The optimal location of fire stations in the city of Mashhad

جغرافیا و مخاطرات محیطی

Article 2, Volume 3, Issue 3 - Serial Number 11, January 2015, Pages 107-128   

Document Type: Research Article

DOI: 10.22067/geo.v3i3.32086

Authors

Mohammad Ajzae Shokouhi; Hamid Shayan; Mohammad Hadi Darroudi^*

Ferdowsi University of Mashhad

Abstract

1. Introduction
Many of citizens living in urban areas are exposed to many dangers which the main result of the fire. Among the elements of fire stations and Land Use Services - Emergency towns which are vital role in protecting life and property against various disasters, particularly hazards are human. City of safety against fire hazards and safety guarantees in different land uses and urban Taxpayers important element of the charge. The layout and location of fire stations and the location and number of sites suitable for coating according to the characteristics of the citizens, current and anticipated financial and logistical possibilities for future development of the In this context, critical and immediate need is.
2. Study Area
As one of the major cities of Mashhad, Iran's second-largest city in the country, according to the statistics of the population, especially on holidays (due to the flexible nature of pilgrims in Mashhad), seems to be insufficient and inappropriate location of urban facilities and equipment, problems citizens has created. On the other hand, in Mashhad, like other metropolitan cities are faced with the phenomenon of marginalization. the core of the physical development of the marginalized population, over time, have been ingested within the law, without any infrastructure and facilities, such spontaneously formed.
3. Material and Methods
The research method is descriptive - analytical and practical aspects are described.
A) Studies Library (documents and comments)
B) Harvest field contains the geographic coordinates of spatial data like Hydrant valves.
C) The use of GIS and Arc GIS 9.3 software for locating fire stations through the implementation process: 1 - extract the effective parameters in the model proposed center location 2 - Selecting optimal locations for proposed using multi criteria decision making.
D) Method of data analysis: the analysis of the research model using fuzzy logic and analytic hierarchy process is. This method is a combination of qualitative and quantitative methods.
4. Results and Discussion
The basic criteria are effective in locating fire stations.
The process of locating fire stations after analyzing the current status of all stations in the city area - no proper access to such services by using fuzzy logic and analytic hierarchy process on 31 indicators grouped in five general measures of time, physical, population, numerous fires and accidents, and natural and infrastructural factors have been identified. Accordingly, the criteria for determining the location of the station, expert opinions and perceptions of fire safety services, field researcher, the optimal area of interest was determined. All of the above criteria through modeling in localization models using fuzzy analytic hierarchy process to analyze the situation and identify the zones have been used to create new stations.
Spatial analysis - location and identification of the optimal locations.
After identifying the factors and parameters to locate the optimal area for the construction of new fire stations in the service area, fire safety services, based on data the layers of the needed data (twenty-five of the information layer Location and Description) formed 's.
Process analysis of existing fire stations and locate new zones.
Step 1: Determine the overall goal
Step 2: Determination of micro-objectives, criteria and selection models to identify the optimal zones.
Step 3: Describe and analyze the data and identify indicators.
Step 4: Identify the subject area of optimal (fuzzy logic model).
Step 5: Identify zones of optimal combination of parameters (model AHP)
Step 6: objective evaluation of the identified zones.
Step 7: Identify the optimal marginal zones.
Step 8: Identify and prioritize improvement areas.
5. Conclusion
Based on the analysis of existing fire stations and locate the optimal zone, create new stations in Mashhad (eight steps) were determined by the macro and micro targets. The optimal criteria for identifying zones on the 31 indicators in five main criteria of time, physical, population, numerous fires and accidents, natural causes and categories of infrastructure are examined. The set of indicators, analyzes the current status of all stations in the city area without proper access to such services was discussed. Next, a review of models and different methods and criteria and indicators used to evaluate the composition to attain the final zone, the Analytical Hierarchy Process (AHP) and fuzzy logic models are used. Then, based on analysis conducted on 42 layers of GIS data production environments based on the specified models, 17 new stations were selected to create the optimal zone. In the final stage, based on the criteria for determining the location of stations, expert opinions Fire Department and field research, in addition to 30 fire stations available (up to 1386) 28 points optimized to create a new station (Map No. 4) designation and is suggested . Since the establishment of priorities proposed stations (of the time) needs to be a priority for them. The priority topic Create a new station on the map (4) is specified.

Keywords

Spatial planning; accident and fire; fire, planning; equipment; location; GIS; AHP

References

احمدی، اردشیر؛ 1370. مکان گزینی نقاط استقرار ایستگاه‌های آتش‌نشانی و خدمات ایمنی در تهران. مجله روش. شماره 9. ص 41.

ایزارد، والتر؛ 1357. روش‌های تحلیل منطقه‌ای. ترجمه کاظم‌زاده صمیمی. تهران: انتشارات دانشگاه ملی ایران. ص 50-48.

