Water Ethics

آب و توسعه پایدار

Article 7, Volume 9, Issue 4 - Serial Number 26, March 2023, Pages 59-76   

Document Type: Review Article

DOI: 10.22067/jwsd.v9i4.2206.1160

Author

Masoud Rezaei^*

Associate Professor, Department of Natural Sciences, Institute for Humanities and Cultural Studies, Tehran, Iran

Abstract

Water consumption grew twice as fast as the global population last century, and an increasing number of regions around the world are facing or will face, water scarcity. Access to water has been recognized as a major threat to world peace in the present century, and ethical issues related to water have been given high priority. Using a systematic review method, this paper examines the three fundamental perspectives of deontology, consequentialism, and virtue ethics in environmental philosophy and their implications for water management and policy-making. Each of the three perspectives has led to the emergence of different ethical approaches to water, but what is clear is that in all three perspectives anthropocentric view has prevailed and moral considerations about non-humans have received less attention. In addition, ethical approaches to water face weaknesses, and water management requires an integrated and holistic approach that integrates humans and aquatic ecosystems and avoids unilateralism.

Keywords

Water; Ethic; Anthropocentrism; Non-anthropocentrism

Supplementary Files

7-2206.1160.pdf

References

اکبرزاده، پ. و کابلی، ح. 1396. ارزیابی اثرات اقتصادی-اجتماعی سدسازی و تأثیر آن بر نظام بهره‌برداری سنتی (مطالعه موردی: سد سیازاخ شهرستان دیواندره). جغرافیا و پایداری محیط، 23: 53-65. 
امامقلی زاده، ص. و رئیسی، م. 1391. فرهنگ مصرف آب از دیدگاه اسلام و قرآن و راهکارهای بهبود آن. نشریه علمی-تخصصی مهندسی فرهنگی، 6(63 و 64): 29-47.
امینی، ک.، ویسی، ف. و محمدی، س. 1397. تحلیل و تبیین اثرهای احداث سدها بر معیشت پایدار نواحی روستایی (نمونه موردی: سد داریان هورامان)، فصلنامه مطالعات راهبردی سیاست‌گذاری عمومی، 8(27): 155-176. 
فروزانی، پ. 1398. مدیریت آب از دیدگاه قرآن. دانشنامه پژوهه، پژوهشکده باقرالعلوم، تهران. 
محمدی، ز. و یزدان‌پناه، م. 1394. آب و اهمیت حفاظت آن از دیدگاه قران کریم. اولین همایش ملی رهیافت‌های علوم کشاورزی در قرآن. دانشگاه کشاورزی و منابع طبیعی رامین، اهواز.
Abdusalam Alghwail, A.D. 2019. Environmental Ethics of Water Resources Management. China-USA Business Review, 18(1): 44-49.
Al-Awar F., Abdulrazzak M.J. and Al-Weshah R. 2010. Water Ethics Perspectives in the Arab Region. In book: Water Ethics: Foundational Readings for Students and Professionals. Island Press. Washington, DC, USA. 
Alvaro, C. 2018. Environmental Ethics: The Virtuous Way. Agricultural Research and Technology: Open Access Journal, 17(2): 1-3. 
Armstrong C. 2017. Justice and Natural Resources: An Egalitarian Theory. Oxford University Press. Oxford, UK.  
Attfield R. 2018. Environmental Ethics: A Very Short Introduction. Oxford University Press. Oxford, UK. 
Beatley T. 2021. The Ethics of Blue Urbanism. In book: Ethical Water Stewardship, Springer, Switzerland.
Bernard P.S. 2010. Messages from the Deep – Water Divinities, Dreams and Diviners in Southern Africa. PhD thesis. Rhodes University. South Africa.
Bettany-Saltikov, J. 2012. How to do a Systematic Literature Review in Nursing: A step-by-step guide. Open University Press. England. 
Bickford A.L. 2021. Uses of Feminist Eco-Criticism for Water Policy. In book: Ethical Water Stewardship, Springer publishing. Switzerland.
Boelens R. 2021. Water justice: Blatant grabbing practices, subtle recognition politics and the struggles for fair water worlds. In book: Environmental Justice: key issues. Taylor and Francis. France.
