The Perception of Middle Eastern Leaders Regarding the Axis of Resistance Focused on Iran: A Case Study of Turkish and Saudi Arabian Perceptions

پژوهش نامه ایرانی سیاست بین الملل

Article 3, Volume 12, Issue 1 - Serial Number 23, November 2023, Pages 59-93   

Document Type: Original Article

DOI: 10.22067/irlip.2023.77772.1303

Authors

najmiyeh poresmaili^{* 1}; Ali Ali Esmaeili Ardakani²

¹. PhD student in International Relations, Faculty of Law and Political Sciences, Allameh Tabatabai University, Tehran, Iran

². Assistant Professor of International Relations at Allameh Tabataba’i University

Abstract

Perceptions and misperceptions frequently affect government relations, subsequently impeding regional relationships. The present state of affairs in the Middle East is a perfect instance of how influential actors' perceptions and misperceptions affect the area, which remains a debated topic. Since the leaders of Turkey and Saudi Arabia have distinct personalities and mentalities, they take different approaches in terms of perspectives, analyses, judgments, and foreign policies on a variety of topics in the Middle East, particularly in relation to Iranian foreign policy goals and priorities. Therefore, it is crucial to examine how these varying mentalities have impacted their approaches to different regional and international issues. The article examines the differing perspectives of Turkish and Saudi Arabian leaders regarding the nature and goals of the Axis of Resistance, a crucial element of the regional political and security structure. The authors present a three-part series of propositions to clarify the reasoning behind these leaders' views on the Axis of Resistance. The differences in policies and actions among these leaders show that their varying mentalities, influenced by the three aforementioned propositions, have affected strategies and actions related to important matters like regional security, interactions with Western nations, the Axis of Resistance, and resolving the Palestinian-Israeli conflict.
 

Keywords

Erdogan; Mohammad bin Salman; Malik Salman; Middle East; Axis of Resistance

References

General Administration of Bills, Compilation and Revision of Laws and Regulations
(undated). The Complete Text of the Constitution of the Islamic Republic of Iran with the
Amendments of 1368. Tehran: Ministry of Science, Research and Technology. Available at:
https://moghararat.msrt.ir/file/download/regulation /1497687031-.pdf [in Persian] Istanbul/Anatolia News Agency. (October 22, 2019).
Erdogan: The Statements of some Iranian Officials Upset me. from Anatolia news agency.
Retrieved in 11 January 2021. Available at: https://bit.ly/39hhrfh [in Persian].
Afshon, toraj & Allahkaram, Abdolhossein (September 2018). Comparison and Conflict of
US- Heshad al-Sha'bi Security Approach in Iraq; Procedure and Perspective. 11(42). 41-
72. Available at: http://www.iaujournals.ir/article_543183_
8580574f9471e84243fb72c64b0e2683.pdf [in Persian].
Iran Sputnik (March 31, 2018). Crown of Saudi Arabia: Assad will Remain in Power. Iran
Sputnik, Retrieved in 11 April 2021. https://bit.ly/3gug4ik. [in Persian].
Ankara/Anatolia News Agency (December 01, 2016). Turkey does not Recognize the
Government of the Houthis in Yemen. Anatolia News Agency. Retrieved in 18 November
2021. https://bit.ly/3js7ukc [in Persian].
Ankara/Anatolia News Agency (January 12, 2016). Erdogan: Iran is Trying to Ignite a New
Dangerous Trend. Anatolia News Agency. Retrieved in 10 November 2021.
https://bit.ly/39gxrtq. [in Persian].
Ankara/Anatolia News Agency (February 28, 2020). Turkey: All the Targets of the Assad
Regime are under Intense Bombardment by our Air and Ground Forces. From Anatolia
News Agency. Retrieved in 11 November 2021. https://bit.ly/30uqsc8. [in Persian].
BBC Farsi (May 20, 2017). Trump and the King of Saudi Arabia's fierce attack on Iran.
BBC Farsi. Retrieved in 11 November 2021. http://www.bbc.com/persian/iran-39991567.
[in Persian].
BBC Farsi (May 31, 2019). King Salman: Iran is a threat to global security. From BBC
Farsi. Retrieved in 11 November 2021. https://www.bbc.com/persian/iran-48470018 [in
Persian].
BBC Farsi (May 2018). In other words: BBC World Service interview with Recep Tayyip
Erdogan. BBC Persian. Retrieved in 9 August 2021.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?V=6wz9w1j3rya. [in Persian].
Eltyaminia, Reza, Dolat Abadi, Bagheri, Ali & Nikfar, Jaseb (December 2016). Yemen
Crisis: Survey of Contexts and Goals of External Intervenes Saudi Arabia and America.
5(18)-Serial Number 48, December 2016, Pages 171-198.
http://qpss.atu.ac.ir/article_6802_8857cec3f9b35d596149bcc49d8298c7.pdf. [in Persian]
Jervis, Robert (November 23, 2011). The Upward Spiral of International Insecurity.
Translation: Alireza Tayeb. Tehran: Raskhun. Retrieved in 11 May 2021.
https://bit.ly/38yf0tg. [in Persian].
Chin, Christian & Mittelman, James (2009). Conceptualizing resistance to globalization.
Perspectives on World Politics. edited by Richard Little and Michael Smith. Translation.
Alireza Tayeb Tehran: Scientific and Cultural Publishing Company. [in Persian].
Dubai-Al Arabiya. Farsi Net (February 17, 2017). Detailed Interview of Recep Tayyip
Erdogan with Al-Arabiya network. Al Arabiya Persian. Retrieved in 17 November 2020.
https://farsi.alarabiya.net/fa/middle-east/2017/02/17/a9.html. [in Persian].
Dubai.Al-Arabiya.net Farsi (November 16, 2017). Al-Jubeir: Hezbollah is a Weapon in the
Hands of Iran that Threatens the Stability of Lebanon and the Region. Al-Arabiya Persian.
Retrieved in 19 September 2021. https://bit.ly/2onroje. [in Persian].
Dubai.Al-Arabiya.Net Farsi (November 17, 2017). Al-Jubeir: Without the disarmament of
Hezbollah. There will be no Peace in Lebanon. Persian Arabic. Al-Arabiya Persian.
Retrieved in 10 November 2021. https://bit.ly/2zuevdh. [in Persian].

