Explaining the necessity of a comprehensive regulation, based on a critical review of internal scientific-research articles (2020-2023)

دانشنامه حقوق اقتصادی

Volume 31, Issue 26, March 2025, Pages 75-101   

Document Type: Scientific research

DOI: 10.22067/economlaw.2024.88472.1375

Authors

Seyed Abed Rezaee¹; Mohammad Vazin Karimian²; Zahra Hadizadeh Esfahani^{* 3}

¹Assistant Professor in Public Administration, Imam Hossein University, Tehran, Iran

²Associate Professor in Judicial Administration, University of Judicial Sciences and Administrative Services, Tehran, Iran

³PhD student in Public Administration in Imam Hussain University

Abstract

1- INTRODUCTION
The importance of regulation has increased over the past 40 years and this has played a key role in economic growth as well as an important part of social progress; Because currently governments tend to interfere less in providing direct services, as a result, regulation has become a large part of their actions. Currently, governments are increasingly using contractual combinations, laws and other regulatory tools to achieve a wide range of social and economic goals.
With the passing of several decades and numerous and various researches, this concept, like other subjects and concepts in the field of human sciences, has undergone changes and transformations; In such a way that all the elements in the previous definition can be questioned and challenged:
Is the intervention in the matter of regulation, only in economic affairs and with the appropriate approach in this field?
Is the government the only regulatory institution?
Are laws and regulations the only regulatory tools and mechanisms?
If the answer to all the above questions is no; In this case, what definition of regulation can be provided that is comprehensive in all its points and types?

2- PURPOSE
The purpose of the current research is to identify the scientific, conceptual, instrumental and institutional scope in the field of regulation and also to evaluate the articles published in this field.

3- METHODOLOGY
In the first step, the theoretical and research literature related to regulation, focusing on: definition, tool, regulatory institution, and also through the lens of different sciences, was carried out in a descriptive-analytical way to get a general outline of the concept of regulatory process. A comprehensive approach should be achieved by considering all its dimensions.
In the next step, scientific-research articles published in recent magazines were studied in recent years to be evaluated according to the results of the first step; This stage was done in the way of critical review by examining 43 articles related to the concept of regulation in the period of 2020-2023.

4- FINDINGS
Evaluation of selected articles showed; Despite the influence of different sciences in the field of regulation, 72% of all articles have benefited from the field of law and 16 articles, i.e. 37% of all articles, have been written with the approach of economics. In 26 articles, i.e. 60% of all articles, regulation is defined as regulation. 29 articles, i.e. 67% of all articles, considered law and regulation as the only regulatory tool. In 37 articles, i.e. 86% of all articles, government institutions are introduced as regulatory bodies.

5- CONCLUSION
Comprehensive regulation means "the process of developing rules and regularizing public behavior"; That is, the cycle that begins with the identification and definition of regulatory standards, in accordance with the goals of governance, based on the principles, institutions and norms of society; And it is implemented by using innovative tools and mechanisms.
As a result, to modify the mechanisms of society administration; Scientific, conceptual, instrumental and institutional transformation in regulation is essential.

Keywords

Comprehensive Regulation; Regulatory Tool; Regulatory Institution; Critical Review

