Comparison of Independence Referendum in Iraqi Kurdistan and Spanish Cataloni

پژوهش نامه ایرانی سیاست بین الملل

Article 3, Volume 9, Issue 2 - Serial Number 18, September 2021, Pages 64-96   

Document Type: مقالات

DOI: 10.22067/irlip.2021.21229.0

Authors

GhorbanAli Ghorbanzadeh Savar¹; mohammad hasanzadeh^{* 2}

¹2. Assistance professor of political science, Imam Khomeini International University

²Imam Khomeini International University

Abstract

One demand of ethnic and linguistic minorities in some countries is political independence. Kurds and Catalans in Iraq and Spain are among the minorities who held the independence referendum in 2017. The present study compares the two referendums regarding the fields, process, results, and outcomes. In various dimensions, using the analytical-comparative method, the findings show few similarities and significant differences between the two referendums in terms of historical, political, economic conditions. In terms of the holding process, both started with the exact mechanism, but during the holding, they differed sharply due to the different approaches of the two central governments of Iraq and Spain. In terms of results, the two referendums are similar regarding the ratio of positive votes to independence. In terms of outcome, both Iraqi Kurdistan and Spanish Catalonia faced similar negative consequences such as political isolation, lack of international support, economic problems, etc. Still, there is no consensus on how and to what extent these consequences affected local, national, and international levels. They are different due to the set of intra-systemic components such as the internal situation of Kurdistan/ Iraq and Catalonia/ Spain and extra-systemic components such as the interests of regional and global powers in these two areas of the referendum.

Keywords

Referendum; Autonomy; Independence; Federal System; Iraqi Kurdistan; Spanish Catalonia

References

Abalas, A. (1998). The Kurdish Movement. translated by I. Fattah Ghazi. Tehran: Negah.
Abdullah, K. (2005). Based on the Geographical Theory of Coins in South Kurdistan.
Second ed. Solaimaniyeh: Ministry of Enlightenment.
Abedi, A. (2017A). A look at the west's position in the face of the Iraqi kurdistan
referendum. A Publication of the Strategic Thought Institute. (in Persian)
Abedi, A. (2017B). Russia and the Iraqi Kurdistan Referendum. Strategic Research Center.
Vice President for Research. Report 305. (in Persian)
Ahmadi, K. (2005). Weak social, political cohesion and geopolitical problems in Iraq after
the fall of Baghdad. Tehran: Ministry of Foreign Affairs Publications. (in Persian)
Ali Mahmoud, M. (2017). Catalonia and Kurdistan in warm autumn. Erbil.
Alice, H. (2007). The demands of the Kurds to form a government and future of the Kurds.
translated by A.M. Haji Yousefi and M. Entezam. Tehran: Ministry of Foreign Affairs
Publications.
Ansari, V. (1999). Generalities of Administrative Law, Vol. 3, Tehran: Mizan. (in Persian)
Aqabakhshi, A. (1997). Dictionary of political science. Tehran: Iran Scientific Information
and Documentation Center. (in Persian)
Ardalan, A. (1996). The Dream of Kurdish Government. Unpublished Master Thesis. Imam
Sadegh (AS) University. (in Persian)
Arfa, H. (2003). Kurds; A historical and political study. translated by M.R. Moradi. Tehran:
Anna. (in Persian)
Arfa, H. (2012). The process of government-nation-building in the new Iraq and the
national security of the Islamic Republic of Iran. Tehran: Noor Institute of Thought
Studies. (in Persian)
Ashouri, D. (1999). Political Encyclopedia, Tehran: Morvarid. (in Persian)
Ashouri, D. (2009). National identity and nationalization project; in Questions and
Questions. Tehran: Agahi. (in Persian)
Azizi, A. (2017). Do's and Don'ts of Legitimacy of the Separation of the Kurdistan Region
in International Law. Qanunyayar, (3), 75-98. (in Persian)
Bahrampour, K. (1993). The problem of decentralization in Iran and suggestions for its
realization. Public Management Quarterly, (20). (in Persian)
Barazesh, M. (2010). Familiarity with the countries of the world. Spain. Tehran: Amirkabir .
(in Persian)
Barzegar, K. (2006). Foreign policy in new Iraq. Tehran: Strategic Research Center. (in Persian)

Calmet, J. (1989). History of Spain. translated by A. Moezzi, Tehran: Ashna.
Dorty, L. (1968). The land and people of Spain. translated by Shamsuddin Masaheb.
Tehran: Book Translation and Publishing Company.
Euronews network. (2017).
Ghazi Shariat Panahi, A. (2001). Essentials of constitutional rights. Fourth ed., Tehran:
Edalatghostar. (in Persian)
Ghorbaninejad, R. (2008). A comparative study of the model of self-government of Iraqi
Kurdistan with the model of autonomy and eederalism. Unpublished Master Thesis.
Tarbiat Modares University. (in Persian)
Imani, N. (2000). Referendum and its reason. Tehran: Resalat Magazine. (in Persian)
Isa Saleh, M. (2000). The crisis of the great powers in Iraqi Kurdistan. Tehran: Tavakoli.
Jazayeri, A. (2017). Iraqi Kurdistan referendum. Causes. positions and consequences.
Basair Magazine. Center for Strategic Studies. AJA Political Deputy. 53-80. (in Persian)
Karami, J. (1997). Developments in Northern Iraq in the 1990s. Defense Policy Quarterly,
(20-21). (in Persian)
Khoobrooyi, M. (1998). A critique of federalism. Tehran: Shirazeh. (in Persian)
Khoshakhlaq, M. (1998). A critique of federalism. Tehran: Shirazeh. (in Persian)
Khosravi, A. (2014). An overview of independence tendencies in catalonia. Spain; Roots
and Future Trends. Journal of Identity Studies, Vol. 1, (9), 59-52. (in Persian)
Khosravi, A. (2016). An overview of separatist tendencies in Europe; Roots and Trends.
Quarterly Journal of Public Policy, Vol. 6, (21), 145-164. (in Persian)
McDowell, D. (2004). Contemporary Kurdish History. translated by E .Younesi. Tehran:
Paniz.
Moin, M. (2002). Dictionary. fourth ed., Tehran: Ensha. (in Persian)
NRT TV network. (2017).
Omidi, A. (2006). Receipt and expansion of the right to self-determination in international
law. Journal of the Vice President for Legal Affairs, Year 35, 225-250. (in Persian)
Rodavo News Agency. (2007).
Simbar, M. (1999). Stateless nations in the world community. Foreign Policy Quarterly,
Year 13, (4), 1108-1132. (in Persian)
Spanish Television. )2017(.
Sputnik News Agency. (2017).
The Guardian Newspaper. (2017)

Walordo, F. (1989). The millennial history of catalonia. Translated by M. Ahmadi.
UNESCO Message. (228). 28-40.
Wassily, N. (1999). Kurds and Kurdistan. third ed. translated by M. Ghazi. Tehran: Tact
Publishing Cultural Center.
Xinhua News Agency. (2017).
Zahmatkash, H. & Hekmatnejad, N. (2014). An autopsy of the cultural, linguistic and
political movement of Catalonia. Quarterly Journal of Politics, Vol. 44, No. 2, 389-371.
(in Persian)
Zargar, A. (2006). Fighting Catalonia and New Nationalizations in Europe by Referendum
Mechanism, Diplomatic Fellowship, Vol. 1, (4). (in Persian)