Designing the Entrepreneurial Model of Technological Businesses in the Banking Industry with the Approach of Structural-Interpretive Equations

اقتصاد پولی مالی

Article 11, Volume 30, Issue 25, July 2023, Pages 314-347   

Document Type: Original Article

DOI: 10.22067/mfe.2023.78609.1229

Authors

Maryam Mashhadiabdol¹; Davood Samari^{* 2}; Majid Ashrafi³; Ebrahim Abbasi⁴

¹Ph. D student in Entrepreneurship Department, Faculty of Management and Accounting, Aliabad Katoul Branch, Islamic Azad University, Aliabad Katoul, Iran.

²2- Associate Professor, Department of Agricultural Management, Faculty of Agriculture and Natural Resources, Karaj Branch, Islamic Azad University, Alborz, Iran.

³Assistant Professor, Department of Accounting, Faculty of Management and Accounting, Ali Abadektol Branch, Islamic Azad University, Ali Abadektol, Iran.

⁴Professor of Management, Faculty of Social and Economic Sciences, Al-Zahra University, Tehran, Iran.

Abstract

 
1- INTRODUCTION
Financial technology will transform traditional financial markets, especially banks, by taking advantage of innovation. The purpose of this research is to present an entrepreneurial model regarding the subject of this research. The research is exploratory in terms of its applied purpose-developments and data collection method. In order to examine the relationship model and its fit, structural equation modeling has been used. As a result, the components are placed in 5. Therefore, according to these recommendations, in order to improve their business models, it has been provided.
 
2- THEORETICAL FRAMEWORK
Today, the world is witnessing very rapid progress in various fields of science, the speed of these developments and innovations resulting from it is faster, especially in the science of information and communication technology, and the technologies of this field have become a precursor to developments in other fields as well. Banks have always been the focus of researchers due to their special importance in the economy of countries. With the expansion of technology and the increasing influence of the internet and virtual space in people's daily lives, the need for ideas and innovation in the banking sector also becomes more tangible.
In a significant part of the previous research in the field of financial technology ecosystem, the way of its development and evolution and the role of this ecosystem in creating innovation in the financial services industry have been discussed. In research, the proposed classification framework of the paper has three dimensions: financial benefits, challenges and functions enabled by blockchain.
The current research seeks to answer the following questions:

What factors does the entrepreneurial model of technological businesses in the banking industry include?
In what dimensions are the influential factors of financial technology in the banking industry?
How are the influential dimensions of financial technology in the banking industry related to each other?

 
 
3- METHODOLOGY
In the first step, to implement this method, the triangular fuzzy values of experts' opinions as well as the components obtained from previous researches in both internal and external studies were calculated and these components were converted into fuzzy values. In the second step, to calculate the average of the opinions of n respondents, their fuzzy average was calculated. In the third step, according to the studies conducted from domestic and foreign researches, the participating team consists of academic experts, number of 20 people, including faculty members of public administration, information technology management, entrepreneurship and banking affairs management, based on the information that they have been determined in the field of financial technologies in the banking system. In the fourth step, to validate the findings of the qualitative part, the method of long-term engagement and continuous observation, review by participants and colleagues, and the triangulation technique of data sources have been used. In order to achieve reliability criteria, including reliability, transferability, reliability, and verifiability, which are used in transferability, the results of the study, in reliability, coding in reports, and in verifiability, recording activities over time. In the fifth step, after data editing, coding and data entry, two methods of descriptive and inferential statistics and software such as Excel, SPSS, PLS have been used to analyze the data. In the sixth step, the interpretive structural model (ISM) was presented by Andrew Sage in 1977.
 
4- RESULTS & DISCUSSION
In the first stage, according to the fact that each of the previous researchers introduced different components in their articles, with the method of content analysis and the combination of similar codes, the primary components in each of the dimensions of the model were identified by analyzing the existing articles and books and interviewing experts became. Fixed fuzzy numbers are calculated by using the average method as follows:
ϰ1=(U+M+L)/3; ϰ2=(U+2M+L)/4; ϰ3=(U+4M+L)/6
  According to KMO number (more than 0.7) and significance level, Bartlett's test is less than 5%. The explained variance shows that these questions consist of 5 factors and these factors explain and cover about 64.55% of the variance, which actually indicates the appropriate validity of the questions. A good fit index above 0.5 indicates a good fit of the model.
According to the results obtained from the structural equation model, the analysis of the research model is presented as follows: the coefficient of determination shows that 74.9 percent of the changes in business internationalization are explained by innovative capabilities, entrepreneurial attitude, supply chain initiatives, and internationalization. Market structure and support activities in this research, the components are placed in 5 levels, which are at the highest level of innovative capabilities and entrepreneurial attitude and at the lowest level of business internationalization.
 
