Comparison Ability of Three Plant Pesticides, Two Chemical Acaricides and Conventional Mineral Oil against Citrus Red Mite Panonychus citri (McGregor) (Acarina: Tetranychidae)

پژوهش های حفاظت گیاهان ایران

Article 4, Volume 30, Issue 2 - Serial Number 35, June 2016, Pages 304-312   

Document Type: Research Article

DOI: 10.22067/jpp.v30i2.46028

Authors

Iman Jafari^{* 1}; behnam amiri-besheli²; Mahmoud Mohammadi Sharif³

¹Sari Agricultural Science and Natural resourcesural

²Sari AgriculturalSciences and Natural resources

³Sari Agricultural Sciences and Natural Resources University

Abstract

Introduction: The harmful plant mites not only feed on crops, but also have irreversible damage to humans. The synthetic pesticides can be replaced with natural products for pest control. The agricultural products, health and hygienic of humans can be treated with harmful caused by the mites (Wooley, 1988). The citrus red mite (CRM) Panonychus citri (McGregor) (Acarina: Tetranychidae) is one of the most important herbivorous pests in citrus growth area. For the first time, this pest was reported from Mazandaran province in 1940. The nymph and adult of these pests create identified small, silver and gray spot on leaves and fruits. As a result of feeding, contamination can cause necrosis of leaves, loses of young leaves and reduce the plant freshness. The synthetic of pesticides has been used for controlling of this pest for a long time. The application of non-normative methods for control of the mites can cause pest outbreaks and destroy the natural enemies of the pest. This pest has been resistant to a wide range of pesticides such as; Dicofol, Hexythiazox, Abamectin and Pyrothroids in field conditions. In recent decays, the organic agriculture has been grown dramatically. Lio (2003) has reported that at least 30 countries produce organic citrus fruit. So, for growing organic citrus in Iran, it also suggested to use the low impact pesticides to the environment and the human health. In this research, the comparison toxicity of three botanical pesticides Tondexir (red pepper extract), Sirinol (garlic extract), Palizin (eucalyptus extract) with two common chemical pesticides (Hexythiazox and Fenpyroximate) and common mineral oil has been investigated against adult and protonymph of citrus red mite P.citri.
Materials and Methods: The citrus red mite (CRM) has been collected from infected trees from citrus orchard and brought into the lab; after that, the adult and nymphs were separated. The citrus red mite has been reared on citrus leaves in growth chambers with constant condition (25 ±2oC, 16:8 L/D and 60% RH conditions). The primary test has been done to identify the maximum and minimum concentration. For bioassay experiments, the citrus leaves were washed and cleaned with distilled water and prepared in 20 mm diameter leaf disc. The bioassay was carried out using leaf dip methods with different concentration of the following pesticides after primary experiment: Mineral oils (2000, 2828, 4000, 5657 and 8000 ppm), Tondexir (1000, 1368, 1871, 2559 and 3500 ppm), Sirinol (750, 1102, 1620, 2381 and 3500 ppm), Palizin (2000, 2378, 2828, 3364 and 4000 ppm), Hexythiazox (250, 370, 548, 811 and 1200 ppm) and Fenpyroximate (500, 679, 922, 1252 and 1700 ppm). The mortality was recorded at 24, 48 and 72 h after-treatments. All experiments were conducted with three replications. The statistical analyses were performed by SPSS version16.0 software.
Results and Discussions: The Probit analysis was shown that the LC50 value of the mineral oils on protunymph and adult of citrus red mite were 1743.6 and 1898 ppm, the LC50 value of the Tondexir were1305.9 and 1549 ppm, the LC50 value of the Sirinol were 666.1 and 693.9 ppm, the LC50 value of the Palizin were 2206 and 1969.2 ppm and the LC50 value of the Hexythiazox were 223.6 and 227.3 ppm at 72 h post-treatments, respectively consequently and the probit analysis was revealed that the LC50 value of the Fenpyroximate on protonymph and adult of citrus red mite were 480 and 439.3 ppm at 72 h post-treatments, respectively. Consistent with our result, the acaricide, Hexythiazox had higher toxicity on adult and protonymph of CRM in comparison to the other pesticides. Among three botanical pesticides, Sirinol has the highest toxicity. Due to the low risk of three botanical pesticides, they should be considered in IPM program.
Conclusion: The data analysis of this research was shown that among different compounds, the highest and lowest toxicity on adult and protonymph were obtained with Hexythiazox and Plazin consequently respectively. By comparison the LC50 values, the protonymph was more susceptible than adult. With regards of being low risk and natural products of the botanical pesticides and mineral oils for humans, it is better to use these products to control red mites.

