The Occurrence of Early Autumn Frost Frequency Analysis Case Study: Khorasan Razavi’s Synoptic Stations

آب و خاک

Article 1, Volume 31, Issue 1 - Serial Number 51, March 2017, Pages 312-320   

Document Type: Research Article

DOI: 10.22067/jsw.v31i1.26217

Authors

nafise seyednezhad; mahboobeh farzandi^{* 1}; H. Rezaee-Pazhand²

¹Ferdowsi University of Mashhad

²Azad Slamic University Unit of Mashhad

Abstract

Introduction: The analysis of extreme events such as first frost dates are detrimental phenomena which influence in various branches of engineering, such as agriculture. The analysis and probability predicting of these events can decrease damage of agriculture, horticulture and the others. Furthermore, this phenomenon can have a relation with other thermal indexes. The analyzing of first frost dates of all synoptic stations of Khorasan Razavi province is subject of this article. The frequency analysis applied to eight distributions. Then the relationship between first frost dates and thermal index were studied. Best relation was between minimum temperature and return periods of first frost dates.
Materials and Methods: The analyzing of first frost dates (origin is March 21) of all synoptic stations of Khorasan Razavi province is subject of this article. At first data of each station were screening. The basic properties such as homogeneity, randomness, stationary, independence and outliers must be tested. The eight distribution Normal, Gumbel type 1, Gamma 2-parameter, Log normal 2 or 3 parameters, Generalized Pareto, Generalized extreme values and Pearson Type 3 fitted to data and the parameters estimated with 7 methods by the name of the several types of Moments (5 methods), maximum likelihood and the maximum Entropy. The Kolmogorov – Smirnov goodness of fit test can be used to compare the best distribution. The return periods of first frost dates are major application in frequency analysis. There is maybe a relationship between periods and thermal index such as min, max and mean temperature. This relationship can be adapted by regression methods.
Results and Discussion: The statistical analysis for prediction probabilities and return periods of the first frost dates for all synoptic stations in Khorasan Razavi province and the relationship between annual temperature indicators and this phenomenon is the aim of this article. The origin date of this phenomenon is March 21. First, data were screened. Then basic hypothesis test were applied which including the Runtest (randomness), the Mann-Whitney test (homogeneity and jump), the Wald-Wolfowitz test (independence and stationary), the Grubbs and Beck test (detection Outliers) and the three sigma methods (Outlier). The results were: 1-The Sabzevar, Mashhad and Gonabad had lower Outliers that will not cause any problem in data analysis by their skewness. The first frost data of all station were without upper outlier. 2- The independence of all stations was accepted at the 10% level. 3-All stations were Randomness, Independence and homogeneous and lack of jump. Eight probability distributions (Normal, Gumbel type 1, 2-parameter gamma, 2 and 3 parameters log-normal, the generalized Pareto, the generalized extreme values and the Pearson type 3) were applied. The skewness coefficients for all stations were more than 0.1 so Normal distribution was rejected. Also the7 methods of estimation (five different methods of moments, maximum likelihood and maximum entropy methods) were used. The ks fit test was applied. The ks for some stations were closed together at several estimations methods. The results are as follows: GPA (4 times), PT3 (4 times), LN2 (4 times), GA2 (3 times). Generalized Pareto distribution had the best fitted to data (60% of cases compared to the other functions). The results significantly indicated that the occurrence of first frost on the first day of process is in place. The first frost in the period of 2 years at all stations, not occur earlier than Aban(October 28). The 100-year return period event does not occur earlier than first of Mehr(September 22). There is no significant relationship between first frost in the period of 2 years with other factors such as altitude, latitude, longitude, temperature and precipitation as well.
Conclusion: Date of the first fall frost is one of the unfavorite climate influences that cause reduction in crop products. The purpose of this paper is to analysis the frequency occurrence of first frost day in several Khorasan’s synoptic stations as study area. Screening and initial basic tests such as randomness homogenity, independence, etc. were done. Eight distribution function, namely Normal, Gumbel type 1, Gamma 2 parameters, Log normal 2 and 3 parameters, Generalized Pareto and Pearson type III were fitted to data with five probability distributions methods (Ordinary Moments, Maximum Likelihood method, Modified Moments, Probability Weighted Moment and Maximum Entropy). Goodness of fit test was Kolmogorove-Smirnov test. PWM and ModM methods revealed relatively superior results compared to the rest of methods. Generalized Pareto distribution had the best fitted to data (60% of cases compared to the other functions). The results significantly indicated that the occurrence of first frost on the first day of process is in place. The first frost in the period of 2 years at all stations, not occur earlier than Aban. The 100-year return period event does not occur earlier than first of Mehr. There is no significant relationship between first frost in the period of 2 years with other factors such as altitude, latitude, longitude, temperature and precipitation as well.

