Ferdowsi's Thoughts and Theories of International Relations Realism or Idealism?

پژوهش نامه ایرانی سیاست بین الملل

Article 1, Volume 7, Issue 2, January 2020, Pages 1-36   

Document Type: مقالات

DOI: 10.22067/jipr.v7i2.71755

Authors

Ali Bagheri Dolatabadi^{* 1}; jafar Hanani²

¹yasouj university

²Yasouj University

Abstract

Abstract
Ferdowsi's Shahnameh is a Persian literature masterpiece. While this book has generally been studied from literary and historical perspectives, little attention has been paid to its political aspects. The main question of the present research is that what International Relations theoretical approaches Ferdowsi’s vision is closer to? Can Ferdowsi be considered a political realist or an idealist? For this purpose, we attempt to assess Ferdowsi's thoughts taking advantage of the most important features of the two Realist and Idealist theories through a comparative method. The findings of the research show that while Ferdowsi is close to constructivist theory in terms of meta-theory, in his theoretical debates he must be considered a realist. This point is especially apparent in Ferdowsi's interpretations of human nature, war, power and security. It is worth Noting that his realism is not similar to Hobbes and Waltz, and is somewhat like "Idealist Realism".

Keywords

Shahnameh; Ferdowsi; realism; Idealism; War; Peace; power

References

References

Abbasi, M., & Fouladi, Y. (2017). Serenading prologues in Shahnameh. Quarterly of Literary Techniques, 9(1), pp. 186-173. (in Persian)

Abdollah Khani, A. (2010). Security Theories. Tehran: Abrar Mo'aser. (in Persian)

Abolhasan Shirzai, H. (2017). Cultural Diplomacy and the Role of Friendship Communities in International Relations. Journal of International Relations, 10(38), pp. 9-25. (in Persian)

Afrasyabpoor, A. A. (2011). Teaching Friendship in Shahnameh. Educational Literature Research, 3(12), pp. 204-181. (in Persian)

Alem, A. (2013). The history of Western political philosophy, the New Era and the Nineteenth Century. Tehran: Department of Political Studies and International Affairs of the Ministry of Foreign Affairs. (in Persian)

Arab Nejad, Z., & Toughyani, I. (2016). The Morphology of Love Stories of Shahnameh. Quarterly of Survey of Texts of Persian Literature, 3(1), pp. 38-23. (in Persian)

Arbelaster, A. (1998). West Liberalism: Rise and Fall. Translation by Abbas Mokhtber. Tehran: Markaz. (in Persian)

Asgarkhani, A. M., & Rahmati, R. (2010). Theory of Realism and International Security. Foreign Policy Quarterly, 21(1), pp. 156-139. (in Persian)

Ashouri, D. (1993). Poetry and thought. Tehran: Markaz. (in Persian)

Ashouri, D. (1994). Gashtha (Trips): Article Collection. Tehran: Institute for Cultural Studies and Research. (in Persian)

Azkia, M. (2003). Applied Research Methods. Tehran: Kayhan Publications.

Bahrami Einolghazi, V., & Eslami, R. (2017). Faramandy/Charisma and Succession Crisis in Shahnameh. Research Letter of Political Science, 13(1), pp.45-72. (in Persian)

Bashirieh, H. (1999). The Theoretical Framework of Political Sociology. Journal of Criticism and Review, 19(1), pp. 298-319. (in Persian)

Blicky, N. (2005). Designing Social Research. Translation by Hassan Chavashian. Tehran: Ney. (in Persian)

Chernov, F. (2011). Theory and Meta-theory in International Relations. Translation by Alireza Tayeb. Tehran: Ney. (in Persian)

Couscoba, K. (2003). Ganji Story and Shahnameh, Comparing Japan Literary Masterpieces and Literary Masterpieces of Iran. Edited by Rouhi. Tehran: Ney. (in Persian)

Dale, J. H. (2008). History of Western Philosophy. Translation by Abdolhossein Azarang. Tehran: Ghoghnoos. (in English)

Dehghani Firoozabadi, S. J. (2010). Foreign Policy of the Islamic Republic of Iran. Tehran: Samt. (in Persian)

Eslami, R., & Bahrami, V. (2015). Political Phenomenology of Farrah Izadi in Avesta and Shahnameh. Research Letter of Political Science, 10(4), pp.7-40. (in Persian)