5- CONCLUSIONS & SUGGESTIONS
Over the years, although many researchers have investigated the components of a business model (Bertel et al., 2012), designing a new business model is closer to an art than a science. In order to achieve the goal of the research, with the help of findings from previous researches, key factors have been identified and then using interpretive structural modeling or ISM, for the key factors identified from the point of view of experts, including university professors, banking experts and managers specializing in the field of business and they are technological works, a structured relationship was defined.
In a changing environment, the delivery and delivery need of financial services will also change. The proposed model is more comprehensive compared to similar proposed models, and the categories taken from previous researches are in five dimensions. By comparing the previous research with the current research, it can be concluded that the structure of institutions and technological activities are among the elements that need to be paid attention to. In order to start and create technological businesses in the banking industry, entrepreneurs need to have a high entrepreneurial attitude in addition to creating an environment that has high innovative capabilities.

Keywords

Financial technology; Fintech; Structural equation

References

Abbasi, K.; Alam, A.; Du, M. A., & Huynh, T. L. D. (2021). “FinTech, SME efficiency and national culture: evidence from OECD countries”, Technological Forecasting and Social Change, 163, 120-454.

Ali, O.; Ally, M., & Dwivedi, Y. (2020). “The state of play of blockchain technology in the financial services sector: A systematic literature review”, International Journal of Information Management, 54, 102-199.

Adib, D.; Safarzadeh, H., & Mohammadi, M. (2023). “Designing and explaining the IoT commercialization model in Iranian organizations (Telecommunication Company of Iran): An interpretive structural modeling (ISM) approach”, Int. J. Nonlinear Anal. Appl, 14(1), 723-738. (in Persian)

Alikhani, H.; Esfandiari, A., & Saidi, P. (2022). “Designing a digital entrepreneurship model with an interpretive structural modeling approach”, Technology Growth Quarterly, 70(18), 64-69. (in Persian)

Arner, D. W.; Barberis, J., & Buckley, R. P. (2015). ‘The evolution of Fintech: A new post-crisis paradigm”. Geo. J. Int'l L., 47, 12-71.

Asadullah, M., & Hamidizadeh, Ali. (2018). "E-banking business model based on the emergence of fintechs and financial startups", Technology Development Management Quarterly, 7(2). (in Persian)

Azimzade, A.; Sanaipoor, H.; Ashrafi, M., & Shojai, S. (2021). “Presenting the structural equation model of international entrepreneurship development in knowledge-based businesses”. Business Management Quarterly, 50, 150-172. (in Persian)

Brettel, M.; Strese, S., & Flatten, T.C. (2012). “Improving the performance of ctive”, European Management Journal, 30(2), 85-98.

Capital value management group. (2016). "The future of financial services markets: Is the financial services market facing a revolution?"; Insurance Bank Holding and National Pension Fund Shares. (in Persian)

CFA institute. (2016) “FINTECH SURVEY REPORT”.

Eftekhari, S.; Rusta, A., & Noami, A. (2019). "Investigating the impact of factors influencing the acceptance of financial technology by bank customers (case study of Pasargad Bank)"; Investing knowledge scientific research quarterly, 10(38). (in Persian)

Gai K.; Qiu M., & Xiaotong S. (2018). “A survey on FinTech. Journal of Network and Computer Applications”, 103, 262-273.

Global Agenda Council on the Future of Financing & Capital. (2015). “The Future of FinTech A Paradigm Shift in Small Business Finance”. 

Habibi, A., & Aden Var, M. (2016). "Structural Equation Modeling", Jihad University Publications, 6th edition. (in Persian)

Habibi, A.; Firouzi jahantigh, F., & Sarafrazi, A. (2015). “Fuzzy Delphi Technique for Forecasting and Screening Items”, Asian Journal of Research in Business Economics and Management, 5(2), 130-143.

Haji Shahvardi, D.; Zamardian, Gh.; Falah Shams Lialestani, Mirfaiz., & Hanifi, Farhad. (2018). "Designing a Systematic Banking Crisis Early Warning System in Iran's Financial Market (Using Markovian Chains)"; Financial Economics Quarterly, 79 (41), 794-799. (in Persian)

Hosseini, S., & Faramarzi Ebad, H. (2015). "Investigating the effect of electronic banking on the return on equity in selected banks active in the Tehran Stock Exchange", Financial Economics Quarterly, 71(53), 169-147. (in Persian)

Huang, H., & Lin, P. (2012). “Banking industry volatility and growth”, Journal of macroeconomics.

Jociene, A. (2015). “Business Models of Scandinavian Banks Subsidiries in the Baltics: Identification and Analysis”; Occasional Paper Series, 5.

Kawai, Y. (2016). “Fintech and the IAIS”, IAIS Newsletter.

