Examining Crone's Quranic Documents regarding the Absence of Physical Idols in the Prophet's Era

علوم قرآن و حدیث

Article 3, Volume 54, Issue 1 - Serial Number 108, September 2022, Pages 53-72   

Document Type: Original Article

DOI: 10.22067/jquran.2022.68948.1057

Authors

Elham Rasouli¹; Zeinab al-Sadat Hoseini^{* 2}

¹MA Graduate, University of Mazandaran

²Associate Professor, University of Mazandaran

Abstract

Many orientalists have studied the Holy Quran with different approaches and Patricia Crone is one of them. By using Quranic verses, she claimed in her article entitled "The Religion of the Quranic Pagans" that the pagans (Mushrikūn) were monotheists. As reasons for her claim, she stated that there were no idols in Mecca for the idolatry ritual to be mentioned in the Quran, Mecca was not an agricultural environment so gifts could be provided for this ritual. Also, she argued that Gods, Lāt, etc were lesser and independent intermediary deities that the Arabs called angels. Moreover, in her opinion, although Mushrikūn believed in a wide variety of gods, because of their belief to one creator, they are considered monotheists. So, by using a descriptive-analytical method and based on the Quran's verses, her claim was critically studied in this paper. The findings suggest that she has not understood the meaning of Tawhīd (monotheism) correctly; because pagans believed in multiplicity of gods and denied the monotheism of partial lordship. Moreover, according to the Quranic verses such as 21:99, the polytheists had made idols for Lāt and other gods and they weren't conceptual. Also, some verses refer to the existence of agriculture in some regions of Arabia. So, it was possible to provide harvests for gifting in this way or through trade. Furthermore, due to the pagans' respect for idols, they would not offer these gifts without rituals. As a result, there have been physical idols and special rituals for them during the Prophet's era and Muhammad (PBUH) is the destroyer of both physical and conceptual idols of polytheists.
 

Keywords

Crone; The Quran and Physical idols in the prophet's era; Mentioning the ritual for idol in the Quran; Monotheism of Quranic polytheists

References

قرآن کریم

ابن­‌فارس، ابوالحسین احمد، معجم مقاییس اللغه. تحقیق و ضبط عبدالسلام محمدهارون. قم: الحوزه العلمیه، مکتب الاعلام الاسلامی، 1404ق/1362ش.

ابن‌منظور، ابوالفضل، لسان العرب، بیروت: دارصادر، 1375ق.

جفری، آرتور، واژه‏‌هاى دخیل در قرآن مجید، تهران، توس، 1385ش.

جوادی آملی، عبداللّه، تسنیم، قم، انتشارات إسراء، 1386ش.

عبدالباقی، محمدفؤاد، المعجم المفهرس لالفاظ القرآن الکریم، تهران، انتشارات اسماعیلیان، 1364 ش.

فراهیدی، خلیل، العین، تحقیق مهدی مخزومی و ابراهیم سامرائی، تصحیح اسعد الطیب، قم، سازمان اوقاف و امور خیریه، انتشارات اسوه، 1410ق.

کلبی، ابن هشام، الأصنام(بت­‌های عرب)، ترجمه سید محمدرضا جلالی نایینی، تهران، نشر نو، 1364.

مشکور، محمدجواد، فرهنگ تطبیقی زبان‌های سامی و ایرانی. بی­‌جا، انتشارات بنیاد فرهنگ ایران، 1357ش.

مصطفوی، حسن، التحقیق فی کلمات القرآن، تهران، مرکز نشر آثار العلامه مصطفوی، بیروت، دارالکتب العلمیه، 1297ق.

Crone, Patricia, Institute for Advanced Study, The Religion of the Qurʾānic Pagans: God and the Lesser Deities, Arabica. 57(2010). PP. 200-151.