The Development Programs in Iran and the Environmental Problems of Urmia Lake

پژوهش ‎های جغرافیای سیاسی

Article 1, Volume 2, Issue 1 - Serial Number 5, June 2017, Pages 1-29   

Document Type: مقالات علمی -پژوهشی

DOI: 10.22067/pg.v2i5.56353

Authors

Mohammad Bagher Ghalibaf¹; Javad Etaat²; Hosein Mohammadi¹; zahra Moussavi^{* 1}

¹University of Tehran

²Shahid Beheshti University

Abstract

Extended Abstract
1. Introduction
Since the end of the Second World War, the development paradigm has become the dominant discourse in the world. During the more than 6 decades that the concept of development discourse has been dominant, many theoretical and practical developments have accompanied it. First, attention was solely paid on economic development and nature was considered as a facilitator of economic growth. However, it was gradually recognized that development with this economic growth approach changes the natural systems of the planet and leads to numerous environmental hazards that can threaten the economic and political systems of countries. Therefore, it is very possible for a political entity to attain the development, but sustained development will be faced with serious doubts because environmental aspects are ignored. Therefore, the concept of sustainable development replaced development.
2. Methodology
Given the above- mentioned approach, this descriptive-analytic research examined the relationship between Development Programs and the environmental problems with Urmia Lake as a case example. To do this, an analytic and explanatory method, the accumulation of data and the existing literature have been adopted to carry out a library and document-based research.
3. Discussion
Urmia Lake, located in the northwestern part of Iran, is one of the salt over-saturated lakes in the world. This lake was introduced as a Biosphere Reserve to UNESCO’s program of Man and the Biosphere and was included in the list of the Wetlands of this Convention on Wetlands of International Importance (Ramsar-1971). The water level in Urmia Lake was at its highest in 1995 and then, since 1995 up to 2012, it has declined more than seven meters. A review of other studies shows that although climate change and particularly evaporation increment are significant agents in decreasing the water level, the main causes of drying up the lake have been anthropogenic factors. For example, Lak, Darvishi Khatooni and Mohammadi (2011) suggested that although Iran has experienced a long-term drought since 13000 years ago up to now, Urmia Lake has never experienced dryness except in coastal areas and the main part of the lake has had lacustrine environment for 13000 years. On the other hand, according to Jamali, Sharifi, and Pourmand (2013), climate change never affects a single point selectively, and the performance of these changes is always on an extensive scale. The dramatic decrease in the water level of Lake Urmia has not been observed in the neighboring lakes such as the Sevan Lake in Armenia and Lake Van in Turkey. Therefore, the National Development Programs as well as development plans in the Urmia Lake Basin as human factors influencing the current situation and the environmental problems of Lake Urmia have been analyzed in this research. At present there are about 95 dams in the Urmia Lake Basin, 57 of which are operational, nine are under construction, and 29 are in the study phase. Moreover, water utilization has increased very rapidly in the past two decades and has depleted more than 90 percent of the water in the aquifers. The agriculture sector is the most important consumer of the water in this Basin and has experienced remarkable changes during the last three decades. So, The Development Programs have been one of the main reasons for the drying up of the Lake. The consequences resulting from the implementation of Development Plans in the Urmia Lake basin and drying the Lake are mainly the disruption of the biodiversity in the region, increased salinity, soil erosion, pollution of water sources, salt dust, and weather changes in the region that can threaten the sustainability of the development.
4. Conclusion
The analysis of the planning process and Development Programs in Iran shows that the patterns of development in Iran have always been based on economic growth which allows for achieving other economic and social goals. So, environmental resources have been considered as the foundation of national wealth and economic growth facilitator. Development with the economic growth approach has led to numerous environmental problems in the country of which Lake Urmia is an example. Therefore, it is possible for a political entity to attain development, but sustained development will be faced with serious doubts because environmental aspects are ignored.

