Comparison of Efficiency of Different Equations to Estimate the Water Requirement in Saffron (Crocus sativus L.( (Case Study: Birjand Plain, Iran)

بوم شناسی کشاورزی

Article 1, Volume 8, Issue 4 - Serial Number 30, December 2016, Pages 505-520   

Document Type: Scientific - Research

DOI: 10.22067/jag.v8i4.40517

Authors

Mohsen Ahmadee^{* 1}; Abbas Khashei-Siuki²; Mohammad Hasan Sayyari Zahan³

¹Department of Irrigation and Drainage, Shahid Chamran University of Ahvaz, Iran

²Department of Water Engineering, Faculty of Agriculture, University of Birjand, Iran

³Department of Soil Science, Faculty of Agriculture, University of Birjand, Iran

Abstract

Introduction
Saffron (Crocus sativus L.) is a subtropical plant mostly cultivated in South Khorasan and Khorasan Razavi provinces, Iran. Total saffron production is about 200 ton all over the world, and since it is native to Iran, the country has an important role to produce saffron. In recent years, drought showed a significant effect on water resources in Birjand, South Khorasan. Due to lack of full equipped meteorological stations and sufficient lysimetery studies, over irrigation and deficit irrigation are mostly common among saffron farmers. The cause of saffron yield decline is mostly related to irrigation. In addition, farmers need the simple equation/formula to determine the water demand, so, it is necessary to present a single and simple equation. Regarding to this purpose, this study was conducted to achieve mentioned goals: 1) determination of the best evapotranspiration equation, 2) comparison of saffron water need based on 12 most relevant evapotranspiration equations, and 3) determination a single-parameter model to rapidly and accurately estimate saffron water need based on gamma test (due to lack of all FAO-Penman-Monteith parameters in all Birjand’s meteorological stations).
Materials and methods
This study was conducted using meteorological data collected from Birjand´s synoptic station during 1984-2014. This station is located at longitude 59˚ 21' E and latitude 32˚ 87' N and elevation 1491m. Twelve evapotranspiration equations (Blaney-Criddle, Hargreaves, Turc, Priestley-Taylor, Thornthwaite, Jensen-Haise, Makkink, Modified Jensen-Haise, Irmak (Rn), Irmak (Rs), Lowry-Johnson, Pan-Class A) were evaluate to determine the best accurate one. To compare the 12 evapotranspiration equations results with FAO-Penman-Monteith equation (FAO56-PM), four statistical criteria (R2, MBE, RMSE and EF) were used. In order to comprise saffron water demand to actual water used, amount of irrigation water for saffron cultivation in Birjand plain was measured during 2014. In addition, saffron yield was recorded during this growing season in this region. In order to propose a single parameter and accurate model based on easily accessible meteorological parameters, gamma test was also employed.
Results and discussion
Results of coefficient of determination (R2) were acceptable (>0.9) for all equations except Turk. The results showed that Blaney-Criddle, Modified Jensen-Haise and Hargreaves had better accuracy compared to other equations so that their root mean square errors (RMSE) were 0.572, 0.721 and 0.945 mm.d-1, respectively. In addition, saffron water requirement determined with FAO56-PM was equal to 2350 m3.ha-1.y-1. Hargreaves equation, with differences about -161.23 m3.ha-1.y-1 compared with FAO56-PM, was determined as a good equation. Measured irrigation water by saffron farmers was about 1184.17 m3.ha-1.y-1. According to the results it found that deficit irrigation was applied by saffron farmers. Saffron grow in arid regions, however, drought stress have a negative effect on its plant development and yield (Khorramdel et al., 2014; Khashei Siuki et al., 2015). Despite the lack of doing no test about the effect of deficit irrigation on saffron yield during 2014 in this region, it seems that deficit irrigation may be a reason of low saffron yield (SYASK, 2010) compared to average saffron yield in this region.
Results of gamma test revealed that temperature is a key parameter to develop a single model. In addition, results showed that the single parameter model based on temperature had better accuracy compared to above-twelve mentioned equation.
Conclusion
Hargreaves equation was only used the temperature (T) and extraterrestrial radiation (Ra) for estimating evapotranspiration. In addition, single parameter equation based on the mean temperature was only used one parameter (T) to estimate the evapotranspiration. Since both of the equations had an acceptable accuracy to use in this region, it is recommended to use them to determine saffron irrigation demand. It is due to lack of meteorological equipment for estimating all parameters in the plain.
Acknowledgement
The authors would like to thank the anonymous reviewers whose valuable comments have helped us to clarify some parts of this paper.