Kikavossi, D. K. (2015). "Financial Technology (FinTech)", Science and Technology Park of Sistan and Baluchistan Province. (in Persian)

Kordenori, A.; Adaltian Shahriari, J.; Azizi, M., & Kabaranzadeh Kaidim, M. (2019). "Designing a conceptual business model in development banks with an international entrepreneurship approach", Financial Economics Quarterly, 14(53), 157-172. (in Persian)

Koshesh Kordsholi, R.; Maleki, M., & Gholami Jamkarani, R. (2021). "Providing a framework for identifying key drivers affecting the future of financial technology using fuzzy Delphi techniques and fuzzy hierarchical analysis type 2", Financial Engineering and Securities Management Quarterly, 49. (in Persian)

Lin, E. M.; Sun, E. W., & Yu, M. T. (2020). “Behavioural data-driven analysis with Bayesian method for risk management of financial services”, International Journal of Production Economics, 107-737.

Maier .E. (2016). “Supply and demand on crowdlending platforms: connecting small and medium- sized”, Enterprise borrowers and consumer investors Journal of Retailing and Consumer Services, 33, 143-153.

Masanell, R., & Ricart, JE. (2012). “From strategy to business models and on to tactics”, Long Rang Planning, 43(8), 98-109.

Mashadiabdol, M.; Samari, D.; Ashrafi, M., & Abbasi, E.; (2018). "Strategic analysis of fintech-based entrepreneurship in banking", Financial Engineering and Securities Management Quarterly, (41), 393-412. (in Persian)

Mirghfouri, H.; Shafii, M., & Malekshahi, F.; (2017) "Ranking of the critical success factors of urban services in new service development projects", scientific research quarterly of management studies (improvement and transformation), 22 (68). (in Persian)

Mishra, A. (2013). “Business model for Indian retail sector: The Cafe Coffee Day case In conversation with V.G. Siddhartha, Chairman, Coffee Day”, IIMB Management Review, 25(3), 160-170.

Mohammadi Qomi, S.; Hikmat, S., & Eslami, Z. (2015). "The progress of financial technologies and its impact on the future of the banking industry: strategic analysis", Trend Quarterly, 23 (73). (in Persian)

Mousavi, F.; Azar, A., & KhodadadHosseini, H. (2022). “Designing Innovation Excellence Modelin Bankingand Monetary Institutions of Islamic Republic of Iran”, Journal of Innovation Management in Defensive Organizations, 4(14), 85-114. (in Persian)

Nikbin, H.; Badiezadeh, A.; Davari, A., & Hosseini Nia, G. H. (2017). "Providing an effective business model in the field of electronic businesses with the treasury network method", Technology Development Management Quarterly, 6(1). (in Persian)

Osterwalder, A., & Pigneur, Y. (2010). “Business Model Generation: A Handbook for visionaries, Game Changers, and Challengers”, John Wiley & Sons.

Qadiri Nejadian, M., & Karimi, F. (2015). "Banking as a platform (BaaP) perspective and its deployment requirements in banks", 6th Annual Conference on Electronic Banking and Payment Systems. (in Persian)

Qolizadeh, M., & Qasim Nejad, M. (2016). "Banking and Fintech: Challenge or Opportunity?", Business Reviews, (83). (in Persian)

Saal, M.; Starnes, S. K., & Rehermann, T. (2017). “Digital financial services: challenges and opportunities for emerging market banks”, The World Bank, 118(736), 1-9.

Sayeedi, O.; Naderiyan, A.; Khozain, A., & Didehkhani, H. (2019). “Designing Total Interpretive Structural Model of Entrepreneurial Orientation”, Petroleum Business Review, 3(3), 61-72.

Seifi Farzad, H.; Ahmadipour, Z.; Hafez Nia, M. & Moradian, M. (2018). "Designing a structural-interpretive model (ISM) of factors affecting the creation of sustainable citizenship security"; Shahr Binsdar, 2(3), 111-125. (in Persian)

Shim, Y., & Shin, D. H. (2016). “Analyzing China’s fintech industry from the perspective of actor–network theory”, Telecommunications Policy, 40(23), 168-181.

Tavakoli Nabavi, N. (2014). "Designing the Internationalization Model of Mellat Insurance Company with a New Service Development Approach (Case Study of Mellat Insurance Company)", University of Tehran.

Wirtz, B. W.; Göttel, V., & Daiser, P. (2016). “Business Model Innovation: Development, Concept and Future Research Directions”, Journal of Business Models, 4(1), 1-28.

Zarei, A., & Hemati, M. (2020). “Designing a relationship model of entrepreneurial marketing components with a modeling approach An interpretative structure (case study: Semnan knowledge-based companies)”, Biannual innovation and value creation, 18(9), 163-178.