The Historical and Intellectual Course of Development in Preserving the Cultural Heritage from the Perspective of Conceptual Status of Integrity

تاریخ و فرهنگ

Article 3, Volume 46, Issue 1 - Serial Number 92, September 2014, Pages 85-108   

Document Type: Research Article

DOI: 10.22067/history.v46i9.28737

Authors

Sumayya Basiri^{* 1}; Rasoul Vatandoust²; Sayyid Muhammad Amin Emami¹; Husayn Ahmadi¹

¹Isfahan University of Art

²Art and Architecture Faculty, Islamic Azad University

Abstract

Integrity is among the fundamental concepts in the field of cultural heritage and the importance of knowing this concept and examining its status in the philosophical principles of perseverance is so great that achieving integrity is introduced as among the basic criteria of optimal preservation of historical monuments. Integrity has always been open to discussion in different historical periods, but because of different impressions made of this concept, it has been used with a different meaning in every period. This article is aimed at finding an answer to the question as to what the conceptual status of integrity is as one of the basic principles of cultural heritage in the theory of preservation and what process it has followed from the middle ages up to the present era; and, in general, what role has the meaning and value had in the philosophical principles of preservation as well as in the category of integrity? The findings obtained from the study of the sources and data indicates the semantic limits, the status, and the degree of importance of integrity in the course of preservation history and clarifies that this concept is one of the basic principles that has to be perpetually supported in all the fields of cultural heritage, to such an extent that discrediting this important matter would diminish the value of the monumental work and the only way to preserve the universal values is to preserve their integrity.

Keywords

Cultural Heritage; value; integrity; philosophical principles; preservation

References

برندی، چزاره، ترجمه پرویز حناچی، تئوری مرمت، دانشگاه تهران، تهران، 1387.

بیردزلی، مونروسی و جان هاسپرس، تاریخ ومسائل زیباشناسی، ترجمه محمدسعید حنائی کاشانی، نشر هرمس، تهران، 1387.

حجت، مهدی، میراث فرهنگی در ایران سیاست‌ها برای یک کشور اسلامی، سازمان میراث فرهنگی کشور، تهران، 1380.

راودراد، اعظم، نظریه های جامعه‌شناسی هنر وادبیات، دانشگاه تهران، تهران، 1382.

طالبیان، محمدحسن، نقش مفهوم اصالت در حفاضت محوطه‌های میراث جهانی (تجاربی از دورانتاش برای حفاظت مبتنی بر اصالت)، پایان نامه دکتری دانشگاه تهران، 1384.

علیزاده، سیامک، اصالت و نقش آن در حفاظت و مرمت میراث فرهنگی، پایان نامه دکتری دانشگاه هنر، 1385.

لسینگ، آلفرد و دنیس داتون، مجموعه مقالات مسائل هنر و زیباشناسی معاصر (آثار جعلی و تقلبی)، ترجمه نیماملک محمدی، فرهنگستان هنر، تهران، 1389.

میرفخرایی، وحیده، سیر تحول و ضرورت مرمت و بازسازی اشیاء تاریخی، نشر سبحان نور، تهران، 1387.

یوکیلهتو، یوکا، تاریخ حفاظت و معماری، ترجمه محمدحسن طالبیان و خشایار بهاری، نشر روزنه، تهران، 1387.

Alberts. van Jaarsveld, Stefanie Freitag, Steven L. Chown, Caron Muller, Stephanie Koch, Heath Hull, Chuck Bellamy, Martin Krüger, Sebastian Endrödy-Younga, Mervyn W. Mansell, Clarke H. Scholtz.1998. Biodiversity Assessment and Conservation Strategies, Vol. 279 no. 5359.

Caple, C., (2004), Conservation Skills: Judgment, Method and Decision Making, Routledge, 3rd Printing, New York

Clavir, Miriam.1998.)THE SOCIAL AND HISTORIC CONSTRUCTION OF PROFESSIONAL VALUES IN CONSERVATION(. Studies in conservation, Volume 43, Number 1.

