Determination of the Integrated Water-Economy-Environment Index for Regional Water Resource Allocations in Iranian Provinces

اقتصاد و توسعه منطقه ای

Article 3, Volume 28, Issue 21, October 2021, Pages 41-74   

Document Type: Original Article

DOI: 10.22067/erd.2021.69591.1028

Authors

Mohammad hadi Akbarzadeh¹; Masoud Khodapanah^{* 2}; Mansour Zarra-Nezhad³

¹PhD Candidate in Economics, Faculty of Economics and Social Sciences, Shahid Chamran University of Ahvaz, Ahvaz, Iran.

²Associate Professor of Economics, Faculty of Economics and Social Sciences, Shahid Chamran University of Ahvaz, Ahvaz, Iran.

³Professor of Economics, Faculty of Economics and Social Sciences, Shahid Chamran University of Ahvaz, Ahvaz, Iran.

Abstract

Extended abstract
1- INTRODUCTION
Sustainable development is defined as a form of development process that meets the current human requirements without affecting the ability of future generations to cover their needs. Water is considered an essential resource for food and industrial productions, environmental protection, and a key irreplaceable requirement to sustainable development. Accordingly, policymaking for water sector in any region requires taking into account the principals of sustainable development and integration in allocation of the water resources. Integrated water resource allocation is usually defined as a process that promotes the coordinated development and allocation of water, land and related resources, in order to meet the resultant economic and social welfare without compromising the sustainability of vital ecosystems. A review of the history of water policymaking and allocation of water resources proves that Iran like many countries around the globe is suffering from a multidimensional complex socio-economic and environmental drought that is the consequence of mismanagement, hasty, and uncoordinated water policymaking as the result of a misunderstanding of sustainable development and integration concepts. A review of studies conducted in Iran indicated that there are still no quantitative and analytical criteria for assessing the situation and decision-making in the form of an integrated system for the allocation of regional water resources. Water policymaking and allocation of resources in Iran is conducted without considering the capability and capacity of water resources in different provinces and also without paying any attention to the inseparable connection between water and other socio-economic, agricultural, technology, transportation, and environmental elements. In order to achieve regional water security as well as to achieve regional sustainability, there is an urgent need to develop an integrated water-economy-environment system as a mechanism for the regional integrated allocation of water resources in Iranian provinces.
2- THEORETICAL FRAMEWORK
One of the solutions to water shortages which is introduced by Allan (1998) for west of Asia was the virtual water strategy which is usually known as "virtual water trade" in the literature. The virtual water trade is originally rooted in Heckscher- Ohlin- Samuelson relative advantage theory. This strategy believed that the main solution to water scarcity is to import grain instead of growing grain regionally. Although the idea of virtual water trading is inherently an economic concept; many economists have criticized the virtual water strategy as fallacious failing to take socio-economic, environmental sustainability into account. In response to the critics, many studies believe that there is an urgent need for an integrated water-economy-environment index system in allocation of regional water resources. This evaluation index system takes into account the co-relationship among various components of the economy, society, resources, technology, transportation, and environment as well.        
 
