Evaluation of Control and Adjustment Structures of the Shibab Main Canal Using HEC-RAS

آب و خاک

Article 13, Volume 30, Issue 4 - Serial Number 48, September 2016, Pages 1059-1074   

Document Type: Research Article

DOI: 10.22067/jsw.v30i4.44841

Authors

maryam mohammadi; farzad hassanpour^* ; Majid azizpour pirsaraie

University of Zabol

Abstract

Introduction: Poor performance of irrigation and drainage networks causes to reduce the transfer and distribution throughputs and in result comes useless water and makes too much consumption in forming. A significant portion of water losses in irrigation and drainage networksis related to transmission and distribution. Therefor more consideration in thrirrigation network management, improve irrigation efficiency and also the exploitation of water resources, especially in the agricultural sector is necessary. Controlling and adjusting structures of water level in the direction of drainage and irrigation canals can influence on increasing of throughput and decrease the use of water. So, right choosing and recognition of the deficiencies of these structures helps carry up the throughput of the networks and prevents to waste water. It is hard to solve equations of water flow in canals and related institutions by using analytic methods. For this reason, this research was done with HEC-RAS hydraulical model in the main channelof irrigation and drainage network of Sistan plain.
Materials and Methods: Sistan plain is located in southeastern of Iran with good potential for agricultural production because of the alluvial sediments from Hirmand River. 23820 ha of the Sistan plain is covered by 5 blocksof the Shibab irrigation and drainage network. While Sistan’sShibab irrigation network efficiency is low, HEC-RAS Hydraulics model in unsteady condition was performed to control and adjust this network’s main canal in approximately 19 Km length. In this research, the evaluation model in the canal was performed for more suitable intakingwater in the quadruple order 2 canals . So, the existing structure’s operation was analyzed on controlling structures in management and lack of management situations.This research was assessed during a 15-day impounding period using hydraulic model of HEC-RAS with the aim of performance and operation evaluation of existing structures on the Shibab main canal. HEC-RAS model was prepared by United States army corps of engineers which is developed by the hydrologicengineering center.HEC-RAS analyzes river system and runs under the Windows operating system. This software package is of hydraulic analysis program series, where the user communicates with the system via a graphical user interface (GUI). The system is capable of performing steady and unsteady flow water surfaceprofile calculations. HEC-RAS software is designed to perform one dimensional hydraulic calculation for a full network of natural and synthetic channels. Visits were made before and after the beginning of irrigation, and during the Operation, in order to record the data of the flow and observe the way of utilization of canal, and existing structures. Then, the model was calibrated on the basis of depth and discharge measurement and simulation data in real condition of operation for 10 days impoundment during 21 to 30 April, and the Statistical parameter values:RMSE, EF, MBEand R2 were calculated. Then the objective functionwas evaluatedusingoperational performance indexes of adequacy, efficiency, equity and reliability of Molden and Gates regarding to HEC-RAS simulation results in unsteady condition.
Results and Discussion: According to the simulation results in existing condition,theerror of delivery dischargeis equal to 0.54 while applying the management onthe adjustment structure of irrigation networkdeclined theerror to 0.42. By the canal routstructuremanagement in HEC-RAS model, on the basis of proposed operation option, according to existing operation condition, delivery discharge loss in comparison to the total discharge of the network 0.12 value decreases.Based on the simulation results, the mean percentage of improvementin performance indexes of adequacy,efficiency, equity and reliability, as well as objective functionofdelivery discharge are equal to 19.7, 20.90, 66.07, 65.24and54.81. Therefore based on simulation results of different scenarios and investigation of the effective factors onto the flow, onthe forms of charts and tables show that without management on controlling structures, it isn`t possible to appropriate of flow rate onto second class canals and traditional streams branched out main canal and also streams branched out second class canals, properly.
Conclusion: The results show that the model of HEC-RAS is proper for hydraulic simulation of main canal in the irrigation and drainage network of Sistan plain. Based on the simulation results of different scenarios of this research, the mostimprovements intheobjective functionare allocated toequity and reliability indexes in the Shibab main canal with the proposed management method.

Keywords

Irrigation network; HEC-RAS; Performance indexes; Sistan plain; Unsteady flow

References

1- Akbarian A. 2007. Design of Small Canal Structures. P. 189. Amidi Press, Tabriz, Iran. (in Persian)

2- Burt C. M., and Styles S. 1998. Modern Water Control and Management Practices in Irrigation: Impact on Performance. Proceeding of the First International ITIS Network Meeting on Modernization of Irrigation System Operations, India: 62-79.