BOUCHENAKI, Mounir.2003.ICOMOS 14th General Assembly and Scientific Symposium. Place , memory, meaning: preserving intangible values in monuments and sites. )THE INTERDEPENDENCY OF THE TANGIBLE AND INTANGIBLE CULTURAL HERITAGE.UNESCO(. Victoria Falls, Zimbabwe.

Cosgrove ,P.J. Hastie, L.C.2001. Conservation of threatened freshwater pearl mussel populations. )river management, mussel translocation and conflict resolution(. Volume 99, Issue 2.

Costello, Peter. 2006. Historic heritage value, pressures and emerging trends .)Conservation of Australians heritage, Productivity Commission Inquiry Report(. No 37.

Edroma, E 2001. The notion of integrity for natural properties and cultural landcapes, in G Saouma-Forero (ed), Authenticity and Integrity in an African context. )Expert meeting, Great Zimbabwe National Monument, Zimbabwe(, 26-29 May 2000, 50-58. Paris: UNESCO.

Eriksen, Ole Søe. 2010. Nordic World Heritage Foundation Periodic. )Reporting 2nd Cycle Europe 2012-2014.Nordic-Baltic SOUV workshop(, Tallinn.

Freundlg, H. 2010. )To Restore or Not Restore? The Never-Ending Controversy Over Art’s Integrity Vs(. The Preservation of Cultural Heritage.

ICCROM International Course.2010.Guidance on the preparation of retrospective statements of outstanding universal value of world heritage properties.

ICCROM International Course.2008.Sharing Conservation Decision, Rome,pp 3 – 28.

ICOMOS. 1994. Nara document on Authenticity.

Guidance for World Heritage Properties, preparation of Retrospective Statement of Outstanding Universal Value, 2010.

Jokilehto,Jokka ,2010,Conserving the authentic, edited by Nicholas Stanley Price and Joseph king.ICROM.

Jokilehto J. 2006, (Considerations on authenticity and integrity in world heritage context), City & Time No.2

Jokilehto ,Jukka .King, Joseph. 2000. Authenticity and Integrity. Summary of ICCROM Position Paper, Amsterdam.

Mason, Randall.2002. Assessing values in conservation planning: Methodological Issues and Choices. Los Angeles .The Getty conservation Institute.

Matero, Frank.2000. Ethics and Policy in Conservation , Newsletter 15, No 1.

Michalski, Stefan .1994. "A systematic approach to preservation: description and integration with other museum activities", Preventive conservation: practice, theory and research. Preprints of the contributions to the Ottawa Congress, International Institute for Conservation of Historic and Artistic Works, 6 Buckingham St. United Kingdom. London.

Mitchell, Nora J,2008, (Considering the Authenticity of cultural landscapes), APT Bulletin, Vol. 39,No. 2/3.

Morgan, Jeff. Alto, Palo. 2009. (Saving Our Global Heritage Scientific Conservation and Master Planning for Sustainable World Heritage Preservation in Developing Economies), A Model for Integrated Community-Based Conservation and Development GHF Technical White Paper August.

Munoz Vinas.Salvador.2005. Contemporary theory of conservation. Elsevier Butterworth-Heinemann.

Reccia Mentor, Emanuele. Prof. Paolo FaccioVenice, 2009. Planned Maintenance and Conservation: A Maintenance Tenance Plan for Restoration Projects the case study of RoscignoVecchia II Level, Master's Thesis, University of Nova GoricaGraduate School,University IUAV of Venice.

Stovel, Herb . 2008. (Origins and Influence of the Nara Document on Authenticity) . APT Bulletin, Vol. 39, No. 2/3, pp. 9-17. http://www.jstor.org/stable/25433946 .Accessed: 24/07/2012.

UNESCO Recommendation concerning the safeguarding and contemporary role of historic areas,1976,par 3.

Varoli- Piazza, Rosalia.2007.Sharing conservation decision. ICCROM.Rome, Italy.

Whalen, Timothy P.2000. (Conservation at the New Century). Newsletter 15, No 1.