3- METHODOLOGY
The purpose of this study was to determine the integrated water-economy-environment index for regional policymaking using a comprehensive fuzzy evaluation system and Shannon entropy weighting method in Iranian provinces. For this purpose, after determination the water-economy-environment index based on the latest theoretical and experimental foundations in the field of water resources, the integrated water-economy-environment index was estimated for 31 Iranian provinces. The integrated water-economy-environment index has five main components including water resources, technology, transportation, economy, society, and environment, respectively. Finally, the radar diagrams and geographic maps were used to analyze the spatial distribution of the total water-economy-environment index and its main components.
4- RESULTS & DISCUSSIONS
According to the results of the study Ardabil, Kerman, South Khorasan, Semnan, Sistan and Baluchestan, Fars, Qazvin, Markazi, and Yazd had slightly poor status in the water resource component. Moreover, from the social perspective of the water-economy-environment index South Khorasan, Zanjan, and Hormozgan were classified as slightly poor while North Khorasan, Kermanshah, and Lorestan were poor provinces. On the other hand, most of the Iranian provinces had slightly poor and average situations in the economic component of regional integrated water-economy-environment index. Besides Ilam and Kohgiluyeh and Boyer Ahmad were identified as slightly poor in the technology and transportation component while South Khorasan, Sistan and Baluchestan, Qazvin, and Kermanshah were classified as slightly poor provinces in the environment component of the integrated water-economy-environment index. In addition, based on the results of the total water-economy-environment index, Gilan, Mazandaran, Chaharmahaal & Bakhtiari, and Khuzestan provinces can be suggested as the most suitable provinces for implementation of the virtual water strategy. In other provinces of the country, depending on the situation of the main components and sub-indicators in each of the dimensions of integrated water- economy-environment index including water resources, technology, transportation, economic, social, and environmental components there is a vital need to adopt an appropriate water policy in consistence with the specific conditions in that province.
5- CONCLUSIONS & SUGGESTIONS
Based on the results of the study the integrated water-economy-environment index can be suggested as an effective instrument for allocation of water resources in Iranian provinces. Virtual water strategy in provinces with scarce water resources can be considered as a potential alternative for facing regional water scarcity in Iranian provinces. Due to the scarcity of water resources and budget constraints as well as various situations in Iranian provinces the integrated water-economy-environment policymaking should be conducted regionally and based on the weakness or strength of each province in water resources, economic, social, technology, and environment components. On the other hand, weak provinces in Iran should prohibit water intensive economic activities and persuade the development of second and third-hand water intensive activities and service sector. Finally, it is recommended to policymakers to use regional integrated water-economy-environment index based on regional components and provincial capacities in Iranian provinces. It is also recommended to researchers to examine more detailed assessments of the integrated water-economy-environment index on longer periods in Iranian provinces.

Keywords

Integrated Index; Regional water resources; Shannon Entropy; Fuzzy Comprehensive Evaluation Method; Iranian provinces

Supplementary Files

chkide 21.pdf

References

References

Abu-Sharar, T. M.; Al-Karablieh, E. K. & Haddadin, M. J. (2012). Role of Virtual Water in Optimizing Water Resources Management in Jordan. Water resources management, 26(14), 3977-3993.

 Allan, J. A. (1997). 'Virtual water': A Long-Term Solution for Water Short Middle Eastern economies? (pp. 24-29). London: School of Oriental and African Studies, University of London.

Allan, J. A. (2003). Virtual Water-the Water, Food, and Trade Nexus. Useful Concept or Misleading Metaphor? Water International, 28(1), 106-113.

Amoori Z.; Bordbar, A. & Heidanejad, M. (2014). 'Quantity and Quality Evaluation of Virtual water trade in Iran (Case study of Khuzestan province), International Journal of Geology, Agriculture and Environmental Sciences, Volume 2, Issue 1, February, 2014.

Ansink, E. (2010). Refuting Two Claims about Virtual Water Trade, Ecological Economics, 69(10), 2027-2032.

Arabi Yazdi, A.; Alizadeh, A. & Mohammadian, F. (2009). Study of ecological water footprint in Iran's agricultural sector, Journal of Water and Soil (Agricultural Sciences and Industries), Volume 23, Number 4, Winter, 2009, pp. 15-1 (in Persian).

Arya, V. & Kumar, S. (2020). Knowledge measure and entropy: a complementary concept in fuzzy theory, Granular Computing, 1-13.

Azadi-Nejad, A.; Amadeh, H. & Emami Meybodi, A. (2010). Effective factors in technical efficiency of the industrial sector in Iranian provinces, Economic Research, Volume 49, 1, pp. 173-188 (in Persian).

Bakhshoodeh, M. & Dehghanpur, H. (2016). Modeling Crop Cultivation Pattern Based on Virtual Water Trade: Evidence from Marvdasht in Southern Iran. Iran Agricultural Research, 34(2), 29-34.

Cai, B.; Zhang, W., Hubacek, K.; Feng, K.; Li, Z.; Liu, Y. & Liu, Y. (2019). Drivers of Virtual Water Flows on Regional Water Scarcity in China. Journal of Cleaner Production, 207, 1112-1122.