Boelens R., Vos J. and Perreault T. 2018. Introduction: The Multiple Challenges and Layers of Water Justice Struggles. In book: Water Justice. Cambridge University Press. UK.
Brown G. and Schmidt J.J. 2010. Editors’ Introduction. In book: Water Ethics: Foundational Readings for Students and Professionals, Island Press. Washington, DC, USA.
Cafaro P. 2015. Environmental virtue ethics. In book: The Routledge Companion to Virtue Ethics. Routledge, England.
Caponera D.A. and Nanni M. 1992. Principles of water law and administration: national and international. CRC Press. second edition. Rotterdam, UK.
Chociej Z. and Adeel Z. 2012. Legal and Ethical Dimensions of a Right to Water. In book: The Global Water Crisis: Addressing an Urgent Security Issue. Hamilton, Canada. 
Dickson R., Cherry M.G. and Boland A. 2017. Carrying out a systematic review as a Master's thesis. In book: Doing a Systematic Review: A Student's Guide. 2nd edition. Sage Publication. London, UK.
Doorn N. 2019. Water Ethics: An Introduction. Rowman & Littlefield International Ltd. London, UK. 
Dursun S. and Mankolli H. 2021. The Value of Nature: Virtue Ethics Perspective. An Interdisciplinary Journal of Human Theory and Praxis, 4(1): 1-15.
Fioret C. 2021. The Ethics of Water: From Commodification to Common Ownership. Ph.D. thesis, The University of Guelph, Guelph. Ontario, Canada. 
Fisher F. and Huber-Lee A. 2005. Liquid Assets: An Economic Approach for Water Management and Conflict Resolution in the Middle East and Beyond, Resources for the Future Press. Washington, DC, USA. 
Foltz R.C. 2002. Iran's Water Crisis: Cultural, Political, and Ethical Dimensions. Journal of Agricultural and Environmental Ethics, 15: 357-380.
Futehally I. 2021. Water Ethics in the Middle East. In book: Ethical Water Stewardship. Springer, Switzerland. 
Groenfeldt D. 2017a. Incorporating ethics into water decision-making. In book: Global Water Ethics: Towards a global ethics charter. Routledge. England. 
Groenfeldt D. 2017b. Developing a Global Water Ethics Charter. In book: Global Water Ethics: Towards a global ethics charter. Routledge, England.
Groenfeldt D. and Schmidt J.J. 2013. Ethics and Water Governance. Ecology and Society, 18(1): 1-10.
Grunwald A. 2016. Water Ethics – Orientation for Water Conflicts as Part of Inter- and Transdisciplinary Deliberation. In book: Society - Water – Technology: A Critical Appraisal of Major Water Engineering Projects, Springer. London, United Kingdom. 
Hale B. 2017. Rights, Rules, and Respect for Nature. In the Oxford Handbook of Environmental Ethics, Oxford University Press. Oxford, UK.
Harris L.M., McKenzie S., Rodina L., Shah S.H. and Wilson N.J. 2018. Water justice: key concepts, debates and research agendas. In The Routledge Handbook of environmental justice. Routledge, England.
Hausman D., McPherso, M. and Satz, D. 2017. Economic analysis, moral philosophy, and public policy. Cambridge University Press. United Kingdom.
Hayman E., James C., Wedge M. and Katzeek D. 2017. I yá.axch´age? (Can you hear it?), or Héen Aawashaayi Shaawat (marrying the water). A Tlingit and Tagish approach towards an ethical relationship with water. In book: Global Water Ethics: Towards a global ethics charter. Routledge. London, United Kingdom. 
Hefny M.A. 2010. Water commoditization: An ethical perspective for a sustainable use and management of water resources, with special reference to the Arab Region. In book: Re-thinking Water and Food Security: Fourth Botín Foundation Water Workshop. Taylor & Francis Group. United Kingdom.