Keywords

FAO56-PM equation; Single-Parameter equation; Water stress

References

Ait-Oubahou, A., and El-Otmani, M. 1999. Saffron Cultivation in Morocco. In: Saffron. (Neghbi, M., ed.). Hardwood Academic Publications, Amsterdam 154 pp.

Alizadeh, A., Mahdavi, M., Iranloo, M., and Bazari, M.E. 1999. Evapo-transpiration and crop coefficient of saffron (Crocus sativus). Geographical Research 54 and 55: 29-42. (In Persian with English Summary)

Allen, R.G., Pereira, L.S., Raes, D., and Smith, M. 1998. Crop evapotranspiration guidelines for computing crop water requirements. FAO Irrigation and Drainage Paper, NO. 56. Rome. Italy.

Allen, R.G., Smith, M., Pereira, L.S., and Raes, D. 1994. An update for the calculation of reference evapotranspiration. ICID Bulletin 43(2): 35-92.

Amatya, D.M., Skaggs, R.W., and Gregory, J.D. 1995. Comparison of methods for estimating REF-ET. Irrigation and Drainage Engineering 121(6): 427-435.

Baiat Varkeshi, M., Zare Abyaneh, H., and Ghasemi, A. 2008. Provide the Best Empirical Evapotranspiration Relationship Compared With FAO-Penman-Monteith in the North West. 3rd Iran Water Resources Management Conference. Tabriz, Iran. (In Persian)

Bari Abarghoei, H., Ghalavand, A., Mazaheri, D., Noor Mohammadi, G., and Sanei, M. 2001. Temperature effect on flowering and yield performance accessions on Iranian saffron. Pajouhesh Va Sazandgi 4: 65-69. (In Persian with English Summary)

Behnia, M.R. 1989. Saffron: Botany, Cultivation and Production. Tehran University Publications, Tehran, Iran 190 pp. (In Persian)

Burman, R., and Pochop, L.O. 1994. Evaporation, Evapotranspiration and Climate Data. Elsevier Science B.V.

Doorenbos, J., and Pruitt, W.O. 1977. Guidelines For Predicting Crop Water Requirements. FAO Irrigation and Drainage Paper, NO. 24. Rome. Italy.

Ehsanzadoh, P., Yadollahi, A.A., and Maibodi, A.N.M. 2004. Productivity, growth and quality attributes of 10 Iranian saffron accessions under climatic conditions of Chahar–Mahal Bakhtrazi, Central Iran. In: Proceeding of the 1st International Symposium on Saffron. Albacete. Spain. p. 183-188.

Goliaris, A.H. 1999. Saffron cultivation in Greece. In: Saffron. (Neghbi, M., ed.). Hardwood Academic Publications, Amsterdam 154 pp.

Hargreaves, G.H. 1994. Defining and using reference evapotranspiration. Irrigation and Drainage Engineering ASCE 120(6): 1132-1139.

Jensen, ME., Burman, R.D., and Allen, R.G. 1990. Evapotranspiration and Irrigation Water Requirements. ASCE Manuals and Reports on Engineering Practices, No. 70. American Society of Civil Engineers, NY.

Kafi, M. 2006. Saffron Ecophysioligy p. 39-57. In: Kafi, M., Koocheki, A., Rashed, M.H., Nassiri, M. (Eds.). Saffron (Crocus sativus) Production and Processing. Science Publishers, Enfield.

Kafi, M., Rashed Mohasel, M.H., Koocheki, A., and Molafilabi, A. 2002. Saffron Production and Processing. Ferdowsi University of Mashhad Publications, Mashhad, Iran. (In Persian)

Khashei Siuki, A., Hashemi, S.R., and Ahmadee, M. 2015. The effect of Pottasic Zeolite and irrigation scheduling on saffron yield. Reserch Project in University of Birjand. (In Parsian)

Khorramdel, S., Gheshm, R., Amin Ghafori, A., and Esmaielpour, B. 2014. Evaluation of soil texture and superabsorbent polymer impacts on agronomical characteristics and yield of saffron. Journal of Saffron Research 1(2): 120-135. (In Parsian)

