating performance: the empirical power and specification of test statistics.J. Financial Economics 41 (3), 359–399.

[6] Braun, M., & Larrain, B., 2005. Finance and the business cycle: international, inter-industry evidence. J. Finance 60 (3), 1097–1128.Chiou, J.R., Cheng, L., Wu, H.W., 2006. The determinants of working capital management. J. Am. Acad. Business (Cambridge) 10(1), 149–155.

[7] Chiou, J. R., & Cheng, L. (2006). The Determinants of Working Capital Management. Journal of American Academy of Business, 10(1), 149-155.

[8] Deloof, M. (2003). Does working capital management affect profitability of Belgian firms? J. Business Finance Acc. 30 (4), 573–587.

[9] Einarsson, T., & Marquis, M.H. (2001). Bank intermediation over the business cycle. J. Money Credit Banking 33 (4), 876–899.

[10] Enqvist, J., & Graham, M., Nikkinen, J. (2014). The impact of working capital management on firm profitability in different business cycles; Evidence Finland. Research in International Business and finance 32; 36-49.

[11] Garcia,J Terue, Martiz,P Solano. (2003).“Effect of Working Capital Management on SME Profitabilty. International Journal of Managerial Finance. Volume 3, Issue 2 pp:1-22.

[12] Ghazavi, H. (2011). The explaining recent developments in the real sector of the Iranian economy, economy news; (127): 23-38 (In Persian).

[13] Gill, A., Biger, N., Mathur, N., )2010(. The relationship between working capital management and profitability: evidence from theUnited States. Business Economics J. 10, 1–9.

[14] Hadian, A. & Hashempour, M (2004). Identify business cycles in the economy, economic studies; (15): 93-120 (In Persian).

[15] Izadi Nye, N. & Taki, A. (2011). The examines impact of working capital management on the profitability of listed companies in Tehran Stock Exchange. Journal of Financial Accounting; (5):120-139 (In Persian).

[16] Jin, Q. (2005). Business cycle-Accounting behavior-Earning management. Thesis (Ph.D.). Hong Kong University of Science and Technology.

[17] Kamath, R. (1989). How useful are common liquidity measures? J. Cash Manage. 9 (1), 24–28.

[18] Korajczyk, R.A, & Levy, A. (2003). Capital structure choice: Macroeconomic conditions and financial constrains. Financial Economics, 68(1), 75–109.

[19] Lazaridis, I., & Tryfonidis, D. (2006). Relationship between working capital management and profitability of listed companies onthe Athens Stock Exchange. J. Financial Management Anal. 19 (1), 26–35.

[20] Makori, M, D, & Jagongo, A. (2013). Working Capital Management and Firm Profitability: Empirical Evidence from Manufacturing and Construction Firms Listed on Nairobi Securities Exchange, Kenya. International Journal of Accounting and Taxation. (1),1.

[21] Matuva, D. M (2010). The influence of working capital management components on corporate profitability: Asurvey on Kenyan listed firm. Research Journal of business management. 4(1), 1-11.

[22] Merville, L.J., & Tavis, L.A. (1973). Optimal working capital management policies: a Chance-Constrained Programming Approach. J.Financial Quantitative Anal. 8 (1), 47–59.

[23] Mohammadi, M. (2010). The effects of working capital on profitability in the companies listed in Tehran Stock Exchange. Journal of Management; (14): 80-91 (In Persian).

[24] Moine-Din, M. Heyrani, F. and Ayandeh Malmiri, F. (2014). The examines impact of working capital management on market value, The National Conference of management and accounting. Shiraz (In Persian).

[25] Pourheydari, H, & Houshmand Zaferanieh, R. (2013). A review of empirical research concerning the effect on profitability, working capital management firms. Journal of Financial Accounting Research; (2): 1-18 (In Persian).

[26] Pourheydari, O, & Alipour, D. (2012). The examines relationship between accounting data to business cycles in the Tehran Stock Exchange. Journal of Financial Financial Accounting; (2): 1-16 (In Persian).

[27] Reza Zadeh, J. & Heydariyan, J. (2011). The impact on working capital management Profitability Iranian companies. Journal of Accounting and Auditing preceding studies; (7): 20-40 (In Persian).

[28] Richards, V.D., & Laughlin, E.J. (1980). A cash conversion cycle approach to liquidity management. Financial Manage. 9 (1), 32–38.

[29] Samiloglu, F. & DemirgOnes, K. (2008) . “The effect of Working Capital Management on Firm’s Profitability: Evidence from Turkey” The International Journal of Applied Economics and Finance, Vol. 2. (1) , pp: 44-50.

[30] Samson, A. A.; Mary, J.; Yemisi and Erekpitan, I. O. (2012) . “The impact of working capital management on the profitability of small and medium scale enterprises in Nigeria” Research Journal of Business Management, ISSN 1819-1932 / DOI: 10.3923/rjbm.

[31] Setayesh, M, and Mansour, O. (2011). The examines the relationship between different components of working capital and profit accounting firms accepted in Tehran Stock Exchange. Journal of Financial Accounting and Auditing; (8): 1-24 (In Persian).

[32] Setayesh, M. Kazemnejad, M and Zulfiqar, M. (2009). The examines impact of working capital management on the profitability of listed companies in Tehran Stock Exchange. Journal of Financial Financial Accounting; (23): 43-66 (In Persian).

[33] Shin, H.H., & Soenen, L. (1998). Efficiency of working capital and corporate profitability. Financial Practice Education 8 (2), 37–45.

[34] Souri, A. (2013). Advanced Econometrics with Eviews and Stata application, First Edition, Tehran, of culture (In Persian).

[35] Tomy R.E. (2012). Earnings Persistence over the Business Cycle. Working paper. Stanford University.

[36] Ukaegbu, B. (2014). The significance of working capital management in determining firm profitability: evidence from developingeconomies in Africa. Res. Int. Business Finance 31, 1–16.

[37] Wang, Y.J. (2002). Liquidity management, operating performance and corporate value: evidence from Japan and Taiwan. J.Multinational Financial Manage. 12 (2), 159–169.

[38] Yaghoobnezhad, A. Vakilifard, A. and Babaie, Reza. (2011). The relationship between working capital management and profitability in the company, listed on the Tehran Stock Exchange, Journal of financial engineering and management of securities; (2): 117-138 (In Persian).