Hiller A. 2017. Consequentialism in Environmental Ethics. In the Oxford Handbook of Environmental Ethics, Oxford University Press. Oxford, United Kingdom.
Huiying H. 2004. Humankind takes up environmental ethics. Chinese Education and Society, 37(4): 16-23.
Jackson, S. 2018. Indigenous Peoples and Water Justice in a Globalizing World. In book: Water politics and policy. Oxford University Press. Oxford, UK.
Jaeger WK, Plantinga AJ, Change H, Dello K, Grant G, Hulse D, McDonnell J, Lancaster S, Moradkhani H., Morzillo A.T., Mote P., Nolin A., Santelmann M. and Wu J. 2013. Toward a formal definition of water scarcity in natural-human systems. Water Resources Research, 49: 4506–17.
James L. and Wescoat Jr. 2013. The duties of water’ with respect to planting: toward an ethics of irrigated landscapes. Journal of Landscape Architecture, 8(2): 6-13.
Jamieson D. 2008. Ethics and Environment: an introduction. Cambridge University Press. London, United Kingdom. 
Jennings B. and Gwiazdon K. 2021. Water and Ecological Ethics in the Anthropocene. In book: Ethical Water Stewardship. Springer, Switzerland.
Jiang M. 2018. Towards Tradable Water Rights: Water Law and Policy Reform in China. Springer, Switzerland. 
Kalloff A. 2017. Water Ethics: Toward Ecological Cooperation. In the Oxford Handbook of Environmental Ethics,.Oxford University Press. Oxford, United Kingdom.
Kernohan A. 2012. Environmental ethics: an interactive introduction. Broadview Press. Canada. 
Khan K., Kunz R., Kleijnen J. and Antes G. 2011.  Systematic Reviews to Support Evidence-based Medicine: How to Review and Apply Findings of Healthcare Research. Hodder Arnold. Second edition. London. 
Kibert C.J., Thiele L., Peterson A. and Monroe M. 2012. The Ethics of Sustainability. Portal Rio. London, United Kingdom.
Kindler J. 2009. Ethics and uncertainty in Integrated Water Resources Management with special reference to transboundary issues. In book: Water Ethics: Marcelino Botín Water Forum 2007, Taylor & Francis Group. London, United Kingdom.
Llamas, M.R. and Martínez-Cortina, L. 2009. Specific aspects of groundwater use in water ethics. In book: Water Ethics: Marcelino Botín Water Forum 2007, Taylor & Francis Group. London, United Kingdom.
Levi R. and Mishori D. 2017. Water, virtue ethics and traditional ecological knowledge in Rajasthan: Anupam Mishra and the rediscovery of water traditions. In book: Global Water Ethics: Towards a global ethics charter. Routledge. London, United Kingdom. 
Liu J. and Huang X. 2017. An ecocentric water allocation across competing demands in an arid inland river basin of northwest China. In book: Global Water Ethics: Towards a global ethics charter. Routledge, England.
Liu J., Dorjderem A., Fu J., Lei X., Liu H., Macer D., Qiao Q., Sun A., Tachiyama K., Yu L. and Zheng Y. 2011. Water Ethics and Water Resource Management. UNESCO, Bangkok. 
Loreau M. 2014. Reconciling utilitarian and non-utilitarian approaches to biodiversity conservation. Ethics in Science and Environmental Politics, 14: 27–32.
Marima P. 2018. The Influence of environmental virtue ethics in water conservation (Thesis). Strathmore University. Available at: http://suplus.strathmore.edu/handle/11071/5960 (visited 28 June 2022).
Matthews C., Gibson R.B. and Mitchell B. 2007. Rising waves, old charts, nervous passengers: navigating toward a new water ethic. In book: Eau Canada: the future of Canada’s water, UBC Press. Vancouver, Canada.
Mayeda G. 2021. Philosophical Issues in Water Law. In book: Ethical Water Stewardship. Springer. Switzerland.