References

[1]Alemanno, Alberto. Spina, Alessandro (2014). Nudging legally: On the checks and balances of behavioral
regulation, International Journal of Constitutional Law, 12 (2), 429–456, https://doi.org/10.1093/icon/mou033
[2] Almond, P., & van Erp, J. (2020). Regulation and governance versus criminology: Disciplinary divides,
intersections, and opportunities. Regulation & Governance, 14(2), 167-183.
[3] Asilyan, L.V & Necrasova, I.E (2023). The essence of state coercion in the mechanism of legal regulation.
SHS Web of Conferences 164(43). 1 – 4. DOI:10.1051/shsconf/202316400092.
[4] Bartle, I., & Vass, P. (2007). Self‐regulation within the regulatory state: Towards a new regulatory
paradigm?. Public Administration, 85(4), 885-905.
[5] Belinskij, A., Iho, A., Paloniitty, T., & Soininen, N. (2019). From top–down regulation to bottom–up solutions: Reconfiguring governance of agricultural nutrient loading to waters. Sustainability, 11(19), 5364.
[6] Boekaerts, M., Zeidner, M., & Pintrich, P. R. (Eds.). (1999). Handbook of self-regulation. Elsevier.
[7] Bora, A. (2014). Rethinking regulation: What governance is all about. Portuguese Journal of Social Science, 13(2), 197-213.
[8] Cohn, M. (2011). 13 Law and regulation: the role, form and choice of legal rules. Handbook on the Politics
of Regulation, 185.
[9] Dal Bo, E. (2006). Regulatory Capture: A Review. Oxford Review of Economic Policy, 22(2), 203–225.
doi:10.1093/oxrep/grj013
[10] Danai Fard, Hassan (2012), Challenges of public administration in Iran, 7th edition, Tehran: University
Humanities Study Organization "Samt".
[11] Farrukh, A., & Sajjad, A. (2023). A Critical Review of Literature Review Methodologies. Advancing
Methodologies of Conducting Literature Review in Management Domain, 2, 103-123.
[12] Ghasem Zadeh Iraqi, Morteza; Khojsteh Bagherzadeh, Hassan and Shah Mohammadi Salmani, Abdolreza
(2021), Presenting the model of governance in online video platforms with an emphasis on the role of
industry (self-regulation), Media and Culture, 11(2), 277-306.
[13] Giddens, Anthony (2003), Sociology, translated by Manouchehr Sabouri, 9th edition, Tehran: Ney
Publishing.
[14] Grabs, J., Auld, G., & Cashore, B. (2020). Private regulation, public policy, and the perils of adverse
ontological selection. Regulation & Governance, 15(4), 1183–1208. doi:10.1111/rego.12354
[15] Guillaume, Biard. (2022). Implementing Regulatory Policy. In the Routledge Handbook of Policy Tools.
Edited by Michael Howlett. 316 -331. doi: 10.4324/9781003163954-31
[16] Gunningham, N., & Holley, C. (2016). Next-generation environmental regulation: law, regulation, and
governance. Annual Review of Law and Social Science, 12(1), 273-293.
[17] Hadavand, Mehdi and Jam, Farhad (2021), "The concept of regulatory government: analysis of regulation
as a governance tool", Strategy Quarterly, 30(99), 228-266.
[18] Heims, E., & Moxon, S. (2024). Mechanisms of regulatory capture: Testing claims of industry influence in
the case of Vioxx. Regulation & Governance, 18(1), 139-157. http://ebookcentral.proquest.com/lib/ubnru-ebooks/
[19] Hughes, O. (2023). "Chapter 2: Governance". In The Crisis of Governance. Cheltenham, UK: Edward Elgar Publishing. Retrieved Jul 14, 2024, from https://doi.org/10.4337/9781839103308.00006
[20] Huising, R., & Silbey, S. S. (2018). From nudge to culture and back again: Coalface governance in the regulated organization. Annual Review of Law and Social Science, 14(1), 91-114.
[21] Karimi Khozani, Ali; Ghafari, Gholamreza and Azizabadi Farahani, Fatemeh (2015), "Ethical challenges
and solutions of the police in managing protest crowds", Journal of Ethics in Science and Technology, 13(1), 9-17.
[22] Katouzian, Nasser (2013), Introduction to the science of law and study in Iran's legal system, 93rd edition,
Tehran: Publishing Company.
[23] Knill, Christoph, and Jale Tosun (2020). Public Policy : A New Introduction, Macmillan Education UK,
ProQuest Ebook Central,
[24] Koop, C., & Lodge, M. (2015). What is regulation? An interdisciplinary concept analysis. Regulation &
Governance, 11(1), 95–108. https://doi:10.1111/rego.12094
[25] Levi-Faur,David. Kariv-Teitelbaum, Yael. Medzini, Rotem. (2021). Regulatory Governance: History,
Theories, Strategies, and Challenges. https://doi:10.1093/ACREFORE/9780190228637.013.1430
