Decision Support System for Economic Value of Irrigation Water with Reducing the Food Gap in Agro-Ecological Zones

اقتصاد و توسعه کشاورزی

Article 4, Volume 30, Issue 4, December 2017, Pages 345-359   

Document Type: Research Article

DOI: 10.22067/jead2.v30i4.58208

Authors

F. Bahrami Mehneh^{* 1}; A.,A,. Keikha²; M. Sabouhi³; M. Ahmadpour Borazjani²

¹Zabol University and Researcher of Institute for Trade Studies and Research

²Zabol University

³Ferdowsi University of Mashhad

Abstract

Introduction: Water scarcity has become a global issue due to its direct relationship with food security. For this reason, the need for the long-term sustainable use of water necessitates the application of effective strategies. In this regard, strategic programs are utilized in water resource management and agricultural policies in order to increase self-sufficiency, to reduce the food gap, to decrease the cultivation of water based products, to maximize the economic value of water and to guarantee efficient allocation of resources among different activities in most parts of the world. The main objective of this study is to develop a decision support system to achieve the above-mentioned policies and strategies in the ten agricultural and ecological zones in the country according to the amount of virtual water for crop production.
Data and Methods: The decision support system seeks to introduce an optimum pattern and to investigate the current status of water resources and determine the food gap and virtual economic value by means of a linear programming model. It intends also to determine the return on investment of crop production in each region. Our goal of this research is to maximize the value of virtual water with respect to land and availability of surface water and groundwater constraints. We also consider socio-economic constraints to ensure minimum and maximum area under cultivation in every region. In order to achieve accurate results, the social value of goods and inputs has been used in the model. In determining the social value of all goods and tradable inputs, prices of the border with a shadow exchange rate are used. Given the importance of addressing the amount of water used to produce goods, the virtual water content of products on maximizing the economic value of water is used in this study. Due to climatic conditions and consequently the performance of production in different regions, we use water requirement to crop yield ratio for every region for calculation of the virtual water content of a product. In this study, water valuation was based on value added inputs, while social values were used as criteria in its calculation. The data are gathered from the database of the Ministry of Agriculture, Ministry of Energy and the relevant agencies in the region. We used the 32.5 Edition of GAMS software to estimate the proposed model.
Results: The results show the amount of water used by farmers to grow major crops in different regions in 1392, was 19 billion cubic meters. Central Zagros with 3.8 billion cubic meters and the Central dry zone with 1.2 billion cubic meters have respectively the largest and smallest water consumption. The results also showed the greatest change and lowest change in economic value of irrigation water related to wet wheat and wet cotton respectively. The regional view, the greatest and the lowest value of water refers respectively to the South Zagros region and the region of Khuzestan. Research results show that the pattern of demand reduces the food gap through increased cultivation of some strategic products. In order to reduce the food gap, one of the most important strategies is the increased cultivation of the wheat crop.
Conclusion: This study provided a cultivating pattern in order to meet two important goals: cutting water consumption and reducing the food gap by increasing the cultivation of strategic crops such as wheat. In fact, by implementing appropriate Logistic policies, the government and politicians can achieve the aforementioned objectives by diversifying the current cultivation pattern in the desired region in compliance with environmental, economic and food security and health security considerations. The economic value of irrigation water and reduction of the area under cultivation is also a consequence of the proposed program. Instead of providing constant value in all regions of a country, providing an optimal cultivation pattern while considering the exact value of virtual water is a better policy. The proposed cropping pattern reduces Food gap and the area of water-based production cultivation and reduces water consumption, which can be used for producing strategic crops. The proposed cropping pattern increases the economic value of water by 20%. Indeed, it suggests that acreage crops such as wheat, pulses, and oil seeds are increased and rice and sugar beet cultivation is decreased. The main objective of the proposed cropping patterns to reduce the food gap and increase the welfare of consumers.

Keywords

Economic value of water; Optimum cropping pattern; Food gap; Linear programing

References

Abonouri E., Mohammadi H., and Norouzi Nejad M. 2011. The estimated economic value of water in agriculture. Hedonic methods (study city of Sabzevar). Journal of Agricultural Economics, (2)5: 21 - 57. [In Persian]

2- Amir Teimouri S., and Bagherzadeh A. 2008. The place of water in agriculture of Iran and its pricing. Third International Conference on Water Resources Management; Tabriz University. Iran. [In Persian]

3- Aref Sh. 2007. The economic value of Mill Dam Magi due to optimum cropping pattern. Master's Thesis, Faculty of Economic Sciences, Tehran University: 116 - 127. [In Persian]

4- Azadegan E., Rastegari Poor F., and Sabouhi M. 2013. Determining planning applications using fuzzy Dvnva crops Sabzevar city. Journal of Agricultural Economics and Development,(1)27: 8 - 15[In Persian]

5- Chizari A H., Sharzehi Gh., and Keramatzadeh E. 2007. The determination of economic value with an ideal planning approach (Case Study: Barzoo Shirvan dam). Journal of Economic Research, (4)40: 39 – 76. [In Persian]

6- Dehghanpour H., and Sheikh Zeindin A. 2013. The determination of economic value of agriculture in the plain of Yazd-Ardakan, Yazd region. Journal of Agricultural Economics and Development,(82)21: 45 - 68.[In Persian]

7- Doppler W., Salman AZ., Al-Karablieh E.K., and Wolf H.P. 2002. The impact of water price strategies on the allocation of irrigation water: the case of the Jordan Valley. Agricultural Water Management, (55): 171-182.