McDonald H.P. 2014. Environmental philosophy: A Revaluation of Cosmopolitan Ethics from an Ecocentric Standpoint. Rodopi B.V.. Amsterdam, Netherland. 
McGee W.J. 2010. Water as a resource. In book: Water Ethics: Foundational Readings for Students and Professionals. Island Press. Washington DC, USA.
Mcshane K. 2017. What Is Ethics? In book: Environmental Ethics: Readings in Theory and Application, Cengage Learning. Seventh Edition. USA.
Mehta L. 2006. Do human rights make a difference to poor and vulnerable people? Accountability for the right to water in South Africa. In book: Rights, Resources and the Politics of Accountability. Zed Books. London.
Meisch S. 2017. What is water ethics and to what end do we study it? Lessons for the Water Ethics Charter. In book: Global Water Ethics: Towards a global ethics charter. Routledge, England. 
Mokori A.S. and Cloete, C.E. 2016. Ethical perspectives on the environmental impact of property development’, HTS Teologiese Studies/Theological Studies, 72(3): 1-8.
Muradian R. and Gomez-Baggethun E. 2021. Beyond ecosystem services and nature's contributions: Is it time to leave utilitarian environmentalism behind? Ecological economics, 185: 1-9.
O’Neill J., Holland A. and Light, A. 2008. Environmental Values. Routledge, England.
O’Neill K.E. 2021. Water Pricing: A Strategy for Rights Fulfillment or Rights Violation? In book: Ethical Water Stewardship. Springer, Switzerland.
Parmar P. 2008. Revisiting the human right to water. The Australian Feminist Law Journal, 28: 77–96.
Pojman. L.P., Pojman P., and McShane K. 2017. Environmental ethics: readings in theory and application. Cengage Learning. Seventh Edition. USA.
Postel S. 2010. The missing link: a water ethic. In book: Water Ethics. Foundational Readings for Students and Professionals. Island Press. Washington, DC, USA. 
Pradhan R. and Meinzen-Dick R. 2010. Which Rights Are Right? Water Rights, Culture, and Underlying Values. In book: Water Ethics. Foundational Readings for Students and Professionals. Island Press. Washington, DC, USA.
Reynolds G.C. 2003. A Native American water ethic. Academy of Sciences, Arts and Letters, 90:143–162.
Roth D., Zwarteveen M., Joy K.J. and Kulkarni S. 2018. Water Governance as a Question of Justice: Politics, Rights, and Representation. In book: Water Justice. Cambridge University Press. United Kingdom.
Sahni P. 2008. Environmental Ethics in Buddahism: A Virtue Approach. Routledge, London. 
Sandler R. 2017. Environmental Virtue Ethics. In the Oxford Handbook of Environmental Ethics, Oxford University Press. Oxford., United Kingdom. 
Sandler R.L. 2018. Environmental Ethics: theory in practice. Oxford University Press. Oxford, United Kingdom.
Sandler R.L. 2007. Character and environment: a value-oriented approach to environmental ethics. Columbia University Press. New York, USA. 
Schlosberg D. 2007. Defining Environmental Justice: Theories, Movements, and Nature. Oxford University Press. Oxford, UK.
Schmidt J.J. and Mitchell K.R. 2014. Property and the right to water: toward a non-liberal common. Review of Radical Political Economics, 46(1): 54–69.
Schmidt J.J. 2010. Water ethics and water management. In book: Water Ethics. Foundational Readings for Students and Professionals, Island Press. Washington, DC, USA.
Selborne L. 2000. The ethics of freshwater use: a survey. UNESCO: World Commission on t
he Ethics of Scientific Knowledge and Technology. Paris. Available at: http://unesdoc.unesco.org/images/0012/001220/122049e.pdf. (visited 28 June 2022). 
Singh N. 2016. Introduction. In book: The Human Right to Water: From Concept to Reality. Springer. Switzerland. 