Caldera, U.; Bogdanov, D., Fasihi, M., Aghahosseini, A. & Breyer, C. (2020). Securing future water supply for Iran through 100% renewable energy powered desalination. International Journal of Sustainable Energy Planning and Management, 23, pp 36-89.

Chen, G. Q., & Li, J. S. (2015). Virtual water assessment for Macao, China: highlighting the role of external trade. Journal of Cleaner Production, 93, 308-317.

Cui, X.; Wu, X., He, X., Li, Z., Shi, C., & Wu, F. (2018). Regional Suitability of Virtual Water Strategy: Evaluating with an Integrated Water-Ecosystem-Economy Index, Cleaner Production, 199, 659-667.

Darbandsari, P.; Kerachian, R., & Malakpour-Estalaki, S. (2017). An Agent-based behavioral simulation model for residential water demand management: The case-study of Tehran, Iran, Simulation Modelling Practice and Theory, 78, 51-72.

Delgado, A., & Romero, I. (2017). Environmental Conflict Analysis Using an Integrated Grey Clustering and Entropy-Weight Method: A Case Study of a Mining Project in Peru, Environmental Modelling & Software, 77, 108-121.

Duarte, R.; Pinilla, V., & Serrano, A. (2016). Understanding Agricultural Virtual Water Flows in the World from an Economic Perspective: A Long-Term Study. Ecol. Indicators 2016, 61, 980-990.

El-Sadek, A. (2012). Virtual Water: An Effective Mechanism for Integrated Water Resources Management, Agricultural Sciences, 2(03), 248.

Faramarzi, M., Yang, H., Mousavi, J., Schulin, R., Binder, C. R., & Abbaspour, K. C. (2010). Analysis of intra-country virtual water trade strategy to alleviate water scarcity in Iran. Hydrology and Earth System Sciences, 14(8), 1417-1433.

Friesen, J.; Sinobas, L. R., Foglia, L., & Ludwig, R. (2017). Environmental and social-economic methodologies and solutions towards integrated water resources management, 906-908.

Garrick, D. E., Hanemann, M., & Hepburn, C. (2020). Rethinking the economics of water: an assessment. Oxford Review of Economic Policy, 36(1), 1-23.

Gawel, E., & Bernsen, K. (2013). What is wrong with Virtual Water Trading? On the Limitations of the Virtual Water Concept, Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy, 31(1), 168-181.

Gong, L., & Jin, C. (2016). Fuzzy comprehensive evaluation for carrying capacity of regional water resources, Water resources management, 23(12), 2505-2513.

Haak, L., & Pagilla, K. (2020). The water-economy nexus: a composite index approach to evaluate urban water vulnerability. Water Resources Management, 34(1), 409-423.

Hoekstra, A. Y., Karandish, F. & Hogeboom, R. J., (2021). Physical versus virtual water transfers to overcome local water shortages: A comparative analysis of impacts, Water Resources, 147, 103811.

Holmberg, J., & Sandbrook, R. (2019). Sustainable development: what is to be done? Policies for a small planet (pp. 19-38). Routledge.

Islamic & Iranian Center of Progress (2016). Iran's water resources management: challenges and strategies, Water Institute, Environment, Food Security and Natural Resources, 2016 (In Persian).

Ismaili-Fard, M. & Kaveh F. H. (2017). Pathology of water policy in Iran, Quarterly Journal of Social and Cultural Strategy, Fifth Year, No. 21, Winter 2017, pp. 169-197 (in Persian).

139. Reimer. J. (2012). On the Economics of Virtual Water Trade, Ecological
     Economics, 75:135-139.

Jalil-Pir, H. (2012). The role of water pricing in the agricultural sector on the balance of water resources, Economic Journal, Monthly Review of Economic Issues, No. 2, May 2012, 128-119 (in Persian).

Jia, S.; Long, Q., & Liu, W. (2017). The Fallacious Strategy of Virtual Water Trade. International Journal of Water Resources Development, 33(2), 340-347.