8- Ebrahimi N., Yazdani S., and Moghadasi R. 2013. Management of supply and demand of Agricultural water. The fifth of Resource management water Conference [In Persian].

9- El-Gafy I.K. 2014. Decision support system to maximize economic value of irrigation water at the Egyptian governorates meanwhile reducing the national food gap. Water Sci, http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.wsj.2013.12.001.

10- Fallahi A., and Khalilian S. 2009. The comparing the importance of petroleum products and electricity with other factors of production in the agricultural sector of Iran, Journal of Agricultural Economics,(2)1: 1 – 19. [In Persian]

11- Food Balance Sheet Islamic Republic of Iran. 2013.

12- Keramatzadeh E., Chizari E., and Mirzaei. A. 2006. Agricultural economic value with optimal crop pattern model of combining agriculture and horticulture study Barzoo Shirvan dam. Journal of Agricultural Economics and Development,54: 35 - 60.[In Persian]

13- Mansouri M., and Gheasi E. 2002. The estimation of cost of agricultural water dams with engineering economics approach, case study dams Bukan, Mahabad in West Azerbaijan and Baron, Journal of Agricultural Economics and Development, (37)10: 171 – 192.[In Persian]

14- MALR E. 2009. Strategy of Agricultural Development in Egypt until 2030. Ministry of Agricultural and Land Reclamation. Cairo. Egypt.

15- Mesa- Jurado M.A., Martin- Ortega J., Ruto E., and Berbel J. 2012. The economic value ofguaranteed water supply for irrigation under scarcity conditions. Agricultural WaterManagement, 113: 10-18.

16- Ministry of Agriculture. Agricultural statistics, agricultural products. 2013.

17- Ministry of Power, Foundations set water charges. Alnzarh and subscription rights, the Iran Water Resources Management. Water Affairs Department, Ministry of Energy. 2012.

18- Molle F., Venot J.P., and Youssef Hassan A. 2008. Irrigation in the Jordan Valley: Are water pricing policies overly optimistic? Agricultural Water Management,95: 427-438.

19- Montazer A A., and Mir Shafiei S. 2012. Development and application of multi-criteria model or fuzzy pricing of water in irrigation networks. Journal of Agricultural Economics, (3)6: 226 – 237. (in Persian)

20- Mwesa G. 2012. Agricultural Sector Model of Egypt (ASME) 2011 Version at Governorate Level with 2007 Database and Update Instructions. Ministryof Water Resources and Irrigation Planning Sector, National Water Resources Plan, Coordination Project (NWRP-CP).

21- Parhizkari A., and Sabouhi M. 2013. The simulation the response of farmers to reduce irrigation water available policy. Water and Irrigation,(2)3:59 - 74. (In Persian)

22- Parhizkari A. 2013. Determining the economic value of irrigation water and the farmers' responses to price and non policies in the area of Qazvin. Master thesis of Agricultural Economics, University of Zabol, Faculty of Agriculture. [In Persian]

23- Parhizkari A., Sabouhi M., and Zeiaei S. 2013. Water market share of irrigation water policy simulation and analysis of impacts on crops under drought conditions. Agricultural Economics and Development, (3)27:1 – 12. [In Persian].

24- Rahnama A., Kohansal M R.., and Dorandish A. 2012. The estimation of the economic value of water using positive mathematical programming approach in the city Ghoochan. Journal of Agricultural Economic,(6)4: 133 – 150.[In Persian].

25- Riazi H., and Montazer E. 2008. Development and application of surface and underground water resources allocation model Qazvin Plain Irrigation Network. The second National Conference irrigation and drainage networks. Shahid Chamran University. [In Persian]

26- Sabouhi M., and Parhizkari A. 2013. Analysis of economic and welfare impacts of irrigation water market in the area of Qazvin. Journal of Agricultural Economics and Development, (4)27: 338 – 350. [In Persian]

27- Rigby D., Alcon F., and Burtons M. 2010. Supply uncertainty and the economic value ofirrigation water, European Review of Rgricultural Economics, 37: 97-117.

28- Salman A., and Al-Karablieh. E. 2004. Measuring the willingness of farmers to pay for groundwater in the highland areas of Jordan. Agricultural Water Management,68(1): 61–76.

29- Siam G., and Moussa H. 2003. Food security in Egypt under economic liberalization policies and WTO agreement. International Conference Agricultural Policy Reform and the WTO: Where are we Heading? Capri, Italy. :23–26 June.

30- Teerink J.R., and Nakashima M. 1993. Water allocation, rights and pricing. examples for Japan and the United States, World Bank technical paper. (68)198.

31- www.fao.org/nr/land/database/sinformation/en.