Dubai-Al Arabiya. Farsi Net (April 3, 2018). Commentary on the Atlantic American
magazine's interview with Prince Mohammed bin Salman - part two. Al-Arabiya Persian.
Retrieved in 17 November 2021. https://bit.ly/2oox8fr. [in Persian].
Dubai-Al-Arabiya.net Farsi (October 26, 2017). Saudi Crown Prince: We will not Allow
Another Hezbollah to Emerge Near our Borders. Al-Arabiya Persian, Retrieved in 16
November 2021. https://bit.ly/3ewmefv. [in Persian].
Dubai-Al-Arabiya.net. Farsi (September 19, 2016). Al-Jubeir to Zarif: Iran Supports
Terrorism with undeniable Facts. Al-Arabiya Persian. Retrieved in 18 August 2021.
https://bit.ly/3ja69yq. [in Persian].
Dubai-Al-Arabiya.net. Farsi (December 23, 2015). King Salman's Emphasis on the Fight
against Terrorism, Support for Palestine and a Political Solution in Syria and Yemen. Al-
Arabiya Persian. Retrieved in 15 March 2021. https://bit.ly/3gyvcga [in Persian].
Leader.ir: The Office of the Supreme Leader. (22 February 2017). Statement of "The
Second Step of the Revolution". addressed to the people of Iran. Leader.ir: The Office of the
Supreme Leader. Retrieved in 15 November 2021. https://farsi.khamenei.ir/message-
content?Id=41673. [in Persian].
Leader.ir: The Office of the Supreme Leader. (March 25, 2014). Statements in the Meeting
of the Members of the Assembly of Representatives of Students and Alumni of Qom
Seminary. Leader.ir: The Office of the Supreme Leader. Retrieved in 17 June 2021.
http://farsi.khamenei.ir/speech-content?Id=32763. [in Persian].
Leader.ir: The Office of the Supreme Leader. (August 22, 2018). The Meeting between the
Spokesman of the Ansar Allah Movement in Yemen and the Delegation with the Leader of
the Revolution. Leader.ir: The Office of the Supreme Leader. Retrieved in 3 July 2021.
https://farsi.khamenei.ir/news-content?Id=43236 .[in Persian].
DW Persian (16 May 2018). The United States and Six Arab Countries Sanctioned
Lebanon's Hezbollah Leaders. DW Persian. Retrieved in 18 november 2021.
https://www.dw.com/fa-ir/a-43824321. [in Persian].
DW Persian (December 27, 2015). Erdogan's Criticism of Iran's "Sectarian Policy" in Syria.
DW Persian. Retrieved in 18 november 2021. https://bit.ly/3jxk6er. [in Persian].
DW Persian (May 27, 2013). Increasing Turkish criticism of Hezbollah and Iran's
involvement in Syria. DW Persian. Retrieved in 18 november 2021. https://bit.ly/2e05nwj.
[in Persian].
Rameshgar, Rahim (undated). Political Psychology and Recognition of Leaders. Aryan.
Http://www.ariaye.com/dari13/elmi/rahim3.pdf. [in Persian].
Al-Alam-Turkey (February 15, 2017). Erdogan Talks about his Country's Relations with
Syria +Video. Al-Alam Network. Retrieved in 18 november 2021.
https://fa.alalamtv.net/news/4043476/. [in Persian].
Moshirzadeh, Homeyra (2017). Theoretical Foundations of Foreign Policy Explanation
and Analysis. Tehran: Samt. [in Persian].
Al-Masri, Ahmed (20 April 2017). Erdogan's opposition to the division of Syria and Iran's
policy in the region. Anatolia News Agency. Retrieved in 8 February 2022.
https://bit.ly/2cbhobd, [in Persian].
Mirghaderi, S.F & Kiyani. Hussein (April 2012). Purporst of Resistance Literature in the
Quran. 01(1), -Serial Number 1. Pages 69-97.
http://jrla.isca.ac.ir/article_131_a7bdac3fe91f5ba2047432fa4f41d78f.pdf. [in Persian]

