Exploring the Conceptual Components of Organizational Silence and their Affecting Factors: a Mixed-methods Study

پژوهش نامه مدیریت تحول

Article 10, Volume 12, Autumn & Winter2021 - Serial Number 24, February 2021, Pages 229-262   

Document Type: Articles

DOI: 10.22067/tmj.2021.30739.0

Author

Hamid Erfanian Khanzadeh^*

Abstract

1- INTRODUCTION
Although employees' voice than their silence is more valuable to organizations in today's competitive and changing world, many employees prefer silence. Therefore, the organization is not capable of investigating and correcting its errors, which refers to a problem called organizational silence. In the experts’ opinion, if employees' mouths are silenced the minds of organizations producing organizational knowledge will be fossilized. Determining the organizational silence is much more complicated than identifying behaviors such as absenteeism or sabotage. Therefore, the question is that how the organizational silence is determined and what factors are considered signals for organizational silence. In this regard, the present study identifies the components of organizational silence and factors affecting these components.
2- THEORETICAL FRAMEWORK
Despite a 50-year time period of interest in identifying the concepts of organizational silence and voice, investigations indicated that most studies had focused on how employees' silence is formed and its causes. However, the organizational silence is beyond these concepts and more in-depth studies are needed to be understood. Organizational silence is a social phenomenon in which employees refuse to express their views and concerns about organizational problems. Silence does not mean not talking, not writing, or the like, but fleeting speeches and writings of no identity, trust, and authority. This phenomenon has destructive consequences for organizations, such as employees' worthlessness, reduced trust, motivation, satisfaction, commitment, and creativity, job turnover, lack of efficiency in organizational change processes, and flattery and distortion of reality. Organizational silence has diverse indices such as employees’ reluctance to talk about work issues, lack of sharing work information, fear of misunderstanding, absenteeism, not listening, having a negative approach, indifference to the organization affairs, constant negligence at work, unwillingness to convey bad news to top management, and Hiding problems due to fear of being victimized.
3- METHODOLOGY
This research is a mixed-methods study. In the qualitative phase, by conducting a content analysis on literature, the most important signs of organizational silence and its affecting factors were extracted. These signs were provided to 10 Delphi members for identifying the components of organizational silence. Among the eight identified characteristics, according to the experts’ opinions, six characteristics were finally selected as components of organizational silence. A 24-item Items questionnaire was designed for these components. Lavache’s content validity ratio (CVR) was used to evaluate the questionnaire’s validity. Since the calculated CVR values for all the items were greater than 0.62, the questionnaire’s validity was satisfactorily confirmed. The Cronbach's alpha coefficient of 0.731 also indicated its adequate reliability.
4- RESULTS & DISCUSSION
Out of eight characteristics identified for organizational silence, six components were finally selected as its components: Flattery, constant nagging and complaining about the situation, yes-manship, indifference to assigned tasks, decreased willingness to participate in none-compulsory activities, feeling frustrated and bored. In the second phase of Delphi, out of 11 identified factors, six were selected as the affecting factors: authoritarian and patriarchal leadership style, repressive organizational culture, low organizational commitment, bureaucratic and cumbersome rules and procedures, conservative personality of managers, tall organizational structure. In addition, five important consequences of organizational silence were identified to be the reduced effectiveness of organizational decisions, resistance to change, blocking the path of providing feedback, lack of analysis of ideas, increased dissatisfaction, and decreased organizational motivation. According to these findings and back to the research literature, adopting a systemic approach, the conceptual model of organizational silence was proposed.
5- CONCLUSIONS & SUGGESTIONS
What the clear is that, contrary to many people's beliefs, organizational silence has adverse effects on both the organization and employees. Indifferent employees resulted from ignoring their silence promote the mindset of being indifferent. As a result of such an attitude, employees will suffer from depression and other wellbeing problems. Organizational silence increases their stress and makes them feel guilty and overwhelmed by psychological problems.