Keywords

Sustainable development; Development programs; Environmental problems; Urmia Lake; Iran

References

1. Bruyn, S. (2000). Economic growth and the environment. Kluwer Academic Publishers.

2. Department of Environment of Iran (DOE). (2010). Integrated management plan for Lake Urmia Basin. Prepared in Cooperation with Governmental Organizations, NGEOs, and Local Communities of Lake Urmia Basin. Iran: Author. (In Persian)

3. Department of Environment of Iran (DOE). (2013). Urmia Lake: Challenges, Actions, and the Way Forward. Urmia Lake Restoration Staff. (In Persian)

4. Deyni Torkmani, A. (2011, January 31). Economic development strategies from the viewpoint of economic schools; Walt Whitman Rowstow's Theory of Economic Growth. Donya-e- eqtesad Newspaper [The word of Economies], p.29. (In Persian)

5. Ebtekar, M. (2013, November 9). Note; Reviving the Iran’s Environment. Iran Newspaper, p.1. (In Persian)

6. Escobar, A. (1995). Encountering development: the making and unmaking of the third world. United States: Princeton University Press.

7. FadayiFard, M. (2013). Significant reasons for reducing the amount of water entering the lake and the operational procedures for saving the Lake Urmia. Ministry of Energy magazine (14 academic instructions to revive Lake Urmia), Special issue on Urmia Lake, 18-20. (In Persian)

8. Farrokhnia, A. & Morid, S. (2014). Evaluation of the effect of precipitation and temperature changes on the flow of rivers in the Uremia Lake basins. Bimonthly Journal of Water and Wastewater, 3, 86-97. (In Persian)

9. Ghalibaf, M.B. & Moussavi, Z. (2014). Development and environment in Urmia Lake of Iran. European Journal of Sustainable Development, 3 (3), 219-226.

10. Hodder, R. (2006). Development geography in Iran and the world. (F., Khani & N., Javadi, Trans.).Tehran: Ghomes. (In Persian)

11. Iran Consulting Engineers Society. (2011). Assessing the sustainability of the development process and its consequences on Lake Urmia (Urmia lake environmental crisis). Tehran: Author. (In Persian)

12. Iran Water Resources Management Company, Deputy of Planning and Development. (2015). Specifications of Iran’s dams. Tehran: Author. (In Persian)

13. Iran Water Resources Management Company, Infrastructure Studies Office. (2015). Iran wells information. Tehran: Author. (In Persian)

14. Islamic Parliament Research Center, Infrastructure Studies Office. (2012). Expertise About revive plan of the country's lakes and wetlands. Tehran: Author. (In Persian)

15. Islamic Parliament Research Center. (1990). Law of the First Economic, Social and Cultural Development Plan of the Islamic Republic of Iran, 1990-1994. (In Persian)

16. Islamic Parliament Research Center. (1995). Law of the Second Economic, Social and Cultural Development Plan of the Islamic Republic of Iran, 1995-1999. (In Persian)

17. Islamic Parliament Research Center. (2000). Law of the Third Economic, Social and Cultural Development Plan of the Islamic Republic of Iran, 2000-2004. (In Persian)

18. Islamic Parliament Research Center. (2005). Law of the Fourth Economic, Social and Cultural Development Plan of the Islamic Republic of Iran, 2005-2009. (In Persian)

19. Islamic Parliament Research Center. (2011). Law of the Fifth Economic, Social and Cultural Development Plan of the Islamic Republic of Iran, 2011-2015. (In Persian)

20. Jalili, S., Morid, S., Banakar, A. & Namdar Ghanbari, R. (2012). Spectrophotometric analysis of time series of Lake Urmia water level. Journal of Water and Soil Conservation, 4, 25-46. (In Persian)

21. Jamali, M., Sharifi, A. & Pourmand, A. (2013). Has Lake Urmia been completely dried up in the past?. Retrieved from http://www.khabaronline.ir/ detail/311311/weblog/akhani. (In Persian)

22. Kamali, M. & Youneszadeh Jalili, S. (2016). Investigation of land use changes in Lake Urmia catchment area using satellite imagery. Tehran: Urmia Lake Restoration Program. (In Persian)

23. Khoshtinat, S., Alami, M.T. & Amin Nezhad, B. (2015). Quantitative Effects Influencing Factors in the Urmia Lake Water Level Change Using a System Dynamics Model. Biological Forum-An International Journal, 7 (1), 861-870.