Keywords

Citrus red mite; Natural products; Palizin; Sirinol; Tondexir

References

1- Amiri-Besheli B. 2009. Toxicity evaluation of Tracer, Palizin, Sirinol, Runner and Tondexir with and without mineral oils on Phylocnistis citrella Stainton. African Journal of Biotechnology, 8 (14): 3382-3386.

2- Arbabi M. 2005. The results of one decade research of acaricides on mites causing damage in Iran. The first national conference of the half a century of use of chemical industry and plant pesticides. University of Science and Technology Iran (12-16 June ) 61-67pp. (in Persian)

3- Arbabi M. 2010. Analysis of the use of chemical pesticides in control of mites causing damage in Iran. P. 145-159. National conference of the half a century of use pesticides in Iran. 2-3 March. Iran. (in Persian)

4- Beattie G.A.C. 1990. Citrus petroleum spray oils. Agfact H2.AE. 5( NSW Agriculture and Fisheries), pp 6.

5- Beattie G.A.C., and Smith D. 1993. Citrus leafminer. Agfact HZ.AE.4, 2nd edition, Sydney: NSW Agriculture and Fisheries, Australia. pp 6.

6- Behdad A. 1990. Pest of fruit crop in Iran. Maraze Nashre Bahman, 841 pp. (in Persian)

7- Chen G.H., and Wang A.Z. 2001. Test on the resistance of Panonychus citri to Dicofol and pyridaben. Hunan Agricultural Sciences. 4: 48.

8- Damavandian M.R. 2005. The Control of citrus rust mite without environmental contamination acaricides. Journal of environmental studies, 38: 103-108. (in Persian)

9- Damavandian M. R., and Jafarabadi M.A. 2009. The control of Citrus Red Mite without use of Environmental. Journal of environmental studies, 33 (42): 83-88. (in Persian)

10- Edwards I.R., Ferry D.H., and Temple W.A. 1991. Fungicides and related compounds. In: Handbook of Pesticide Toxicology, v3, W.J. Hayes, Jr. and E. R. Laws, Jr. editors Academic Press, San Diego, CA. pp 1409-1470.

11- Edwards Clive A. U.S. Environmental Protection Agency. (2011). Pesticides. Available at http://www.epa.gov

12- Fadamiro H., Mensah C.A., Xiao Y., and Anikwe J. 2013. Field evaluation of predacious mites (Acari: Phytoseidae) for biological control of citrus red mites, Panonychus citri (Trombidiformes: Tetranychidae). Florida Entomology, 96 (1): 80- 91.

13- Farazmand H., Sirjani M., JafariNadoshan A., Azadbakhat N., Moshiri A., Naserian N., and Ahmadeh Rad S. 2013. Effect of herbal insecticides, palizin and tondexir, on pomergaranate aphid and mite.pp 368. 20th Iranian Plant Protection Congress, 25–28 August. Iran. (in Persian with English abstract)

14- Farid A. 1993. Study on bioecology and control Aonedelia orientalis in Jiroft and Hormozgan. Journal of Entomology and Phytopathology of Iran, 61: 96-105. (in Persian with English abstract)

15- Food and Agriculture Oranization of the United Nations. 2011. Pesticides as water pollutants - FAO: FAO Home, Available at http://www.fao.org.

16- Jamieson L.E., Charles J.G., Stevens P.S., Mckenna C.E., and Bawden R. 2005. Natural enemies of the citrus red mites (Panonychu scitri) in citrus orchards. New Zealand Plant Protection, 58: 299-305.

17- Hu J.F., Wang C.F., Wang J., You Y., and Chen F. 2010. Monitoring of resistance to spirodiclofen and five other acaricides in Panonychu scitri collected from Chinese citrus orchards. Pest Managgement Science, 66: 1025–1030.

18- Huang G.Y., Xu Z.H., and Fang Z.G. 1999. Studies on pesticide resistance of Panonychus citri. Journal of Zhejiang University Science, 6: 252-259.

