analyzing the conflicting interests of turkiye and russia in the south caucasus from a critical geopoliticalperspective:2001-2022

پژوهش ‎های جغرافیای سیاسی

Article 6, Volume 9, Issue 3 - Serial Number 35, October 2024, Pages 123-142   

Document Type: Original Article

DOI: 10.22067/pg.2024.89037.1301

Authors

leila shirali¹; farzad navidinaya^{* 2}; shiva jalalpoor³; feredoun akbarzadah³

¹Ph.D. student of International Relations, Ahvaz Branch, Islamic Azad University, Ahvaz, Iran

²assistant ppoliticalsciencerofessor department of islamic azad university andimshek branch-andimashek

³Assistant Professor, Department of Political Science, Ahvaz Branch, Islamic Azad University, Ahvaz, Iran

Abstract

The South Caucasus is one of the most important geopolitical regions that regional powers, including Turkey and Russia, have over the past two decades. This research seeks to explain the conventionality of Turkey and Russia in the South Caucasus from the perspective of critical geopolitics and proposes the assumption that the conflict between the two countries in the South Caucasus can be explained by moving away from traditional geopolitics in the form of power, space and identity metaphors. This research has investigated this issue with the descriptive-analytical method and the use of critical geopolitical theory. the results of the research indicate that the mentality of the Russian authorities in the South Caucasus is based on the domination of this region for more than two centuries, the need to remain in Moscow's sphere of influence, and the need to keep the West away from it. The discourse of Turkish authorities in the South Caucasus is based on strategic depth, the connecting route to Europe and Central Asia, and balancing. Based on the metaphor of power, Russia and Türkiye consider the South Caucasus as their geopolitical sphere of influence. In the metaphor of space, Russia, by its presence in the lands of Eurasia, of which the Caucasus is also a part, and Turkey, with Ottomanism and civilizational geopolitics, try to manage the region's space for their own benefit. in the metaphor of Russian identity, he sees this region as the arena of "Russian identity" and the presence of Russians. Activism based on moderate Islamism and secularism is also important for Türkiye.

Keywords: critical geopolitics, South Caucasus, conflicting interests, regional powers