Maaroofi, S., Zare Abyaneh, H., and Baiat Varkeshi, M. 2008. Assessment of Evapotranspiration Empirical Formulas Between two Reference Crop of Alfalfa and Grass with Pan in Ahvaz. The 2rd National Conference On Irrigation and Drainage Networks Management. Ahvaz, Iran. (In Persian)

Mahdavi, M. 1999. Plant coefficient and saffron evartanspiration on standard condition. MSc thesis. Faculty of Agricultutre. Ferdowsi University of Mashhad, Iran. (In Parsian)

Mobaraki, Z. 2005. Saffron cultivation locating in Qazvin province. MSc thesis. Tehran University, Tehran, Iran. (In Persian with English Summary)

Mollafilabi, A. 2004. Experimental findings of production and echophysiological aspects of saffron (Crocus sativus L.). Acta Horticulturae (ISHS) 650: 195-200.

Nasaji Zavareh, M., and Sadeghifar, R. 2007. Estimation of reference crop evapotranspiration using different methods (Case study: Karaj). 9th Conference on Irrigation and Evaporation Reduction. Kerman, Iran. (In Persian)

Noori, R., Karbassi, A., and Sabahi, M.S. 2009. Evaluation of PCA and gamma test techniques on AAN opration for weekly solid waste prediction. Journal of Enviromental Management 91: 767-771.

Pakdin, M., Shahnavaz, Y., Roostaei, S., and Alipoor, H. 2012. Study of potential and actual evapotranspiration in Faruj basin. The 1st National Conference on Solutions to Access Sustainable Development in Agriculture, Natural Resources and the Environment (sdconf). Tehran, Iran. (In Persian)

Pazoki, A., Kariminejad, M., and Foladi Targhi, A. 2013. Effect of planting patterns on yield and some agronomical traits in saffron (Crocus sativus L.) Under different irrigation intervals in Shahr-e-Rey Region. International Journal of Farming and Allied Sciences 2(S2): 1363-1368.

Rashed, M.H., Kafi, M., Koocheki, A., and Nassiri, M. 2006. Saffron (Crocus sativus) Production and Processing. Science Publications 87-96.

Remesan, R., Shamim, M.A., and Han, D. 2008. Model data selection using gamma test for daily solar radiation estimation. Hydrological Processes 22: 4301-4309.

Rezvani-Moghaddam, P., Huda, A.K.S., Parvez, Q., and Koocheki, A. 2007. Indigenous Knowledge in Agriculture with Particular Reference to Medicinal Crop Production in Khorasan, Iran. Managing Knowledge, Technology and Development in the Era of Information Revolution. Edited by A. Ahmed p. 105-115.

Saeed, M. 1986. The estimation of evapotranspiration by some equations under hot and arid conditions. Transaction American Society of Agricultural and Biological Engineers 29(2): 434-438.

Salih, A.M.A., and Sendil, U. 1984. Evapotranspiration under extremely arid climates. Irrigation and Drainage Engineering, ASCE 110(3): 289-303.

Samadi, H., and Majdzadeh, B. 2003. Comparison of reference evapotranspiration calculated by empirical formulas with lysimeters in Kerman. 8th Conference on Irrigation and Evaporation Reduction. Kerman, Iran. (In Persian)

Sepaskhah, A.R., and Kamgar-Haghighi, A.A. 2009. Saffron irrigation regime. International Journal of Plant Production 3(1): 1-16.

Shih, S.F. 1984. Data requirement for evapotranspiration estimation. Irrigation and Drainage Engineering. ASCE 110(3): 263-274.

Statistical Yearbook of Agriculture in Khorasan Razavi Province (SYAKRP). 2010. Available at Web site: Http://www.koaj.ir/news/default.asp?nk=63&maincatid=1184. (In Persian)

Statistical Yearbook of Agriculture in South Khorasan (SYASK), 2010. Available at http://kj-agrijahad.ir/dbagri/html1/birjand88-89.htm (In Persian)

Stegman, E.C., and Bauer, A. 1977. Sugar beet response to water stress in sandy soils. Transaction of the American Society of Agriculture Engineering 20: 469-472.

Trajkovic, S., and Kolakovic, S. 2009. Evaluation of reference evapotranspiration equations under humid conditions. Water Resource Management 23(14): 3057-3067.

Zandilak, H. 2011. Select the Appropriate Method for Estimating Evapotranspiration in Yazd. 1st Regional Water Resources Development Conference. Abarkoh. (In Persian)