Turkish Radio and Television Corporation (trt) (20 April 2017). Erdogan's Opposition to
the Division of Syria and Iran's Policy in the Region. Turkish Radio and Television
Corporation (trt). Retrieved in 1 December 2022. https://www.trt.net.tr/persian/thlyl-w-
gzrsh/2017/04/20/mkhlft-rdwgn-b-tjzyh-swryh-w-syst-yrn-dr-mntqh-717169. [in Persian].
Turkish Radio and Television Corporation (trt) (March 27, 2015). Erdogan Supported the
Operation of Saudi Arabia. Turkish Radio and Television Corporation (trt). Retrieved in 16
jun 2022. https://www.trt.net.tr/dari/trkhyh/2015/
03/27/rdwgn-mlyt-rbstn-s-wdy-mwrd-hmyh-qrr-dd-284470. [in Persian].
EuroNews (21 May 2017). The King of Saudi Arabia: Iran is the Tip of the Spear of Global
Terrorism. EuroNews. Retrieved in 16 jun 2022. http://fa.euronews.com
/2017/05/21/pe-2105-saudi-king-iran. [in Persian]
Hermann, Margaret G. (2002) Assessing Leadership Style: A Trait Analysis. Cite seer x,
http://citeseerx.ist.psu.edu/viewdoc/download?doi=10.1.1.487.3393&rep=rep1&type=pdf.
Hermann, M. G. (1980). Explaining Foreign Policy Behaviour using the Personal
Characteristics of Political Leaders. International Studies Quarterly, 24(1).
Hermann, M. G. (1987b). Assessing the Foreign Policy Role Orientations of Sub-Saharan
African Leaders. In Walker, S. G. (ed.). Role Theory and Foreign Policy Analysis. Durham,
N.C.: Duke University Press.
Hermann, M.G. (2002). Assessing Leadership Style: A Trait Analysis. Social Science
Automation, Inc. https://socialscience.net/docs/LTA.pdf.
Hermann, M. G. (2010). Assessing Leadership Style: A Trait Analysis. The Psychological
Assessment of Political Leaders. 178-212, University of Michigan Press.
Hermann, C. (1990). Changing Course: When Governments Choose to Redirect Foreign
Policy. International Studies Quarterly, 34(1).
Kaarbo, Juliet, and Hermann & Margaret G. (1998). Leadership Styles of Prime Ministers:
How Individual Differences Affect the Foreign Policymaking Process. Leadership
Quarterly 9, 243- 263.
Otara, Alfred (September 2011). Perception: A Guide for Managers and Leaders. Journal of
Management and Strategy, 2(3), http://sciedu.ca/journal/index.php/
jms/article/viewFile/397/187.
The Guardian (2 May 2017). Iran is Seeking 'to Control Islamic World: Says Saudi Arabian
Prince. The Guardian, https://bit.ly/3h11gif.
BERLIN (Reuters) (APRIL 30, 2020). After U.S., Israeli Pressure, Germany Bans
Hezbollah Activity, Raids Mosques. Reuters, https://reut.rs/39fvECV, (25 Apr 2020).
Otara, Alfred (September 2011). Perception: A Guide for Managers and Leaders. Journal of
Management and Strategy, 2(3), http://sciedu.ca/journal/index.
php/jms/article/viewFile/397/187.
The Guardian (2 May 2017). Iran is Seeking 'to Control Islamic World'. Says Saudi Arabian
Prince. The Guardian, https://bit.ly/3h11gif.
BERLIN (Reuters) (APRIL 30, 2020), After U.S., Israeli Pressure, Germany Bans
Hezbollah Activity, Raids Mosques. Reuters, https://reut.rs/39fvECV, (25 Apr 2020).