Joodaki, G., Wahr, J., & Swenson, S. (2014). Estimating the human contribution to groundwater depletion in the Middle East, from GRACE data, land surface models, and well observations, Water Resources Research, 50(3), 2679-2692.

Kacprzak, D. (2017). Objective weights based on ordered fuzzy numbers for fuzzy multiple criteria decision-making methods. Entropy, 19(7), 373.

Karamouz, M., Yazdi, M. S., Ahmadi, B., & Zahraie, B. (2011). A system dynamics approach to economic assessment of water supply and demand strategies. In World Environmental and Water Resources Congress 2011: Bearing Knowledge for Sustainability (pp. 1194-1203).

Katyaini, S., Barua, A., & Duarte, R. (2020). Science-policy interface on water scarcity in India: Giving ‘visibility’to unsustainable virtual water flows (1996–2014). Journal of Cleaner Production, 275, 124059.

Khalili, d. (2016). Challenges facing water resources management in drought conditions in Iran, Journal of Strategic Research in Agricultural Sciences and Natural Resources, 1, 2, pp. 149-164 (in Persian).

Liu, J., Hull, V., Batistella, M., DeFries, R., Dietz, T., Fu, F., ... & Zhu, C. (2013). Framing sustainability in a telecoupled world. Ecology and Society, 18(2).

Madani, K. (2014). Water management in Iran: what is causing the looming crisis? Journal of environmental studies and sciences, 4(4), 315-328.

Madani, K. Amir A. & Ali Mirchi (2016). Iran’s Socio-economic Drought: Challenges of a Water-Bankrupt Nation, Iranian Studies, 49:6, 997-1016.

Majerník, V. (2014). Entropy—A universal concept in sciences. Natural Science, 2014.

Manshadi, H. D., Niksokhan, M. H., & Ardestani, M. (2015). A quantity-quality model for inter-basin water transfer system using game theoretic and virtual water approaches. Water Resources Management, 29(13), 4573-4588.

Merrett, S. (2003). Virtual Water and the Kyoto Consensus: A Water Forum Contribution. Water International, 28(4), 540-542.

Mohammadi-Kanigolzar, F., Ameri, J. D., & Motee, N. (2014). Virtual Water Trade as a Strategy to Water Resource Management in Iran. Journal of Water Resource and Protection, 6(02), 141.

Mohammad-Jani A. & Yazdanian N. (2014). Analysis of the water crisis in Iran and its management requirements, Ravand Quarterly Journal, Volume 21, Numbers 65 & 66, 2014, pp. 117-144 (in Persian).

Mousavi, S. N., Akbari, S. M. R., Soltani, Gh,. & M. Zarei (2010). Virtual water, a new strategy to deal with water crisis, The First National Conference on Water Crisis Management, March 2010 (in Persian).

Nasrollahi, M., Khosravi, H., Moghaddamnia, A., Malekian, A., & Shahid, S. (2018). Assessment of drought risk index using drought hazard and vulnerability indices.  Journal of Geosciences, 11(20), 1-12.

Nasrollahi, Z. & Zarei, M. (2018). "Study of virtual water flows in Iran's economy: analysis of water sector relationships using output data approach", Quarterly Journal of Econometric Modeling, Volume 2, Issue 4, Fall 2018 (in Persian).

Nguyen, T. D., Edenhofer, O., Grimalda, G., Jakob, M., Klenert, D., Schwerhoff, G., & Siegmeier, J. (2018). Policy options for a socially balanced climate policy. G20 Insights. T20 Task Force on Global Inequality and Social Cohesion.

Pires, A., Morato, J., Peixoto, H., Botero, V., Zuluaga, L. (2017). Sustainability Assessment of indicators for integrated water resources management. Science of the total environment, 578, 139-147.

Pouran, R. Raghfar H. Ghasemi, A. & Bazazan, F. (2018). Calculating the economic value of virtual water using maximizing irrigation water efficiency approach", Iranian Journal of Water Economics, Volume 6, Number 21, Spring 2018. pp. 189-212 (in Persian).

Qasemipour, E., & Abbasi, A. (2020). Virtual water flow and water footprint assessment of an arid region: A case study of South Khorasan province, Iran. Water, 11(9), 1755.