24. Lak, R., Darvishi Khatooni, J. & Mohammadi, A. (2011). Paleolimnological studies and causes of sudden decrease in Lake Urmia water level. Applygeology, 4, 343-358. (In Persian)

25. Leftwich, A. (2006). The developmental states. (J., Afsharkohan, Trans.). Mashhad: Merendiz and Neynagar. (In Persian)

26. Lotfi, A. (2012). A description of the basic conditions of Lake Urmia. Micheal Mozer(Ed.). (Y., Akbaradeh, Trans.). Tehran: Ghalam Azin. (In Persian)

27. Makhdoom, M. (2015). Land management is a prerequisite for development plans. Retrieved from http://www.iraneia.ir/fa/NewsDetails.aspx?NewsId=328. (In Persian)

28. Management and Planning Organization. (2001-2013). Books of the Budget Law of the country; Attachment. Tehran: Management and Planning Organization publication. (In Persian)

29. Ministry of Energy (2013). Restoration of the Urmia Lake. Journal of Ministry of Energy. Tehran: Ministry of Energy. (In Persian)

30. Ministry of Planning and Budget. (1991-2001). Books of the Budget Law of the country. Attachment1; Construction Projects. Tehran: Author. (In Persian)

31. Ministry of planning and budget. (1992-2002). Country Budget Laws. Tehran: Ministry of planning and budget publication. (In Persian)

32. National Parliament (1951). Law of the First Development Plan (1949-1955). (In Persian)

33. National Parliament (1956). Law of the Second Development Plan (1956-1963). (In Persian)

34. National Parliament (1962). Law of the Third Development Plan (1963-1969). (In Persian)

35. National Parliament (1968). Law of the Fourth Development Plan (1969-1973). (In Persian)

36. National Parliament (1973). Law of the Fifth Development Plan (1974-1978). (In Persian)

37. National Parliament (1978). Law of the Sixth Development Plan (1979-1983). (In Persian)

38. Payan, A. & Phillips, N. (2010). Development. Cambridge: Polity Press.

39. Pieterse, J.N. (1998). My paradigm or yours? Alternative development, post development, reflexive development. Development and Change, 29 (2), 343-73.

40. Potter, R., Conway, D., Evans, R. & Evans, S.L. (2012). Key concepts in development geography. London: SAGE Publication Ltd.

41. Potter, R.B. & Conway, D. (2011). In John Agnew and David N. Livingstone, The Sage Handbook of Geographical Knowledge. California: SAGE.

42. Rapley, J. (2007). Understanding development: theory and practice in the third world. United States: LYNNE RIENNER Publishers.

43. Razzaghi, E. (1997). Introduction to Iranian Economy. Tehran: Ney publications. (In Persian)

44. Rouzbahan, M. (1992). Basics of Economic Development. Tehran: Rouzbahan. (In Persian)

45. Sachs, W. (1992). The development dictionary. London: Zed book Ltd.

46. Sarrafi, M. (1998). Fundamentals of regional development planning. Tehran: Planning and Budget Organization; Center for Social-Economic Documents. (In Persian)

47. United Nations Environment Program (UNEP). (2012). The drying of Iran’s Lake Urmia and its environmental consequences. Retrieved from www.unep.org

48. Urmia Lake Restoration Program. (2015). Urmia Lake restoration necessity: Causes of Drought and Threats. Tehran: Author. (In Persian)

49. Vice President of Strategic supervision and Planning. (2014). Country Budget Laws. Tehran: Vice President of Strategic supervision and planning publication. (In Persian)

50. Vilis, K. (2014). Theories and development experiences. (H., Imani Jajarmi & P., Pourrajab, Trans.). Tehran: Pejvak. (In Persian)

51. Water Research Institute. (2013). Investigating the process of changing environmental conditions in the catchment area of Lake Urmia; comparing it with some nearby lakes. Tehran: Author. (In Persian)

52. West Azerbayijan Regional Water Authority Website: http://www.agrw.ir/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=33:lake-stats&catid=2&Itemid=50&lang=fa. (In Persian)

53. Woodhouse, P. (2002). Development policies and environmental agendas. In V. Kothari and M. Minogue (eds.), Development theory and practice: critical perspectives. (PP. 136-56). Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan.

54. Zeynali B., Asghari Sarskanrood, S. (2012). Investigation of changes in the coastline of Lake Urmia water level and its impact on the cities located in the basin. Biannaul Journal of Urban Ecology Researches, 3 (2), pp.103-116. (In Persian)