3- Dahmardeh M. 2010. Performance Analysis of Poshtab and Shibab Main Channels in Sistan Plain using HEC-RAS Model. Msc thesis in agriculture faculty, University of Zabol, Iran. P. 129. (in Persian with English abstract)

4- Ghodusi H., Monem M.J., and Emadi A. 2009. Using Hydrodynamic Models in Determination of Irrigational Channels Operation in Unsteady Flow Conditions, National Conference of Water. P. 6. Soil, Planet and Agricultural Machinery, Azad University of Dezful, Dezful, Iran. (in Persian with English abstract)

5- Goussard J. 2000. Canal Operation Simulation Models. International Commission on Irrigation and Drainage Publisher (ICID Pub). New Delhi.

6- Habib Z., Shahid B., and Butta M. 1992. The Utility of a Simulation Model for Pakistan Canal Systems. Cemagref-IIMI International Workshop on the Application of the Mathematical Modeling for Improvement of Irrigation Canal Operation, Octobr 26-30, Montpellier, France, pp. 131-150.

7- HEC-RAS. 2010. River Analysis System, Reference Manual, Version 4.1. U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, Hydrologic Engineering Center, 411p.

8- Isalou-Pasban N., Zadeh-Deli A., Farsadi-Zadeh D., and Sadrodini A.A. 2008. Hydraulic Operation Evaluation of Water Flow Measurement Structures, Case Study: L1D/R2M Slide Gate Canal of Moghan Irrigation and Drainage Network, Technical Workshop on the Management. Operation and maintenance of Irrigational and Drainage Networks, Tehran, Iran. (in Persian with English abstract)

9- Islam A., Raghuwanshi N. S., and Singh R. 2008. Development and Application of Hydraulic Simulation Model for Irrigation Canal Network. Irrigation and Drainage Engineering, 134: 1(49).

10- Javid A., and Muhammad L. 2009. Flexibility Analysis of Irrigation Outlet Structures using Simulation of Irrigation Canal Hydrodynamic Model. Irrigation science. 29: 127-134.

11- Jebelifard S., and Omidvar A. 2002. HEC-RAS River Analysis System, Jahad Daneshgahi. P. 371. Tehran, Iran. (in Persian)

12- Litrico X., and Fromion V. 2004. Analytical Approximation of Open-Channel Flow for Controller Design. Applied Mathematical Modeling, 28: 677-695.

13- Mishra A., Anand A., Sing R., and Ranghuwanshi N. S. 2001. Hydraulic Modeling of Kangsabati Main Canal for Performance Assessment. Journal of Irrigation and Drainage Engineering, ASCE 127(1): 27-34.

14- Mohseni Movahed S.A., Mohseni N., and Norouzpour S. 2010. Assessing Impacts of Weighting Indicators on Optimum Performance of Irrigation Canals. Journal of Water and Soil, 24: 1083-1096. (in Persian with English abstract)

15- Molden D. J., and Gates T. K. 1990. Performance Measures for Evaluation of Irrigation Water Delivery Systems. Journal of Irrigation and Drainage Engineering, American Society of civil Engineering (ASCE), 116: 804-822.

16- Monem M.J., and Kiapasha M.S. 2009. Training and Testing of Upstream Phase Automated Control Systems in Irrigation Canals. Iran Water Research Journal, 4: 41-50. (in Persian)

17- Montazar A.A., and Pashazadeh N. 2010. Performance Assessment of West Main Canal of Dez in the Different Water Operational Scenarios Using CANALMAN Model. Journal of Water and Soil, 25: 125-139. (in Persian with English abstract)

18- Samani J.M. 2004. Report of Applied Research Plan: Legal Studies of Sistan Plain Water Resources. Code 410, No 7302. (in Persian)

19- Shafai-Bajestan M. Open Channel Flow. P. 386-388. Shahid Chamran University, Ahvaz, Iran. (in Persian)

20- Soltani H., Maroufi S., and Boroumand nasab S. 2006. Representation of a Mathematical Equation for Estimation of Channels Efficiencies (Case Study in Shavour Irrigation and Drainage Network). The 1st Conference on Optimum Utilization of Water Resources, 5-6 Sep. 2006. Shahrekord, Iran. (in Persian)

21- Zalaghi A. 2005. Flow Discharge Coefficient in Radial Gate. Msc thesis in water structures field, Shahid Chamran University of Ahvaz, Iran. (in Persian with English Abstract).