Smith K.K. 2018. Exploring Environmental Ethics: An Introduction. Springer. Switzerland.  
Smith S.L. 2017a. Developing an ecumenical framework for water justice. In book: Global Water Ethics: Towards a global ethics charter. Routledge, England.
Smith S.L. 2017b. The historical and intellectual context of global water ethics. In book: Global Water Ethics: Towards a global ethics charter. Routledge, England. 
Stefanovic I.L. and Adeel, Z. 2021. Preface. In book: Ethical Water Stewardship. Springer. Switzerland. 
Stefanovic I.L. and Atleo C. 2021. Valuing Water. In book: Ethical Water Stewardship. Springer, Switzerland.
Sym A. 2017. Water ethics and water stewardship: Personal reflections. In book: Global Water Ethics: Towards a global ethics charter. Routledge, England. 
Treanor B. 2014. Emplotting virtue: a narrative approach to environmental virtue ethic. State University of New York Press, Albany, USA.
Udoudom M. 2021. The Value of Nature: Utilitarian Perspective. GNOSI: An Interdisciplinary Journal of Human Theory and Praxis, 4(1): 31-46.
United Nations (UN). 2014. Realizing the human rights to water and sanitation: A Handbook. UN Special Rapporteur on the human right to safe drinking water and sanitation, Portugal. 
United Nations Department of Economic and Social Affairs. 2014. The human right to water and sanitation. Available at: http://www.un.org/waterforlifedecade/human_right_to_water.shtml. (visited 28 June 2022).
United Nations Development Programme. 2006. Human Development Report, 2006. In book: Beyond Scarcity: Power, Poverty and the Global Water Crisis (Editors: B. Ross-Larson, M. de Coquereaumont and C. Trott), Palgrave Macmillan, New York, USA.
United Nations Economic and Social Council. 2002. General Comment No. 15: The Right to Water. UN Doc. E/C.12/2002/11, 18pp.
United Nations General Assembly. 2010. The Human Right to Water and Sanitation. July 26, 2010. A/64/L.63/Rev.1. 3pp.
United Nations General Assembly. 2012. General Assembly Adopts Resolution Recognizing Access to Clean Water, Sanitation as Human Right, by Recorded Vote of 122 in Favour, None against, 41 Abstentions. Available at: http://www.un.org/News/Press/docs/2010/ga10967.doc.htm (visited 28 June 2022).
United Nations Human Rights Council. 2010. Human Rights and Access to Safe Drinking Water and Sanitation. Sept. 24, 2010. A/HRC/15/L.14. 4pp.
United Nations. 2019. Sustainable development goals: water action decade. Available at:  https://www.un.org/sustainabledevelopment/water-action-decade. (visited 28 June 2022).
van Zyl L. 2019. Virtue ethics: a contemporary introduction. Routledge, London, UK.
Veiga da Cunha, L. 2009. Water: A human right or an economic resource? In book: Water Ethics: Marcelino Botín Water Forum 2007, Taylor & Francis Group. London, United Kingdom.
Wellington A. 2018. Water ethics. In Encyclopedia of the Anthropocene. Elsevier. Amsterdam, Netherlands
Wellington A. 2021. Contextualizing a Human Rights Perspective for Water Ethics: From Exploitation to Empowerment and Beyond. In book: Ethical Water Stewardship. Springer. Switzerland.  
Wet C. and Odume O.N. 2019. Developing a systemic-relational approach to environmental ethics in water resource management. Environmental Science and Policy, 93(2019): 139-145. 
World Health Organization (WHO). 2019. Drinking-water. Available at: https://www.who.int/news-room/factsheets/detail/drinking-water (visited 28 June 2022).
Ziegler R. and Groenfeldt D. 2017. Introduction. In book: Global Water Ethics: Towards a global ethics charter. Routledge, England