Keywords

Conceptual model; Organizational silence; Silence Components; Affecting factors

References

Ahmadi, A.; Esmaeili, A., & Khazli, S. (2016). Presenting a model of structural equations for the relationship between organizational silence and organizational commitment with the mediating role of organizational justice in ghavamin bank, Quarterly Journal of Resource Management in Law Enforcement, Fourth Year. 1, pp 35-62. (In Persian)

Alvani, S. (2006). General management, Tehran, Nashr-e NeyPublications, 22nd edition. (In Persian)

Al-Rousan, M. A. M., & Omoush, M. M. (2018). The Effect of organizational silence on burnout: a field study on workers at jordanian five-star hotels. Journal of Management and Strategy, 9(3), 114-122.

Appelbaum, S.; Bartolomucci, Nicolas., & Girard, Ch. (2004). Organizational citizenship behavior: a case study of culture, leadership and trust, Management Decision, 42(1), 2004, 13-40.

Ardalan, M.; Ghanbari, S., & Mohammadi, M. (2015). Evaluating the role of transformational leadership in the emergence of organizational voice: an analysis of the mediating role of information and communication technology, Quarterly Journal of Information Technology Management Studies, Third Year, 11, Spring, 24-1. (In Persian)

Bazargan, A. (2008). An introduction to qualitative and mixed methods research ", Didar Publishing. (In Persian)

Bagheri, Gh.; Zarei, R., & Nik Aeen, M. (2012). Organizational silence (basic concepts and its development factors), ideal type of management, 1(1), Spring 2012, 47-58.

Bozorgniya Hosseyni, S., & Enayati, T. (2013). The Relationship between organizational silence and employee performance, ethics in science and technology quarterly, year 9, 4. (In Persian).

Cetin, A. (2020) organizational silence and organizational commitment: a study of turkish sport managers, annals of applies sport science, 8th Year, Issue 2.

Damghanian, H., & Roozban, F. (2015). Investigating the reason for employees' silence in relation to direct manager: application of mixed research, quarterly journal of organizational behavior studies, fourth year, 3, Fall, 195-174. (In Persian)

Danaeifard, H., & Fani, A. (2011). Explaining the role of organizational culture in organizational silence in the public sector, public management perspective, 8, Winter, 82-61. (In Persian)

Danaeifard, H., & Panahi, B. (2010). Analysis of job attitudes of employees of government organizations; explaining the atmosphere of organizational silence and the behavior of organizational silence, Transformation Management Research Journal; Second Year, 3, 19-2. (In Persian)

Farhadi, A.; Ghfouri, P., & Haghighi Kafash, M. (2015). The effect of transformational leadership style and organizational learning in reducing organizational silence, Journal of Transformation Management, Spring and Summer, Year 7, Issue 13. (In Persian)

Fernandez-Lores, S., & Gavilan, D. (2015). Affective commitment to the employer brand: development and validation of a scale, Business Research Quarterly (2016) 19, 40-54.

Greenberg, J., & Edwards, M. S. (2009). Voice and Silence in Organizations, Emerald Group Publishing, 2009, p16. Harlos, K. (2001). When organizational voice systems fail more on the deaf-ear syndrome and frustration effects, mcgill university, The Journal of Applied Behavioral Science, September, 323-342.

Hassani, S.; Ahmadi, S.; Sarmast, B., & Alodari, H. (2020). Designing a comprehensive model of organizational silence based on the five pillars of the organization in selected public universities in Tehran, Management of Government Organizations, 8(2), 97-112. (In Persian)

Hazen, Mary. A. (2006). Silences, perinatal loss, and polyphony: a post-modern perspective. Journal of Organizational Change Management, 19(2), 2006, pp. 237-249.  

Hutmire, J. L. (2016). meaningfulness of work as perceived by women from diverse social classes: a grounded theory exploration, College of Social and Behavioral Sciences, Walden University.

Karaca, H. (2013). An Expletory study on the impact of organizational silence in hierarchical organizations: Turkish National Police case, Turkish National Police Academy, European Scientific Journal, August 2013, 9(23), pp 37-50.

Korkmaz, E. (2018). The Relationship between organizational silence and allen-meyer organizational commitment model: a research in the health sector in Turkey, Bilecik Şeyh Edebali University Journal of Social Sciences Institute, 3, 200-213 .