Keywords

first frost; Generalized Pareto Distribution; Probable Weighted Moments; Statistical Analysis

References

1- Alizadeh A., 2011. Climate and agricultural meteorology. Beh-Nashr. Iran. Mashhad.

2- Amirrghami N.R., Sanjari D. and Bozorgnia A. 2002. Elementary survey sampling. Mashhad University.

3- Baranet, V., Lews, Toby, 1987. Outliers in Statistical Data. John Wiley & Sons, 458 PP.

4- Hozhirpur Gh. and Alijani B. 2007. Frost Synoptic analysing of Ardabil province, Geography and Development, 10: 89-106. (In Persian).

5- Isazadeh Sh., Memarian M. H., Mirkani S.M. and Taghizadeh A. 2010. Frost Synoptic Analysis of East Azarbaigan Province, 14th Conference on Geophysics, 11-13 May 2010. Tehran. (In Persian)

6- Ismaili, R. and Adab H., 2010. Evaluation of late frosts changes of Khorasan in the future climate, Proceedings of the Fourth International Congress of the Islamic World Geographers, Iran. Zahedan. 27-25 Persian date Farvardin 2010. (In Persian with English abstract(

7- Kamali Gh.A., Hajam S. and Khairkhah A. 2008. The Assessment of Relationship between durabiling of the lost spring frost & apple production loss in Tehran, P. 2-17. Workshop frost, frost and ways of dealing with it. 30 April 2008 Administration of Meteorological Semnan province. Iran. Semnan. (In Persian with English abstract)

8- Mianabadi A., Mousavi- Baygi M., Sanai Nejad H. and Nezami A. 2009. Assessment and mapping of early autumn. late spring and winter freezing in Khorasan Razavi province using GIS, Journal of Water and Soil, 23(1):79-90. (In Persian with English abstract)

9- Noohi K., Pedram M., Sahraian F. and Kamali G.A. 2006. Analysis of first fall and last spring advectionand radiation-advection frosts in Azerbaijan provinces, Pajouhesh & Sazandegi. 75: 78-85. (In Persian with English abstract)

10- Noohi K., Sahraian F., Pedram F. and Sedaghat-kerdar A. 2007. Determination the no frost period by the dates of beginning and end of the advection and radiation frost in the region of Zanjan, Qazvin and Tehran. Journal of Science and Technology of Agriculture and Natural Resources, 46: 449-460.

11- Rahimi M., Hajjam, S., Khalili, A. and Kamali. G. A. 2007. Risk analysis of first and last frost occurrences in the central Alborz region. Iran. International Journal of climatology, 27(3): 349–356.

12- Rao, A., Khaled H. Hamed,Raton and Boca .2000. Flood Frequency Analysis, CRC Press LLC. 350 pp.

13- Rezaee-Pajand H. and Bozorgnia A. 2006. The gamma family and derived distributions applied in hydrology, Ferdowsi university press. Mashhad.

14- Rezaee-Pazhand H. 2001. Application of statistics and probability in water resources, Sokhan gostar. Iran. Mashhad.

15- Ricardo A. Maronna, R. Douglas Martin and V´ıctor J. Yohai.2006. Robust Statistics, Jhon Wiley.417pp.

16- Root TJ., Price JT., Hall KR., Schneider SH., Rosenzweig C. and Pounds JA. 2003 . Fingerprints of global warming on wild animals and plants, Nature (Lond) 421: 57–60)

17- Rosenberg NJ. and Myers RE. 1962.The nature of growing season frosting and along the Platte valley of Nebraska", Monthly Weather Review , 90: 471–478.

18- Stone R., Nicholls, N. and Hammer, G. 1996. Frost in NE Australia, trends and influence of phases of the Southern Oscillation".Journal of climate 9: 1896-1909.

19- Tavakoli M. and Hosseini M. 2006. evaluation indicators and the seasonal frost in Iran (Case Study Ekbatan station, Journal of Nivar, the new course No. 61, page 31. (In Persian with English abstract(

20- Thom H. C. S. and Shaw R. H. 1958. Climatological analysis of freeze data for Iowa, Monthly Weather Rev.86: 251-257.

21- Vincent LA., Peterson TC., Barros VR., Marino Mb., Rusticucci M., Carrasco G., Ramirez E., Alves LM., Ambrizzi T., Berrlato MA., Grimm AM., Marengo JA., Molion L., Moncunill DF., Rebello E., Anunciacao YMT., Quintana J., Santos JL., Baez J., Coronel G., Garcia J., Trebejo I., Bidegain M., Haylock MR. and Karoly D. 2005. Observed trends in indices of daily temperature extremes in South America 1960–2000, Journal of climate 18: 5011–5023.

22- www.razavimet.gov.ir

23- Yevjevich,V. 1972. Probability and Statistics in Hydrology,Water Resources PUB. 302pp.