Ferdowsi, A. (1999). Ferdowsi's Shahnameh (Based on the Nine-Volume Version of Moscow's Edition). Tehran: Ghoghnoos. (in Persian)

Ferdowsi, A. (2008). Ferdowsi's Shahnameh. Editied by Saeed Hamidian. Tehran: Ghatreh. (in Persian)

Ferdowsi, A. (2015). Ferdowsi's Shahnameh (Full Series of Shahnameh Ferdowsi from the Moscow Version). Qom: Adina Sabz. (in Persian)

Ghaderi, H. (2007). Political Thoughts in the Twentieth Century. Eighth edition. Tehran: Samt. (in Persian)

Ghahremanpour, R. (2004). Constructivism: From International Politics to Foreign Policy. Strategic Studies Quarterly, 7(24), pp. 318-299. (in Persian)

Ghavam, A., & Fatemi Nejad, S. A. (2009). The Relationship between War and Anarchy: A Double-Hierarchical Anarchy Critique Based on Shahnameh. Political Science Research Letter, 4(2), pp. 193-152. (in Persian)

Ghavam, A. A. (2006). Principles of Foreign Policy and International Policy. Twelfth Edition. Tehran: Samt.(in Persian)

Hadian, N. (2003). Structuralism: From International Relations to Foreign Policy. Foreign Policy Quarterly, 17(4), pp.45-70. (in Persian)

Haghighat, S. S., & Hejazi, H. (2010). A critical look at the Application of the Theory of the Spragnens Crisis in Political Studies. Political Science Quarterly, 13(49), pp. 1-49. (in Persian)

Hamidi, S. J. (2009). A Look at Ferdowsi's Age and Review the Story of Fereydoun and Zahak in Shahnameh. Book of the Months of Literature, 25(1), May 2009. (in Persian)

Hesampour, S., & Dehghani, N. (2008). The Study of the Types of Covenants and Oaths in Ferdowsi's Shahnameh, the Research Letter of Ghanei Literary, 6(11), pp. 66-37. (in Persian)

Hopf, T. (1998). The Promise of Construction in International Relations Theory. International Security, 23(1), pp.171-200. (in English)

Jones, V. T. (1979). The Lord of Political Thought. Translation by Ali Ramin. Tehran: Amir Kabir. (in Persian)

Karami, J. (2004). Foreign Policy from the Perspective of Social Constructivism. Strategic journal, 31(1), pp. 174-161. (in Persian)

Karimi Kohanjani, R. (2016). Shahnameh, Colorful Epic from the Past of Iran. Book Review Quarterly, 3(12), pp. 262-259. (in Persian)

Kasraee, M. S. (2007). Ferdowsi Political Thought, Journal of Political Science, 4(7), pp. 224-213. (in Persian)

Khaleghi Motlagh, J. (2009). Old words. Editied by Ali Dehbashi. Vol. 3. Tehran: Afkar. (in Persian)

Khalehi Motlagh, J. (2011). Review and Evaluation of Manuscript of the Florence Shahnameh. Baharestan letter, 12(18-19), pp. 207-250. (in Persian)

Khalehi Motlagh, J. (2013). Help rhyme in correcting some bits of Shahnameh. Mirror of Heritage, 53(1), pp. 245-262. (in Persian)

Lak, I., & Tamim Dari, A. (2016). A Comparative Study of the Structure of the Debate and the Heroes' Dialogue in the Shahnameh of Ferdowsi, Iliad and Odyssey Homer: based on some achievements of the American School of Comparative Literature, relying on the method of critical discourse analysis. Comparative Literature Quarterly, 4(2). pp. 175-133. (in Persian)

Menashadi, M. (2017). A Survey on Ferdowsi's Political Views and Thoughts. Siyasatnameh, 6(17), pp.86-88. (in Persian)

Menshanadi, M., & Bahrami Einolghozati, V. (2014). The Protocol of the Embassy and the Ritual of Negotiations in the Shahnameh, Iranian Research Letter of International Policy, 2(1), pp. 137-117. (in Persian)

Meskoob, Sh. (1972). Mourning Siavash. Tehran: Kharazmi. (in Persian)

Meskoob, Sh. (2014). Souvenirs from Ant: An Investigation in Shahnameh. Tehran: Ney. (in Persian)

Meskoob, Sh., & Milaniyan, H. (2002). The Body of the Hero and the Spiritual of Wisdom. Tehran: Tarh-e-No. (in Persian)