Qudusi, H. & Davari H. (2017). Critical analysis of virtual water from a policy perspective. Water and Sustainable Development, 3 (1), 47-58 (in Persian).

Razavi, S. & Davari, K. (2014). The role of virtual water management in Iran water resources management, Water and Sustainable Development, Volume 1, No. 1, March 2014, pp. 9-18 (in Persian).

Roodposhti, M., Aryal, J., Shahabi, H., & Safarrad, T. (2016). Fuzzy shannon entropy: A hybrid gis-based landslide susceptibility mapping method. Entropy, 18(10), 343.

Runkler, T. A. (1997). Selection of appropriate defuzzification methods using application specific properties. IEEE transactions on fuzzy systems, 5(1), 72-79.

Sartori, M., Schiavo, S., Fracasso, A., & Riccaboni, M. (2017). Modeling the Future Evolution of the Virtual Water TradeN: A combination of Network and Gravity Models. Water Resources, 110, 538-548.

Sarvin., Etaei, S., & Montaseri, M. (2021). Development of hydro-social-economic-environmental sustainability index (HSEESI) in integrated water resources management. Environmental Monitoring and Assessment, 193(8), 1-29.

Shannon, C. E. (2001). A Mathematical Theory of Communication. SIGMOBILE Mob Comput Commun Rev, 5 (1): 3–55.

Siddique, Muhammad. "Fuzzy decision making using max-min, MMR methods." (2009).

Sun, S., Wang, Y., Engel, B. A., & Wu, P. (2016). Effects of Virtual Water Flow on Regional Water Resources Stress: A Case Study of Grain in China. Science of the Total Environment, 550, 871-879.

Tahamipour, M. Abbas, S. & Arab Mazar, A. (2015). "Virtual water trade pattern in economic activities of Gilan province: application of augmented input-output tables, Quarterly Journal of Environmental Sciences, Volume 13, Issue 3, Fall 2015 (in Persian).

Talon, A., & Curt, C. (2017). Selection of appropriate defuzzification methods: Application to the assessment of dam performance. Expert Systems with Applications, 70, 160-174.

Tomislav, K. (2018). The concept of sustainable development: From its beginning to the contemporary issues. Zagreb International Review of Economics & Business, 21(1), 67-94.

Van der Voort, N., & Vanclay, F. (2015). Social impacts of earthquakes caused by gas extraction in the Province of Groningen, The Netherlands, Environmental Impact Assessment Review, 50, 1-15.

Wang, Z., Zhang, L., Zhang, Q., Wei, Y. M., Wang, J. W., Ding, X., & Mi, Z. (2019). Optimization of Virtual Water Flow via Grain Trade within China. Ecological Indicators, 97, 25-34

Wichelns, D. (2004). The Policy Relevance of Virtual Water Can Be Enhanced by Considering Comparative Advantages. Agricultural Water Management, 66(1), 49-63.

Wu, D. S., Feng, X., & Wen, Q. Q. (2011). The Research of Evaluation for Growth Suitability of Carya Cathayensis Sarg. Based on PCA and AHP. Procedia Engineering, 15, 1879-1883.

www.amar.org.ir

www.doe.ir

www.iwmi.cgiar.org

Yang, H.; Zehnder, A.J. (2002). Water Scarcity and Food Import: A Case Study for Southern Mediterranean Countries, World Development, 2002, 30, 1413-1430.

Ye, W., Xu, X., Wang, H., Wang, H., Yang, H., & Yang, Z. (2016). Quantitative assessment of resources and environmental carrying capacity in the northwest temperate continental climate ecotope of China. Environmental Earth Sciences, 75(10), 868.

Zadeh, L. A. (2015). Fuzzy logic—a personal perspective, Fuzzy sets and systems, 281, 4-20.

Zulqarnain, R. M., Xin, X. L., Saeed, M., & Ahmed, N. (2020). Application of Interval Valued Fuzzy Soft Max-Min Decision Making Method in Medical Diagnosis. International Journal of Pharmaceutical Sciences Review and Research, 62(1), 56-60.