Keywords

Critical Geopolitics; South Caucasus; Conflicting Interests; Regional Powers

References

1. Afzali, Rasool and et al, (2013), "Discursive Territorialization in Geopolitics", World Politics Quarterly, Volume 3, Number 4, Winter (In Persian)
2. Afzali, Rasool and et al, (2014), "Elements and components of discourse territorialization in geopolitics", Human Geography Research Quarterly, Volume 47, Number 3, Fall, (In Persian).
3. Anadolu agency, (08/11/2021), Azerbaijan marks 1^st anniversary of victory in patriotic war, available at: https://www.aa.com.tr/en/azerbaijan-front-line/azerbaijan-marks-1st-anniversary-of-victory-in-patriotic-war/241499
4. Dalby, Simon, (2016), "Critical Geopolitics and Security", in Peter Burgess, New Investigations of Security, translated by Alireza Tayeb, Tehran: Amirkabir Publishing, (In Persian).
5. Deshyar, Hossein, (2013), "Russia's foreign policy towards Ukraine: the inevitability of the crisis", Foreign Relations Quarterly, Vol 6, Issue 1, Spring, (In Persian).
6. Doraj, Hamid, (2023), "Turkey's foreign policy in the South Caucasus and its impact on the territory of this country's influence in the region", Quarterly Journal of Geography and Regional Development, Vol 21, no 3, autumn, (In Persian).
7. Dugin, Alexander, (2022), The Fourth Theory of Russian Politics and Political Ideas of the 21st Century, translated by Mahnaz Nowrozi, Tehran: International Center for Peace Studies, (In Persian).
8. Engvall, Johan, (2024), Eurasia: between russia and turkey, available at: https://nationalinterest.org/blog/silk-road-rivalries/eurasia-between-russia-and-turkey-211159.
9. Falahatpisheh, Heshmatollah and et al, (2014), "Turkey's Foreign Policy in the South Caucasus and the Interests of Iran and Russia", Strategic Policy Research Quarterly, Volume 4, Number 12, Spring, (In Persian).
10. Geiger, Julianne, (2024), Europe imports Russian oil products via turkey, skirting sanctions, available at: https://oilprice.com/Latest-Energy-News/World-News/Europe-Imports-Russian-Oil-Products-via-Turkey-Skirting-Sanctions.html.
11. Gotz, Elias, (2022), Near Abroad: Russia’s Role in Post-Soviet Eurasia, Europe – Asia Studies, Vol 74, Issue 9.
12. Gulmohammadi, Vali, (2021), "Turkey-Russia relations in the post-Western world; From geopolitical competition to strategic partnership", quarterly journals of Central Eurasian studies, Vol 14, No 1, spring and summer, (In Persian).
13. Hafeznia, Mohammad Reza, (2005), principles and concepts of geopolitics, Mashhad: Papili Publishing, (In Persian).
14. Hedayati Shahidani, Mehdi and Rezapour, Daniyal, (2016), "The Near Foreign Position in the Security Discourse of the Russian Neo-Eurasians", Central Asia and Caucasus Studies Quarterly, No. 96, Winter, (In Persian).
15. Huasheng, Zhao, (2021), Russia and its Near Abroad: Challenges and Prospects, available at: https://valdaiclub.com/a/highlights/russia-and-its-near-abroad-challenges-and-prospect/
16. Hunter, Shireen and et al, (2021), The New Geopolitics of the South Caucasus: Prospects for Regional Cooperation and Conflict Resolution,Lexington Books Publications.
17. Iskandarian, Alexander, (2023), the south Caucasus between Putin and Erdogan is Russia on its way out?, available at: https://www.ponarseurasia.org/the-south-caucasus-between-putin-and-erdogan-is-russia-on-its-way-out/.
18. Jansiz, Ahmad and Salehian, Tajeddin, (2015), "A new look at the competition between Iran and Turkey in gaining regional power", Quarterly of International Relations Researh, Volume 6, Number 19, Spring, (In Persian).
19. Kakai, Siamak, (2022), "Baku is extravagant; The ominous role of Türkiye and Israel in the Caucasus", available at: http://irdiplomacy.ir/fa/news/2016249/ (In Persian).
20. Kakai, Siamak and Dehghani Firouzabadi, Jalal, (2021), "Turkey's policy in the Karabakh conflict", Central Asia and Caucasus Studies Quarterly, Vol 27, number 115, autumn, (In Persian).
21. Kazemi, Ahmad, (2004), Security in South Caucasus, Tehran: Publication of Abrar Contemporary Research Institute, (In Persian).
22. Kolaee, Elahe and et al, (2015), "Russia's security activism in the South Caucasus", Central Asia and Caucasus Studies Quarterly, No. 95, Fall, (In Persian).
23. Kolaee, Elahe and Hadipour, Maitham, (2019), "Analysis of Russia's foreign policy in the South Caucasus based on Geneva geopolitics", Central Eurasian Studies bi-quarterly, vol 13, no 2, autumn and winter, (In Persian).
24. Kolaee, Elahe and Jokar, Aliakbar, (2019), "The role of Russia's developments with the West in Iran's economic cooperation with South Caucasus countries: 2014-2019", Central Asia and Caucasus Studies Quarterly, No 112, Winter, (In Persian).
25. Kutelia, Batu and Sikharolidze, Vasil, (2021), Strategic connectivity in the Black sea: a focus on Georgia, available at: https://www.fpri.org/article/2021/12/strategic-connectivity-in-the-black-sea-a-focus-on-georgia/
26. Mirhaidar, Dare and Hamidinia, Hossein, (2016), "Comparison of political geography and international relations in terms of methodology and concepts", Geopolitics Quarterly, Vol 2, issue 3, (In Persian).
27. Muir, Richard, (2000), A New Introduction to Political Geography, translated by Mirhaidar Valley, Tehran: Armed Forces Geographical Organization publication, (In Persian).
28. Nouri, Alireza, (2009), "What is the Great Power Thought in Russia's Foreign Policy", Central Asia and Caucasus Quarterly, No. 71, Autumn, (In Persian).
29. Pishgahifard, Zahra and Noorali, Hassan, (2021), "Examining neglected theories in Iran's geopolitical literature", Human Geography Research Quarterly, Volume 53, Number 4, Winter, (In Persian).
30. Rouhi, Mahbobe, (2021), "The effect of individual and structure variables on Turkey's attitude towards Russia; A case study of Justice and Development Party period", Political Studies Quarterly, Volume 13, Number 51, Spring, (In Persian).
31. Sadeghi Aval, Hadi and et al, (2018), "Critical Geopolitics and Analysis of Turkey's Approach to ISIS", Islamic World Political Studies Quarterly, Vol 8, Issue 1, Spring, (In Persian).
32. Shapouri, Mehdi, (2014), Ukraine Crisis: Causes, Consequences and Prospects, Tehran: Strategic Studies Research Institute Publications, (In Persian).
33. The Concept of the Foreign Policy of the Russian Federation, (2023), available at: https://mid.ru/en/foreign_policy/fundamental_documents/1860586/.
34. Turkey Ministry of Foreign Affairs, (2024), Economic Relations between Türkiye and Georgia, available at: https://www.mfa.gov.tr/economic-relations-between-turkiye-and-georgia.en.mfa.