Meskoob, Sh. (2013). Introduction to Rostam and Esfandiar. Tehran: Amirkabir. (in Persian)

Mizani, F. (2009). The Epic of Justic: An Argument on the Political Content of the Shahnameh .2nd Edition, Tehran: The Publishing House of the Tudeh Party of Iran. (in Persian)

Mohammadpour, A. (2013). Method of Qualitative Research, Anti-method. Second Edition. Tehran: Jameaeshnasan. (in Persian)

Mojtabaee, F. (1975) A few points about Rostam and Sohrab. Foundation of Shahnameh, The Word (Sokhan), 7- 8(1). (in Persian)

Mojtabaee, F. (1992). A Words About Shahnameh, The Magazine of Being (Majale Hastie), March 1992. (in Persian)

Mojtabaee, F. (1993). An Old Version of Shahnameh, The Future, March-June 1993, pp. 291-302. (in Persian)

Mollah Ahmad, M. (2003). War and Peace in Shahnameh. Persian letter, 10(1), pp. 85-43. (in Persian)

Montasef, M. (2004). Impact of Quran and Hadith in Ferdowsi's Shahnameh. Kermanshah: Razi University of Kermanshah. (in Persian)

Moshirzadeh, H. (2004). Dialogue of Civilizations in Constructivism Perspectives. Journal of Faculty of Law and Political Science, 63(1), pp. 1-261. (in Persian)

Moshirzadeh, H. (2013). The Evolution of the Theory of International Relations. Tehran: Samt. (in Persian)

Naji, M. (2011). Ferdowsi's Political thought. Journal of Culture Research, 12(1), pp. 67-94. (in Persian)

Parham, B. (1994). With the View of Ferdowsi: The Basics of Political Criticism in Iran. Tehran: Markaz. (in Persian)

Ranjbar, A. (2000). Ferdowsi's Intellectual Attractions. Tehran: Amir Kabir. (in Persian)

Rastegar Fasaei, M. (2005). Ferdowsi and Other Poets. Tehran: Tarh-E-No. (in Persian)

Reggie, J. G. (1998). Constructing the World Polity: Essays on International Institutionalization, London and New York: Rutledge. (in English)

Rezaei Eskandari, D. (2005). The Transformation of the Concept of State in Theories of International Relations. Strategic Studies, 27(1), pp. 105- 134. (in Persian)

Rezvanian, Gh.; Ghiaei, N., & Azamzadeh, M. (2016). The Study of the Effect of Ferdowsi's Metaphorical Narrative on writing of Shahnameh. Quarterly of Comparative Literature (Persian Language and Literature Academy), 13(1), pp. 160-129. (in Persian)

Riyahie, M. A. (2016). The Great Value of Shahnameh, Etela'at Newspaper, 9 March 2016. (in Persian)

Rostamvandy, T. (2009). Greed and Justic: Political Pathology of King in Shahnameh Ferdowsi. Theoretical Policy Research, 5(1), pp. 1-19. (in Persian)

Saghebfar, M. (2008). Ferdowsi Shahname and Iran's History philosophy. Tehran: Moein. (in Persian)

Sheyhan, M. (2009). International Security. Translation by Seyed Jalal Dehghani Firoozabadi. Tehran: Center for Strategic Studies. (in English)

Shoayb, B. (2009). Russia and the EU; the Confrontation between Realism and Liberalism. Central Asian and Caucasian Quarterly, 67(1), pp.96-69. (in Persian)

Spragnens, T. (2015). Understanding Political Theories. Translation by Raja'i Farhang. Tehran: Agah. (in Persian)

Tabatabaee, S. J. (2017). A Survey on Ferdowsi's Political Views and Thoughts. Siyasatnameh, 6(17), pp. 89-92. (in Persian)

Wendt, A. (2005). Social Theory of International Politics. Translation by Homeira Moshirzadeh, Tehran: Foreign Affairs Publication. (in Persian)

Wohlforth, W. C. (2008). Realism and Foreign Policy, in: Foreign Policy: Theories, Actors, and Cases. Edited by Steve Smith, Amelia Hadfield and Tim Dunne, Oxford University press. (in English)

ZarinKoob, A. (2002). Namwar letter: About Ferdowsi and Shahnameh. Tehran: Sokhan. (in Persian)