بهشتی‌روی، مجید؛ 1374. ضوابط مکان گزینی ایستگاه‌های آتش‌نشانی در شهرهای کشور. انتشارات وزارت کشور. ص 1 تا 10.

بیات، محمد؛ 1375. سازمان‌های خدمات ایمنی و آتش‌نشانی کشورهای اروپایی. تهران: انتشارات انوار. ص 20-10.

پرهیزکار، اکبر. 1376. ارائة الگوی مکان‌گزینی مراکز خدمات شهری با تحقیق در مدل‌ها و GIS شهری. رسالة دکتری دانشگاه تربیت مدرس. تهران. ص 64-27.

سازمان آتش‌نشانی و خدمات ایمنی شهرداری مشهد؛ 1387. آمار مرکز عملیات سازمان آتش‌نشانی. ص 80-55.

سازمان شهرداری‌ها و دهیاری‌های کشور؛ 1378. ماهنامه شهرداری‌ها. شماره 10. ویژه‌نامه آتش‌نشانی. ص 25-15.

لی، کولین؛ 1366. مدل‌ها در برنامه‌ریزی شهری. ترجمه عباس‌زادگان، مصطفی. انتشارات جهاد دانشگاهی تهران. ص 35.

مرکز آمار ایران؛ 1385. نتایج تفصیلی سرشماری نفوس و مسکن. ص 90-50.

شهرداری مشهد؛ 1391. آمارنامه سال 1391. ص 246.

شهرداری تهران؛ 1375. مطالعة مقدماتی نحوة توسعة ایستگاه‌های آتش‌نشانی در تهران. مجله بی‌تا. شماره 9. ص 40-38

وزارت کشور؛ 1383. ارائه مدل و ضوابط مکان گزینی ایستگاه‌های آتش‌نشانی. پرهیزگار، اکبر. تهران.

ص 5-4.

Ahmadi, A., 1370. The location of fire stations and safety services in Tehran. Journal of ravesh. No. 9, pp. 41.

Ayzard, Walter., 1357. Regional analysis. translation Kazemzadeh samimi. Tehran. National University Press. S50-48.

Bhshtyravy, M., 1374. criteria, location of fire stations in the city. The Interior Ministry. pp. 1 to 10.

Bayat, M., 1375., fire safety services organizations in Europe. Tehran. anvar. S20-10.

parhizkar, Akbar., 1376. Model locate in urban centers with models and GIS in urban research. Tarbiat Modarres University doctoral dissertation. Tehran. S64-27.

The Fire and Safety Services Mashhad Municipality., 1387. Statistics Fire Department Operations Center. S80-55.

Municipalities and Dhyary country., 1378. Municipalities Magazine. No. 10. especially a fire. S25-15.

Lee, Colin., 1366. Models in urban planning. translating Baszadgan. Mostafa. Tehran University Jihad Press. p. 35.

Statistical Center of Iran., 1385. Detailed results of the Census of Population and Housing. S90-50.

Mashhad Municipality., 1391. Figures a year. 1391. p. 246.

Tehran Municipality., 1375. Preliminary study of how the development of fire stations in Tehran. B. Journal. No. 9. pp. 40-38

Department of the Interior., 1383. Site selection criteria model and fire stations. parhizgar. Akbar. Tehran.

Pp. 5-4.

Dey, Prasanta Kumar November., 2003. "Analytic Hierarchy Process Analyzes Risk of Operating Cross-Country Petroleum Pipelines in India". Natural Hazards Review. Retrieved 2007-08-20.

Caffrey, James June., 2005. "Test Run: The Analytic Hierarchy Process". MSDN Magazine. Retrieved 2007-08-21.

Chan, F. T. S.; Chan, H. K., 2010. "An AHP model for selection of suppliers in the fast changing fashion market". The International Journal of Advanced Manufacturing Technology 51 (9–12): 1195.

Lewis, Robert J. The application of microcomputers to fire station location planing international Fire chief., 1986 Feb: Vol. 52(no.2): PP.18-21.

Jenks, George F., 1967. "The Data Model Concept in Statistical Mapping". International Yearbook of Cartography 2007: 186.

Reilly, J.M. Development and application of a fire station plcement model. Fire Technology., 1985 Aug: Vol. 21 (no 3): PP. 181-198.

Novak, V. "Are fuzzy sets a reasonable tool for modeling vague phenomena?". Fuzzy Sets and Systems 156 (2005) 341—348.

Saaty, Thomas L., 2010. Principia Mathematica Decernendi: Mathematical Principles of Decision Making. Pittsburgh. Pennsylvania: RWS Publications. ISBN 978-1-888603-10-1.

Saaty, Thomas L.; Peniwati, Kirti., 2008. Group Decision Making: Drawing out and Reconciling Differences. Pittsburgh. Pennsylvania: RWS Publications. ISBN 978-1-888603-08-8.