19- Huang M.D.1979. Integrated management of citrus red mite. Chinese Science Press Beijing, 361-369.

20- Kabiri M., and Amiri-Behesli B. 2012. Toxicty of Palizin, Mospilan and Consult on Agonoscena pisticae Burckarat and Lanuter (Hemiptera: Psyllidae), Oenopia conglobata L. (Coleopteran: Coccinellidae) and Psyllaephaus pistaciae Frriiere (Hym: Encyrtidae), Academic journal of Entomology, 5: 99-107.

21- Kazem M.G.T., and El-Shereif S.A. 2010. Toxic Effect of capsicum and garlic xylene extracts in toxicity of boiled linseed oil formulations against some piercing sucking cotton pests. American- Eurasian Journal of Agricultural & Environmental Science, 8: 390-396.

22- Keifer M., McConnell R., Pacheco A.F., Daniel W., and Rosenstock L. 1996. Estimating under reported pesticide poisonings in Nicaragua. American Journal of Industrial Medicine, 30: 195-201.

23- Li Z.Q., Cen Y., Liang G., and Zeng L. 2011. Evaluation of organic management system on the population control of Panonychu scitri (Acari: Tetranychidae) in a citrus orchard in South China. International Journal of Acarilogy, 37 (6): 485-489.

24- Li Z.Q., Liang G.W., Cen Y.J., and Zeng L. 2009. Roles of organic management in restoration of arthropod community diversity in citrus orchard. Chinese Journal of Ecology. 28(8): 1515–1519.

25- Liu P. 2003. World Markets for organic citrus and citrus juices. Food and Agriculture of the United Nations (FAO), Rome. 26 pp.

26- Mafi Pashakolai Sh., Barari A., Valiollahpour H., and Babai M. 2012. The effect of used pesticides of Citrus orchard against lady beetle Cryptolaemus montrouzieri in Mazandaran Province the second national Integrated Pest Management (IPM) Kerman 197-206. (in Persian)

27- Nadimi A., Kamali K., Arbabi M., and Abdoli F. 2008. Side-effects of three acarideson the predatory mite, Phytoseiulus persimilis Athias-Henriot (Acari: Phytoseiidae) under laboratory conditions. Munis Entomology & Zoology, 3 (2): 556-567.

28- Natesc C. 2003. Pesticides resistance monitoring of Chinese agricultural pest (No. 1). Pesticides Express, 18: 23-24.

29- Osakabe M., Goka K., Toda S., Shintaku T., and Amano H. 2005. Significance of habitat type for the genetic population structure of Panonychus citri (McGregor) (Acarina: Tetranychidae). Experimental and Applied Acarology, l36: 25-40.

30- Pimental D. 1995. Amounts of pesticide reaching target pests: environmental impacts and ethics. Journal of Agricultural and Environmental Ethics 8: 17-29.

31- Ranjbar S., and Heydari A. 2011. Evaluation of control of Eastern yellow citrus scale with mineral oils spray and side effect on masked two spotted ladybird Chilocorus bipustulatus L. National conference of the half a century of use pesticides in Iran, Tehran. 527-541. (in Persian)

32- Shaieghi M., Khobdel M., Ghamisi A., Selseleh M., Abolhasani M., and Nasirian H. 2008. Investigation and determination of the amount of organo phosphate insecticides malathion and diazinon residues in Karaj Dam catchment. Environmental Science and Technology, 10: 257-266.

33- Smith S.F., and Krischik V.A. 2000. Effects of biorational pesticides on four coccinellid species (Coleoptera: Coccinellidae) having potential as biological control agents in interio rscapes. Journal of Economic Entomology, 93(3): 732-736.

34- Yu D., Wang Ch-F., Yu Y., Huang Y-Q., Yao J-A., and Hu J-F. 2011. Laboratory selection for spirodiclofen resistance and cross-resistance in Panonychus citri. African Journal of Biotechnology, 10(17): 3424-3429.

35- Van Leeu wen T., Van Nieuwenhuyse P., Van Holme B., Dermauw W., Nauen R., and Tirry L. 2011. Parallel evolution of cytochrome b mediated bifenazate resistance in the citrus red mite Panonychus citri. Insect Molecular Biology, 20(1): 135-140.

36- Woolley T.A. 1998. Acarology and mite and human welfare. Wiley Publishes, New Yourk. 484 pp.