Korkmaz, T., & Arpaci, E. (2009). Relationship of organizational citizenship behavior with emotional intelligence, Procedia Social and Behavioral Sciences, (2009) 2432–2435.

Li, Y., & Sun, J. M. (2015). Traditional chinese leadership and employee voice behavior: a cross-level examination. The Leadership Quarterly, 26(2), 172-189.

Morrison, El., & Milliken, J. F. (2000). Organizational silence: a barrier to change and development in a pluralistic world, new york university, Academy of Management Review, 25(4), 2000, 700-725.

Nasr Esfahani, A. (2010). Flattery in the organization, organizational culture management, Year 8, No. 22, Fall and Winter, 114-95. (In Persian)

Nielsen, Richard P. (2003). Why do we remain silent in the face of unethical behavior, the church in the 21st century  from crisis to renewal, Boston College Occasional Paper,7.

Penttila, C. (2003). It’s a sad fact of downturns: employees stop speaking their minds, Entrepreneur Magazine, November 1, 2003.

Pinder Craig C., & Harlos Karen, P. (2001). Employee silence: quiescence and acquiescence as responses to perceived injustice. research in personnel and human resources management, 20, 331-369.

Pirannejad, A.; Davari, E., & Afkhami, M. (2017). Organizational silence, the contemporary challenge of human resource management; identifying its factors and consequences, Quarterly Journal of Organizational Behavior Studies, Year 6, Issue 1 (26) Spring, 47-176. (In Persian)

Podsakoff, Philip M., & MacKenzie, Scott B. (2000). Organizational citizenship behaviors: a critical review of the theoretical and empirical literature and suggestions for future research. indiana university, Journal of Management, 2000, 26(3), 513–563.

Rastegar, A., & Roozban, F. (2014). Identifying the factors affecting organizational silence by descriptive mixed method of participant selection, Quarterly Journal of Management of Government Organizations, 8, 8-8. (In Persian)

Rezabeygi, S., & Almasi, D. (2014). Organizational silence: a dangerous phenomenon in the way of the organizational progress, International Journal of Sciences: Basic and Applied Research (IJSBAR) (3)

Slade, M. R. (2008). The adaptive nature of organizational silence: a cybernetic exploration of the hidden factory, the george washington university, ProQuest Dissertations Publishing.

Sutton, R. I. (2010). Good Boss, Bad Boss first edition, September 2010, Hachette bookgroup Publishers.

Tinuke Fapohunda, M. (2016). Organizational silence: predictors and consequences among university academic staff, International Journal for Research in Social Science and Humanities Research, 2(1), 83-103.

Vakola, M., & Bouradas, D. (2005). Antecedents and consequences of organizational silence: an empirical investigation, Employee Relations, 27(5), 2005, 441-458.

Van Dyne, L.; & Ang, S., & Botero, Isabel C. (2003). Conceptualizing employee silence and employee voice as multidimensional constructs, Journal of Management Studies 40:6 September 2003, pp 1359-1392.

Van Dyne, L., & Lepine, J. (1998). Helping and voice extra-role behaviors: evidence of construct and predictive validity. michigan state university, Academy of Management Journal, 1998, 41(1), 108-119.

Xu, A. J.; Loi, R., & Lam, L. W. (2015). The bad boss takes it all: how abusive supervision and leader–member exchange interacts to influence employee silence. The Leadership Quarterly, 26(5), 763-774.

Yıldız, E. (2013). Enigma of silence in organizations: what happens to whom and why? sakarya university, institute of social sciences, Beykent University Journal of Social Sciences, 6(2), 2013, 30-44.

Zarei Matin, H.; Taheri, F., & Sayar, A. (2011). Organizational silence, concepts, causes and consequences, Iranian Journal of Management Sciences, 6(21), Spring, 104-77. (In Persian)

Zahed Babalan, A.; Ahmadi, H., & Seyed Kalan, S. (2015). Organizational silence alert in higher education: identifying the causing factors among the staff of mohaghegh ardabili university, Quarterly Journal of Leadership Research and Educational Management, First Year, 4, 129-151(In Persian)