[26] Madise, S. (2019). Different Types of Regulation. In: The Regulation of Mobile Money. Palgrave
Macmillan Studies in Banking and Financial Institutions. Palgrave Macmillan, Cham.
https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-13831-8_4
[27] Michael, W., Taylor. (2010). Institutional Structures of Regulation. 473-480. doi: 10.1016/B978-0-12-
397875-2.00026-X
[28] Minogue, M., & Cariño, L. (Eds.). (2008). Regulatory governance in developing countries. Edward Elgar
Publishing.
[29] Motahari, Morteza (2009), the collection of works of Master Shahid Motahari, 13th edition, Tehran: Sadra
Publishing House.
[30] Nobahar, Rahim and Shahbeigi, Iman (2020), "The evolution of the paradigm of punishment to regulation
in the light of the theory of responsive regulation", Criminal Law and Criminology Studies, 50(2), -539
515.
[31] Pan, J., Shao, Z., & Xu, Y. (2022). How government-controlled media shifts policy attitudes through
framing. Political Science Research and Methods, 10(2), 317-332.
[32] Potoski, M., & Prakash, A. (2002). Protecting the environment: voluntary regulations in environmental
governance. Policy Currents, 11(4), 9-14.
[33] Rajendran, R., Din, R., & Othman, N. (2023). A Critical Review on Using Canva as a Visual Media
Platform for English Language Learning. Social Sciences, 13(6), 631-641.
[34] Rasekh, Mohammad and Hosseini Karaei, Siddmojtaba (2014), "The Concept of Regulation in the Realm
of Law", Encyclopedia of Economic Law Journal, 22(8), 39-23.
[35] Scott, Alister. Baker, Jonathan. (2013). Regulatory tools: a literature review. Available at
http://neat.ecosystemsknowledge.net/pdfs/regulatory_tools_literature_review_full.pdf.
[36] Scott, Colin (2012). Regulating Everything: From Mega- to Meta-regulation. Administration, 60:57-85.
[37] Shabani, Qasim (2013), Fundamental Rights and Government Structure of the Islamic Republic of Iran,
51st edition, Tehran: Information Publications.
[38] Shams, Irfan (2022), Epidemic and Regulating Government, Legal Research Quarterly, 25(1002), -478
461.
[39] Shirazi, Hossein (2019), regulation instead of ownership in policy-making; A case study: the model of
interaction between the institution of public libraries and the library department of Tehran municipality,
Dolat Pazhuhi Quarterly, 5(20), 35-1.
[40] Shirazi, Hossein (2021), policy making to change behavior in order to empower citizens; A necessary
approach in order to realize the government's macro-goals, Scientific Quarterly of Government Research, 6
(27), 31-59.
[41] Tahmasbi, Reza (2016), An introduction to the theories of public administration, 7th edition, Tehran:
University Humanities Study Organization "Samt".
[42] Valizadeh (2019). Analysis of regulation, privatization in Iran. Kanon Yar, 12(3), 298-255.
[43] Vestoso, Margherita. Cecere, Ilaria. (2022). Norm vs Norm: A behavioural and agent-based study of the
interaction between formal and informal rules. Sociologia del diritto, 153-172. https://doi:10.3280/sd2022-
001007
[44] Windholz, E. (2022). Implementing Regulatory Policy: Regulatory Tools and the Use of Authority. In The
Routledge Handbook of Policy Tools (pp. 316-331). Routledge.
[45] Windholz, Eric and Hodge, Graeme (2012). Conceptualising Social and Economic Regulation: Implications
for Modern Regulators and Regulatory Activity. Monash University Law Review, 38 (2), 212- 237.,
Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=2215334
[46] Wirtz, B. W., Weyerer, J. C., & Sturm, B. J. (2020). The Dark Sides of Artificial Intelligence:
An Integrated AI Governance Framework for Public Administration. International Journal of
Public Administration, 1–12. doi:10.1080/01900692.2020.1749851
[47] Yasuda, J. (2016). Regulatory governance. In Handbook on theories of governance (pp. 428-
441). Edward Elgar Publishing.
[48] Yasuda, J. (2022). "Chapter 41: Regulatory governance". In Handbook on Theories of
Governance. Cheltenham, UK: Edward Elgar Publishing. Retrieved Mar 16, 2024, from
https://doi.org/10.4337/9781800371972.00051
[49] Yavari, Asadullah. (2014). Understanding the concept of legal regulation. Comparative law
studies. 5(2). 647-629.
[50] Zwitter, A. (2024). Cybernetic governance: implications of technology convergence on
governance convergence. Ethics and Information Technology, 26(2), 1-13.